Skip to contentSkip to conversation

GCC-4.6.0 not ready for prime time?

DISCUSSION Gary Thomas 2 participants 2 messages Jun 9, 2011

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I'm not convinced switching to GCC-4.6.0 is a good choice at this time. Not only did I have problems getting a working kernel, there are a lot of applications that don't build with this new compiler. Some of those that do, don't work :-(

I have a local recipe to build Mozilla FireFox which has been working fine, but with GCC-4.6.0, it no longer runs correctly. Given the magnitude of FireFox, it may take me a while to figure out why.

Even some core programs no longer build, e.g. web-webkit (I was looking for an alternate web browser). This was probably not obvious as it is no longer being built by your test images (it used to be included in core-image-sato but was dropped by 9d7aa1090c407ac0da6154c481f1c787fd7efbfc)

I guess I'll be sticking with GCC-4.5.x for now

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
#1 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Gary Thomas

I'm not convinced switching to GCC-4.6.0 is a good choice at this time.

at some point we have to and we have time to harden it until next release. Compiler upgrades are a bit of work

Quoted 7 lines

Not only did I have problems getting a working kernel, there are a lot of applications that don't build with this new compiler. Some of those that do, don't work :-(

I have a local recipe to build Mozilla FireFox which has been working fine, but with GCC-4.6.0, it no longer runs correctly. Given the magnitude of FireFox, it may take me a while to figure out why.

yes there are always some issues that need resolving. If you are able to narrow down the problem a bit it would be easier to pin point the problem.

Quoted 9 lines

Even some core programs no longer build, e.g. web-webkit (I was looking for an alternate web browser). This was probably not obvious as it is no longer being built by your test images (it used to be included in core-image-sato but was dropped by 9d7aa1090c407ac0da6154c481f1c787fd7efbfc)

I guess I'll be sticking with GCC-4.5.x for now

For something that you would like to release soon it may be a sane choice

-Khem