Skip to contentSkip to conversation

shallow&single-branch clone?

DISCUSSION Norbert Nemec 2 participants 2 messages Jun 15, 2016

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi there,

it seems like there is no way to clone a single branch with truncated history.

Truncating history is done by 'git clone --depth 1', there is not way to restrict 'clone' to a single branch (the --branch option still downloads all branches and only then chooses something other than HEAD as active branch).

The manual sequence
git init
git remote add -t master -f origin URL
git checkout
allows a clone of a single branch but offers no means to truncate history.

The least intrusive solution would be an additional option to clone, perhaps '--branch-only'.

More user friendly, this options should be on by default when --depth is set. After all: who would expect branches to be cloned when the history is explicitely truncated?

Ideas?

Greetings,
Norbert Nemec

#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Norbert Nemec

Truncating history is done by 'git clone --depth 1', there is not way to restrict 'clone' to a single branch (the --branch option still downloads all branches and only then chooses something other than HEAD as active branch).

The manual sequence
git init
git remote add -t master -f origin URL
git checkout
allows a clone of a single branch but offers no means to truncate history.

You can do:

git init
git remote add -t master origin URL
git fetch --depth=1
git checkout

But obviously that's not as nice as an option to clone.

Quoted 2 lines

The least intrusive solution would be an additional option to clone, perhaps '--branch-only'.

Agreed, that would be better. We might want to make it more flexible, like:

  git clone --fetch=branch1 --fetch=branch2

and then by default choose "-b branch1" since it was mentioned first.

Quoted 3 lines

More user friendly, this options should be on by default when --depth is set. After all: who would expect branches to be cloned when the history is explicitely truncated?

Yeah, that probably makes sense. If the branches are related, it's probably not saving much, but if you have unrelated branches, it would be a nice convenience. OTOH, how would you tell git "no, I really do want the tip of every branch"?

-Peff