Question about error from xhci-hcd
I apologize but I am having the same issue reported in this thread in December
[ 5077.573181] xhci_hcd 0000:0a:00.0: ERROR no room on ep ring
I saw no resolution on this issue so I figured I'd step up and see if you needed an active tester who could reproduce the issue.
I am running Gentoo with a 3.2.2 kernel. I am able to run any kernel version you need, including random git trees and custom patches. If you have not solved this yet, please allow me to be your test monkey. If you have solved this already then sorry for harming the signal to noise ratio, I could not a find a later message then the one below.
Thanks,
Rick
Quoted 11 lines · Andiry Xu
That's the error I want to see, but I didn't find it in the dmesg you posted. is it wrapped?
Anyway, please post the full dmesg with no room on ring error and the dump of the ep ring and event ring (so the
xhci_debug_ring()is triggered in the patch), so we can see if the ring is mangled or there is just too many transfers.Another thing you can try is the andiry-ring-expansion branch on Sarah's xhci git tree, check if there is still no room on ring error.
No, the ring is not wrapped. I seems that my anti-spam mechanism kicked in too
soon. or the run stopped too soon.
I'll have the OP do another run and see if we can get the right information.
Larry
--
Quoted 5 lines · Richard Farina
I apologize but I am having the same issue reported in this thread in December
[ 5077.573181] xhci_hcd 0000:0a:00.0: ERROR no room on ep ring
Quoted 9 lines
I saw no resolution on this issue so I figured I'd step up and see if you needed an active tester who could reproduce the issue.
I am running Gentoo with a 3.2.2 kernel. I am able to run any kernel version you need, including random git trees and custom patches. If you have not solved this yet, please allow me to be your test monkey. If you have solved this already then sorry for harming the signal to noise ratio, I could not a find a later message then the one below.
You can try andiry-ring-expansion branch on Sarah's xhci git tree. It contains bugs and I'm trying to fix that, but you can have a try.
Thanks,
Andiry
Quoted 25 lines · Andiry Xu
Quoted 11 lines
That's the error I want to see, but I didn't find it in the dmesg you posted. is it wrapped?
Anyway, please post the full dmesg with no room on ring error and the dump of the ep ring and event ring (so the
xhci_debug_ring()is triggered in the patch), so we can see if the ring is mangled or there is just too many transfers.Another thing you can try is the andiry-ring-expansion branch on Sarah's xhci git tree, check if there is still no room on ring error.
No, the ring is not wrapped. I seems that my anti-spam mechanism kicked in too
soon. or the run stopped too soon.I'll have the OP do another run and see if we can get the right information.
Larry
--
Quoted 5 lines · Richard Farina
I apologize but I am having the same issue reported in this thread in December
[ 5077.573181] xhci_hcd 0000:0a:00.0: ERROR no room on ep ring
Quoted 8 lines
I saw no resolution on this issue so I figured I'd step up and see if you needed an active tester who could reproduce the issue.
I am running Gentoo with a 3.2.2 kernel. I am able to run any kernel version you need, including random git trees and custom patches. If you have not solved this yet, please allow me to be your test monkey. If you have solved this already then sorry for harming the signal to noise ratio, I could not a find a later message then the one below.
Are the "no room" messages triggered by rtl8192cu, or some other driver?
Larry
Quoted 9 lines · Larry Finger
Quoted 8 lines · Richard Farina
I apologize but I am having the same issue reported in this thread in December
[ 5077.573181] xhci_hcd 0000:0a:00.0: ERROR no room on ep ringI saw no resolution on this issue so I figured I'd step up and see if you needed an active tester who could reproduce the issue.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I am running Gentoo with a 3.2.2 kernel. I am able to run any kernel version you need, including random git trees and custom patches. If you have not solved this yet, please allow me to be your test monkey. If you have solved this already then sorry for harming the signal to noise ratio, I could not a find a later message then the one below.
Are the "no room" messages triggered by rtl8192cu, or some other driver?
They can be caused by any USB driver that attempts to queue large transfers or many small transfers.
Sarah Sharp
Quoted 3 lines · Sarah Sharp
They can be caused by any USB driver that attempts to queue large transfers or many small transfers.
At least two of the drivers that I maintain, or have had some part of the development, have this problem; however, I do not have the hardware to replicate it. I am ready to help in any way I can.
Is the ringfull patch that Andiry sent still useful? I know that it applies. If it would be worthwhile, I'll send it on to Richard.
Thanks,
Larry
Quoted 9 lines · Larry Finger
Quoted 8 lines · Richard Farina
I apologize but I am having the same issue reported in this thread in December
[ 5077.573181] xhci_hcd 0000:0a:00.0: ERROR no room on ep ringI saw no resolution on this issue so I figured I'd step up and see if you needed an active tester who could reproduce the issue.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I am running Gentoo with a 3.2.2 kernel. I am able to run any kernel version you need, including random git trees and custom patches. If you have not solved this yet, please allow me to be your test monkey. If you have solved this already then sorry for harming the signal to noise ratio, I could not a find a later message then the one below.
Are the "no room" messages triggered by rtl8192cu, or some other driver?
rtl8187 and rt2800usb both seem to reliably trigger that message on my system. And when I say reliably I mean by the time I noticed I had a 1.5GB /var/log/messages. Fortunately I have several usb2 ports in addition to the affected usb3 ports. :-)
-Rick
Quoted 4 lines
Larry