question about splice
Hi all,
I used splice and found a prolem(at least i call).
The demo is:
A:splice(regularfileA--->pipe);
B:splice(pipe--->regularfileB)
Before do B, we modify the data of regA which now in pipe. The data to regularfileB willbe change. If we used the buff
A:read(regA, buff);
B: write(buff, regB);
After A, the contend of regA can't effect the buff.
Review the code of splice,I know the pipe share the pagecache of regA.
Maybe this is not a problem or am i missing something?
Thanks!
Jianpeng Ma
Hi Jianpeng,
Quoted 11 lines · majianpeng
Hi all,
I used splice and found a prolem(at least i call).
The demo is:
A:splice(regularfileA--->pipe);
B:splice(pipe--->regularfileB)
Before do B, we modify the data of regA which now in pipe. The data to regularfileB willbe change. If we used the buff
A:read(regA, buff);
B:write(buff, regB);
After A, the contend of regA can't effect the buff.
Review the code of splice,I know the pipe share the pagecache of regA.
Right. And also this is the splice's original design intention, using share mmap rather than copy_to_user/copy_from_user in order to achieve zero-copy.
Thanks,
Gu
Quoted 5 lines
Maybe this is not a problem or am i missing something?
Thanks!
Jianpeng MaN嫥叉靣笡y氊b瞂千v豝�)藓{.n�+壏{睉赙zXФ洝塄}财爖�&j:+v墾�珣赙zZ+€�+zf"穐殘啳嗃i�z�畐ア�?櫒璀�&�)撷f旟^j谦y呩@A玜囤�0鹅h�鍜i
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-fsdevel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Quoted 16 lines
Hi Jianpeng,
Quoted 11 lines · majianpeng
Hi all,
I used splice and found a prolem(at least i call).
The demo is:
A:splice(regularfileA--->pipe);
B:splice(pipe--->regularfileB)
Before do B, we modify the data of regA which now in pipe. The data to regularfileB willbe change. If we used the buff
A:read(regA, buff);
B:write(buff, regB);
After A, the contend of regA can't effect the buff.
Review the code of splice,I know the pipe share the pagecache of regA.
Quoted 3 lines
Right. And also this is the splice's original design intention, using share mmap rather than copy_to_user/copy_from_user in order to achieve zero-copy.
If it use some method like COW, i think it can avoid this problem.
Quoted 11 lines
Thanks,
GuQuoted 5 lines
Maybe this is not a problem or am i missing something?
Thanks!
Jianpeng MaN嫥叉靣笡y氊b瞂千v豝?)藓{.n?+壏{睉赙zXФ洝塄}财爖?&j:+v墾?珣赙zZ+€?+zf"穐殘啳嗃i?z?畐ア??櫒璀?&?)撷f旟^j谦y呩@A玜囤?0鹅h?鍜i
Thanks!
Jianpeng Ma
Quoted 30 lines
Hi Jianpeng,
Quoted 11 lines · majianpeng
Hi all,
I used splice and found a prolem(at least i call).
The demo is:
A:splice(regularfileA--->pipe);
B:splice(pipe--->regularfileB)
Before do B, we modify the data of regA which now in pipe. The data to regularfileB willbe change. If we used the buff
A:read(regA, buff);
B:write(buff, regB);
After A, the contend of regA can't effect the buff.
Review the code of splice,I know the pipe share the pagecache of regA.Right. And also this is the splice's original design intention, using share mmap rather than copy_to_user/copy_from_user in order to achieve zero-copy.
Thanks,
GuQuoted 5 lines
Maybe this is not a problem or am i missing something?
Thanks!
Jianpeng MaN嫥叉靣笡y氊b瞂千v豝?)藓{.n?+壏{睉赙zXФ洝塄}财爖?&j:+v墾?珣赙zZ+€?+zf"穐殘啳嗃i?z?畐ア??櫒璀?&?)撷f旟^j谦y呩@A玜囤?0鹅h?鍜i