Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?

DISCUSSION ChaosEsque Team 4 participants 6 messages Feb 14, 2014 – Feb 18, 2014

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?

The systemd fans ban anyone who say f__k-that to systemd.

What can we do?
Can we fork debian? (Why do we have to...)
Why do 4 people get to decide to send thousands and thousands of people into the systemd waters? This is not fair.

This is not-pro choice. And YES, linux, and especially debian IS about choice. No matter what redhat and lennart fans say.

Is there any way to kick the systemd fans out of debian development before they kick out all the alternative init systems?

They have stated many times that they want the sys-v scripts to become unmaintained and to be removed. They need to be kicked the hell out of debian before they make their change unrecoverable.

Everyone knows that the systemd crap is armtwisting and trys to pull everyone and everything along with it. We wouldn't be having these discussions if that were not so.

Our simple desire to continue using what we know is derided by systemd fans, even alternative kernels like kFreeBSD are suggested to be removed by systemd fans for the benifit of systemd.

They basically say "hahhahah we will make sure sys-v is unusable in the future, hahhahhaha systemd wins". It is a competition to them, and there must be winners and losers.

4 people should not be able to control the distro that thousands develop for and use. Nor should 500 people either. We should have choice, but the systemd people will not allow it. They constantly argue and berate others who prefer something other than systemd, they constantanly point out the systemd way to do whatever, they are constantly evangelizing systemd.

Not using systemd is never an option to them, unless you leave debain and or use a non-linux operating system.

There has to be some way out of this. There has to be some way to fight them. To retain choice, to oppose bloat, atleast on our own systems. TO NOT HAVE TO DO EVERYTHING FROM SCRATCH.

We should not be forced or moved to leave debain by these new systemd people. We should not accept being told "if you don't like systemd, do everything yourself, sucker"

The sys-v scripts are their, they work, when a systemd fan tells us they will be removed, or cease working (they're made of wood remember) that systemd fan should be removed from debian development for a time.

Fire needs to be fought with fire.
The systemd people ban those who speak against sytemd in anything they control (chat server, forums, lists) They deride all users of other systems.
They proclaim constanty the death of every other init system. They tell us that our scripts will break and be unsupported. They are triumphalist against us.

A simple, clean, unixlike option needs to be maintained. In debian. In linux.
It exists today. The systemd people should not be permitted to tear it down. They should not be allowed to take away what we have and replace it in whole cloth with their new order of things.

Quoted 6 lines

(An aside:)
(Lennart at some point announced that udev will no longer work without systemd. He is such a scumbag.

Linus told him specifically not to do this. Lennart thinks he is a god and is dragging us all with him.)

#1 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · ChaosEsque Team

Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?

The systemd fans ban anyone who say f__k-that to systemd.

What can we do?
Can we fork debian? (Why do we have to...)
Why do 4 people get to decide to send thousands and thousands of people into the systemd waters? This is not fair.

This is not-pro choice. And YES, linux, and especially debian IS about choice.

I don't know if you're trolling for a useless discussion or this is really your opinion but if it were, I have to say that I agree with you about the choice aspect. I don't like that systemd-or-die XOR-morality either.

I'm sure systemd might have its merits and all but I think, too, people should have a choice on any distro.

Just my 2c.

Signature · 5 lines
Regards/Gruss,
    Boris.

Sent from a fat crate under my desk. Formatting is fine.
--
#2 lore raw

I much prefer simpler forms over complex forms.
SysV is that vs systemd.

The systemd people have pushed hard for exclusive systemd in debian. And everywhere else for that matter.

I really would like to have the option, forever, to continue using sysv scripts, just like we've been doing since linux came into existance and since debian came into the world. I do not like how systemd works, I just don't want to use it. I don't like how it takes over everything.

I do like debian, it has always been about choice. But now the systemd people are taking that choice away.

They are always threatening us that sysv scripts _will_ "bit rot" away (they're wooden?, no they exist now and work fine, and will continue to work fine).

I wish someone could weigh in and defang the systemd and pottering people. They are steamrolling over all of us, they seem to take pleasure in the fact that we will have to relearn everything and on their terms. It is domination of the mind.

They also have zero respect for anyone else. Zero respect for people that like the unix way. Zero respect for those older than them and Zero respect for those working in the field.

Could linus perhaps atleast delegate udev away from pottering and friends? And maybe make a statement that linux is NOT systemd, there is no new "linux software stack" that pottering and friends keep insisting on.

This situation is coming to a head. We need leadership against this landgrab of the systemd people.

--------------------------------------------
On Fri, 2/14/14, Borislav Petkov <[email protected]> wrote:

Subject: Re: Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?
To: "ChaosEsque Team" <[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]
Date: Friday, February 14, 2014, 6:27 AM

Quoted 1 line · ChaosEsque Team

Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the

fans of them.

Quoted 3 lines

Where's linus in all of this?

The systemd fans ban anyone who say f__k-that to

systemd.

Quoted 4 lines

What can we do?
Can we fork debian? (Why do we have to...) Why do 4 people get to decide to send thousands and

thousands of people into the systemd waters?

Quoted 3 lines

This is not fair.

This is not-pro choice. And YES, linux, and especially

debian IS about choice.

I don't know if you're trolling for a useless discussion or this is
really your opinion but if it were, I have to say that I agree with you
about the choice aspect. I don't like that systemd-or-die XOR-morality
either.

I'm sure systemd might have its merits and all but I think, too, people
should have a choice on any distro.

Just my 2c.

--
Regards/Gruss,
    Boris.

Sent from a fat crate under my desk. Formatting is fine. --

#3 lore raw
Quoted 73 lines · ChaosEsque Team

I much prefer simpler forms over complex forms.
SysV is that vs systemd.

The systemd people have pushed hard for exclusive systemd in debian. And everywhere else for that matter.

I really would like to have the option, forever, to continue using sysv scripts, just like we've been doing since linux came into existance and since debian came into the world. I do not like how systemd works, I just don't want to use it. I don't like how it takes over everything.

I do like debian, it has always been about choice. But now the systemd people are taking that choice away.

They are always threatening us that sysv scripts _will_ "bit rot" away (they're wooden?, no they exist now and work fine, and will continue to work fine).

I wish someone could weigh in and defang the systemd and pottering people. They are steamrolling over all of us, they seem to take pleasure in the fact that we will have to relearn everything and on their terms. It is domination of the mind.

They also have zero respect for anyone else. Zero respect for people that like the unix way. Zero respect for those older than them and Zero respect for those working in the field.

Could linus perhaps atleast delegate udev away from pottering and friends? And maybe make a statement that linux is NOT systemd, there is no new "linux software stack" that pottering and friends keep insisting on.

This situation is coming to a head. We need leadership against this landgrab of the systemd people.

--------------------------------------------
On Fri, 2/14/14, Borislav Petkov <[email protected]> wrote:

Subject: Re: Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?
To: "ChaosEsque Team" <[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]
Date: Friday, February 14, 2014, 6:27 AM

Quoted 1 line · ChaosEsque Team

Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the

fans of them.

Quoted 3 lines

Where's linus in all of this?

The systemd fans ban anyone who say f__k-that to

systemd.

Quoted 4 lines

What can we do?
Can we fork debian? (Why do we have to...) Why do 4 people get to decide to send thousands and

thousands of people into the systemd waters?

Quoted 3 lines

This is not fair.

This is not-pro choice. And YES, linux, and especially

debian IS about choice.

I don't know if you're trolling for a useless discussion or this is
really your opinion but if it were, I have to say that I agree with you
about the choice aspect. I don't like that systemd-or-die XOR-morality
either.

I'm sure systemd might have its merits and all but I think, too, people
should have a choice on any distro.

Quoted 8 lines

Just my 2c.

--
Regards/Gruss,
Boris.

Sent from a fat crate under my desk. Formatting is fine. --

I wholeheartedly second this, systemd is way too monolithic. What ever happened to the traditional *nix philosophy of writing a program that did one thing, and did it really well. If i wanted to be forced lack of choice, I'd be using OS X or Windows, not Linux. This is actually one of the primary reasons I refuse to use Debian or Ubuntu anymore. Even worse, I've heard rumblings of plans to integrate D-Bus into systemd, although that's likely to result in somebody forking D-Bus.

#4 lore raw
In reply to ChaosEsque Team
Quoted 2 lines

And maybe make a statement that linux is NOT systemd, there is no new "linux software stack" that pottering and friends keep insisting on.

The largest Linux user is Android, which I don't think uses systemd. The kernel does not care. You can use emacs as your init for all the kernel cares and handle all your udev messages in emacs lisp.

The kernel does not care. Indeed if the kernel did care about whether someone used systemd, forked Debian or wanted to run emacs lisp as their init then it would mean the architecture was wrong.

It's simply not the kernel's problem what people run as init and if Debian wishes to divide into two distributions (Deb and Ian perhaps...) then this is the wrong list for that debate.

Alan

#5 lore raw

It sounds as if you have not heard the good news:
systemd.

Or you have not digested it enough:
systemd.

SystemD is touted as a new required "software stack" for linux according to Pottering (who is a douchbag that should be kept away from computers and other people's presentations) and his followers.

Gnome is requiring it, along with breaking compatability in libgtk (eventhough libgtk is the GIMP's library, gnome folks have decided to take it over)

SystemD and gnome are embracing and extending everything. They are extinguishing unix-like linux on the ground.

Their fans/employees/agents try to get systemd adopted exclusively in every distro. To force everyone into compliance. They are constantly constantly evangelizing systemd. Anyone who opposes them is a troll and they have them banned.

They say if you don't like systemd etc, use mac or switch to bsd. This included the debian-devs.

Lennart Pottering is the scumbag that is spearheading this. Redhat is the company.

Fuck SystemD

--------------------------------------------
On Mon, 2/17/14, One Thousand Gnomes <[email protected]> wrote:

Subject: Re: Honestly, f__k systemd and f__k lennart, and f__k the fans of them. Where's linus in all of this?
To: "ChaosEsque Team" <[email protected]>
Cc: "Borislav Petkov" <[email protected]>, [email protected]
Date: Monday, February 17, 2014, 7:22 AM

Quoted 1 line

And maybe make a statement that

linux is NOT systemd, there is no

Quoted 1 line

new "linux software stack" that pottering and friends

keep insisting on.

The largest Linux user is Android, which I don't think uses systemd. The
kernel does not care. You can use emacs as your init for all the kernel
cares and handle all your udev messages in emacs lisp.

The kernel does not care. Indeed if the kernel did care about whether
someone used systemd, forked Debian or wanted to run emacs lisp as their
init then it would mean the architecture was wrong.

It's simply not the kernel's problem what people run as init and if
Debian wishes to divide into two distributions (Deb and Ian perhaps...)
then this is the wrong list for that debate.

Alan