Skip to contentSkip to conversation

testing mlmmj using Sendmail on a CentOS server

mlmmj [email protected] 3 participants 13 messages Oct 8, 2014 – Oct 19, 2014

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I looked through the documentation, and installed mlmmj per the readme and install documents on a virtual CentOS server.

I have created a test email list - [email protected] - and added 2 subscribers using mlmmj-sub. All appears to be setup properly, but when I send an email to the list using one of the subscribed addresses ([email protected]), my mail log file shows the following:

Oct  7 23:14:21 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: from=<[email protected]>, size=1250, class=0, nrcpts=1, msgid=<[email protected]>, proto=ESMTP, daemon=MSA, relay=c-24-22-61-28.hsd1.or.comcast.net [24.22.61.28]
Oct  7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: Milter insert (1): header: DKIM-Signature:  v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=simple/simple; d=vlsc.org; s=default;\n\tt=1412723662; bh=SrfRFSC5LbQjGOAy8L6/MImtgtMNuon//Nkbtb0XVZI=;\n\th=Date:From:To:Subject;\n\tb=oKK6sefKYUbo7sC8oIAK0bnVA92vas8lkpOYQsVd//ru+cu5Eyg13wGRlZ+vyAUH2\n\t ko/f+ma6dQdizl1mVIq35h62m1tS+THd8LMZtadOFT1kiyG2HHyasmiqK1UuVjCbxO\n\t 6RfbPTriyZKsXnZfDK4y4pcoAqRextw+ZdKOrDU8=
Oct  7 23:14:22 cloud opendkim[771]: s97NEL7Z001390: DKIM-Signature field added (s=default, d=vlsc.org)
Oct  7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1392]: s97NEL7Z001390: to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]>  (8/0), delay=00:00:01, xdelay=00:00:00, mailer=*file*, pri=31824, dsn=2.0.0, stat=Sent

The entry "to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]>" seems suspicious, like the email is being dumped to /dev/null instead of being delivered to the list.

Can anyone help me by letting me know if I've missed some piece in my setup, or at least how to interpret this log entry correctly?

I'm a refugee from majordomo who is trying to get our new server running with mlmmj so our organization can continue to run several small in-house email lists.

Thanks for any help!

Philip

#1 lore raw
Quoted 23 lines · On 08-Oct-14 7:00 PM, [email protected] wrote:

I looked through the documentation, and installed mlmmj per the readme and install documents on a virtual CentOS server.

I have created a test email list - [email protected] - and added 2 subscribers using mlmmj-sub. All appears to be setup properly, but when I send an email to the list using one of the subscribed addresses ([email protected]), my mail log file shows the following:

Oct 7 23:14:21 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: from=<[email protected]>, size50, class=0, nrcpts=1, msgid=<[email protected]>, proto=ESMTP, daemon=MSA, relay=c-24-22-61-28.hsd1.or.comcast.net [24.22.61.28]

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: Milter insert (1): header: DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=simple/simple; d=vlsc.org; sÞfault;\n\tt12723662; bh=SrfRFSC5LbQjGOAy8L6/MImtgtMNuon//Nkbtb0XVZI=;\n\thÚte:From:To:Subject;\n\tb=oKK6sefKYUbo7sC8oIAK0bnVA92vas8lkpOYQsVd//ru+cu5Eyg13wGRlZ+vyAUH2\n\t ko/f+ma6dQdizl1mVIq35h62m1tS+THd8LMZtadOFT1kiyG2HHyasmiqK1UuVjCbxO\n\t 6RfbPTriyZKsXnZfDK4y4pcoAqRextw+ZdKOrDU8>
Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud opendkim[771]: s97NEL7Z001390: DKIM-Signature field added (sÞfault, d=vlsc.org)

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1392]: s97NEL7Z001390: to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]> (8/0), delay:00:01, xdelay:00:00, mailer=*file*, pri1824, dsn=2.0.0, stat=Sent

The entry "to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]>" seems suspicious, like the email is being dumped to /dev/null instead of being delivered to the list.

Can anyone help me by letting me know if I've missed some piece in my setup, or at least how to interpret this log entry correctly?

Quoted 7 lines

I'm a refugee from majordomo who is trying to get our new server running with mlmmj so our organization can continue to run several small in-house email lists.

Thanks for any help!

Philip

Hi Philip!
Did you come right with this? If so, please tell me how!

I tried this some years ago in a home / test environment (using OpenSUSE) before rolling out to a small production LAN - and failed miserably! The only documentation I found was from mlmmj. Asked the mlmmj list and still did not come right. Perhaps I was misunderstanding something on the sendmail side of things.

I toyed with the idea of switching to postfix, but have some custom rules in sendmail so did not want to take on a new learning curve for what was essentially a functionality for which the users were not clamouring at that time.

Regards,
Geoff

#2 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Hi Geof!

Thanks for your note.

I have not heard any response, except an automated note - some list member's original email address is no longer valid.

I'm still attempting to chase down the proper configuration to get mlmmj running with Sendmail as the MTA. I too, considered using Postfix, but Sendmail is already running, and don't want to try with Postfix if it's not required.

I've begun the slow process of reading through the list archives, but haven't found anything that helps me yet.

When you tried asking the list previously, did you receive any responses? If so, can you recall more specifically when that might have been? - I'd like to go back and see any feedback you might have received, even if it wasn't enough to help you solve this. Perhaps a 2nd pair of eyes on the same feedback, combined with what I'm seeing on my server, might somehow reveal the trick.

Is there anyone still doing development/support for mlmmj?

I've spend years working with and configuring servers, including customizing automated processes that work in the background with majordomo lists. Unfortunately majordomo hasn't been supported in years and is quickly becoming unusable in today's server/mail environments.

I would love to find a new mailing list tool to work with, and mlmmj seems like a great candidate, but I need some help getting out of the starting blocks with configuring this on a CentOS LAMP server environment running Sendmail - a very common platform.

Unless I've completely missed something obvious, the documentation on the mlmmj website doesn't speak to running with Sendmail, except when trying to use VERP (using VERP isn't a requirement for configuring mlmmj to work with Sendmail, is it?)

I'm not even sure that my issue is related Sendmail, but I can't find any documentation that can tell me either way.

Any help that can be provided would be greatly appreciated!!!

Philip

Quoted 52 lines · G Stansfield
Quoted 25 lines · On 08-Oct-14 7:00 PM, [email protected] wrote:

I looked through the documentation, and installed mlmmj per the readme and install documents on a virtual CentOS server.

I have created a test email list - [email protected] - and added 2 subscribers using mlmmj-sub. All appears to be setup properly, but when I send an email to the list using one of the subscribed addresses ([email protected]), my mail log file shows the following:

Oct 7 23:14:21 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: from=<[email protected]>, size=1250, class=0, nrcpts=1, msgid=<[email protected]>, proto=ESMTP, daemon=MSA, relay=c-24-22-61-28.hsd1.or.comcast.net [24.22.61.28]

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: Milter insert (1): header: DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=simple/simple; d=vlsc.org; s=default;\n\tt=1412723662; bh=SrfRFSC5LbQjGOAy8L6/MImtgtMNuon//Nkbtb0XVZI=;\n\th=Date:From:To:Subject;\n\tb=oKK6sefKYUbo7sC8oIAK0bnVA92vas8lkpOYQsVd//ru+cu5Eyg13wGRlZ+vyAUH2\n\t ko/f+ma6dQdizl1mVIq35h62m1tS+THd8LMZtadOFT1kiyG2HHyasmiqK1UuVjCbxO\n\t 6RfbPTriyZKsXnZfDK4y4pcoAqRextw+ZdKOrDU8=

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud opendkim[771]: s97NEL7Z001390: DKIM-Signature field added (s=default, d=vlsc.org)

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1392]: s97NEL7Z001390: to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]> (8/0), delay=00:00:01, xdelay=00:00:00, mailer=*file*, pri=31824, dsn=2.0.0, stat=Sent

The entry "to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]>" seems suspicious, like the email is being dumped to /dev/null instead of being delivered to the list.

Can anyone help me by letting me know if I've missed some piece in my setup, or at least how to interpret this log entry correctly?

Quoted 7 lines

I'm a refugee from majordomo who is trying to get our new server running with mlmmj so our organization can continue to run several small in-house email lists.

Thanks for any help!

Philip

Hi Philip!
Did you come right with this? If so, please tell me how!

I tried this some years ago in a home / test environment (using OpenSUSE) before rolling out to a small production LAN - and failed miserably! The only documentation I found was from mlmmj. Asked the mlmmj list and still did not come right. Perhaps I was misunderstanding something on the sendmail side of things.

I toyed with the idea of switching to postfix, but have some custom rules in sendmail so did not want to take on a new learning curve for what was essentially a functionality for which the users were not clamouring at that time.

Regards,
Geoff

-----
No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4765 / Virus Database: 4040/8384 - Release Date: 10/13/14

#3 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Hi, Philip,

Yes, we are definitely still here! Development has slowed a bit recently, but not stopped, and the mailing list is small, but friendly; we help when we can.

Looks like not many people know how to configure Sendmail. I toyed with it many years ago, and can remember nothing.

Perhaps if you send some configuration snippets we will have a better chance helping.

It seems to me like the mail is never even getting to Mlmmj, i.e. that it is a Sendmail issue, not an Mlmmj issue. Maybe the Sendmail mailing list would be a better source of help.

Perhaps worth a try is putting some other program in place of Mlmmj, e.g. a script that just does cat > /tmp/mymail. Perhaps even temporarily replacing the mlmmj-receive binary with that script is smartest, as you are changing fewest things in the system, then. Then you can send an email to the list address and see if it ends up in /tmp/mymail. If so, it looks more like an Mlmmj-related issue. If not, get that working first, and then replace with Mlmmj and see if you have more luck.

Let us know how you go!

Ben.

Quoted 114 lines · On 15/10/14 5:16 AM, [email protected] wrote:

Hi Geof!

Thanks for your note.

I have not heard any response, except an automated note - some list member's original email address is no longer valid.

I'm still attempting to chase down the proper configuration to get mlmmj running with Sendmail as the MTA. I too, considered using Postfix, but Sendmail is already running, and don't want to try with Postfix if it's not required.

I've begun the slow process of reading through the list archives, but haven't found anything that helps me yet.

When you tried asking the list previously, did you receive any responses? If so, can you recall more specifically when that might have been? - I'd like to go back and see any feedback you might have received, even if it wasn't enough to help you solve this. Perhaps a 2nd pair of eyes on the same feedback, combined with what I'm seeing on my server, might somehow reveal the trick.

Is there anyone still doing development/support for mlmmj?

I've spend years working with and configuring servers, including customizing automated processes that work in the background with majordomo lists. Unfortunately majordomo hasn't been supported in years and is quickly becoming unusable in today's server/mail environments.

I would love to find a new mailing list tool to work with, and mlmmj seems like a great candidate, but I need some help getting out of the starting blocks with configuring this on a CentOS LAMP server environment running Sendmail - a very common platform.

Unless I've completely missed something obvious, the documentation on the mlmmj website doesn't speak to running with Sendmail, except when trying to use VERP (using VERP isn't a requirement for configuring mlmmj to work with Sendmail, is it?)

I'm not even sure that my issue is related Sendmail, but I can't find any documentation that can tell me either way.

Any help that can be provided would be greatly appreciated!!!

Philip

Quoted 67 lines · G Stansfield
Quoted 34 lines · On 08-Oct-14 7:00 PM, [email protected] wrote:

I looked through the documentation, and installed mlmmj per the readme and install documents on a virtual CentOS server.

I have created a test email list - [email protected] - and added 2 subscribers using mlmmj-sub. All appears to be setup properly, but when I send an email to the list using one of the subscribed addresses ([email protected]), my mail log file shows the following:

Oct 7 23:14:21 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390:
from=<[email protected]>, size50, class=0, nrcpts=1, msgid=<[email protected]>, proto=ESMTP, daemon=MSA, relay=c-24-22-61-28.hsd1.or.comcast.net [24.22.61.28]

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1390]: s97NEL7Z001390: Milter insert (1):
header: DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=simple/simple; d=vlsc.org;
sÞfault;\n\tt12723662; bh=SrfRFSC5LbQjGOAy8L6/MImtgtMNuon//Nkbtb0XVZI=;\n\thÚte:From:To:Subject;\n\tb=oKK6sefKYUbo7sC8oIAK0bnVA92vas8lkpOYQsVd//ru+cu5Eyg13wGRlZ+vyAUH2\n\t ko/f+ma6dQdizl1mVIq35h62m1tS+THd8LMZtadOFT1kiyG2HHyasmiqK1UuVjCbxO\n\t
6RfbPTriyZKsXnZfDK4y4pcoAqRextw+ZdKOrDU8>>>
Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud opendkim[771]: s97NEL7Z001390: DKIM-Signature field
added (sÞfault, d=vlsc.org)

Oct 7 23:14:22 cloud sendmail[1392]: s97NEL7Z001390: to=/dev/null,
ctladdr=<[email protected]> (8/0), delay:00:01, xdelay:00:00, mailer=*file*, pri1824, dsn=2.0.0, stat=Sent

The entry "to=/dev/null, ctladdr=<[email protected]>" seems suspicious, like the email is being dumped to /dev/null instead of being delivered to the list.

Can anyone help me by letting me know if I've missed some piece in my setup, or at least how to interpret this log entry correctly?

Quoted 7 lines

I'm a refugee from majordomo who is trying to get our new server running with mlmmj so our organization can continue to run several small in-house email lists.

Thanks for any help!

Philip

Hi Philip!
Did you come right with this? If so, please tell me how!

I tried this some years ago in a home / test environment (using OpenSUSE) before rolling out to a small production LAN - and failed miserably! The only documentation I found was from mlmmj. Asked the mlmmj list and still did not come right. Perhaps I was misunderstanding something on the sendmail side of things.

I toyed with the idea of switching to postfix, but have some custom rules in sendmail so did not want to take on a new learning curve for what was essentially a functionality for which the users were not clamouring at that time.

Regards,
Geoff

-----
No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4765 / Virus Database: 4040/8384 - Release Date: 10/13/14

#4 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Hi Ben!

Thanks to your reply, I was able to make great headway in getting this to work :)

I still have one error message I can't solve - but first, this is what I did to move things along...

As I mentioned offline to Geof, I already figured out the Sendmail MTA wasn't getting the mlmmj program call, as you suspected. I've made all references to my domain and email list below generic, to make things easier to read.

I tried your suggestion by replacing the aliases entry program-call for mlmmj, with a simple "cat" command to determine if this was a Sendmail issue, or mlmmj... turns out the "cat" command would not fire either.

Here's what I did to get Sendmail to successfully fire the basic "cat" command:

- I added an entry to the /etc/mail/virtusertable file:

[email protected] listname.mydomain.com

- then I changed the entry in the /etc/aliases file:
from:

listname: "|cat > /tmp/mailtest.txt"

to:

listname.mydomain.com: "|cat > /tmp/mailtest.txt"

Presto! The "cat" command fired when I sent an email to [email protected].

(*NOTE: this differs from the README documentation on the mlmmj website; which has the aliases entry displayed as "listname: xxxxxxxx" instead of "listname.mydomain.com: xxxxxxx" - I'm not sure if this is Sendmail specific, or if this may be important for other MTAs as well... )

So now I had Sendmail set correctly to potentially fire the mlmmj program, so I tried this /etc/aliases entry:

listname.mydomain.com: "|/usr/local/bin/mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

It did get as far as trying to call mlmmj-receive, but it failed to start mlmmj-receive:

Oct 15 18:45:22 cloud smrsh: uid 8: attempt to use "mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname" (stat failed)
Oct 15 18:45:22 cloud sendmail[4560]: s9FIjLBe004558: to="|/etc/smrsh/mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname", ctladdr=<[email protected]> (8/0), delay=00:00:00, xdelay=00:00:00, mailer=prog, pri=35725, dsn=5.0.0, stat=Service unavailable
Oct 15 18:45:22 cloud sendmail[4560]: s9FIjLBe004558: s9FIjMBe004560: DSN: Service unavailable

smrsh: "mlmmj-receive" not available for sendmail programs (stat failed) 554 5.0.0 Service unavailable

So here's what I did to get mlmmj-receive to fire through the restricted shell utility smrsh:

- I created symlinks for the mlmmj-xxx executables in the /etc/smrsh directory:

ln -s /usr/local/bin/mlmmj-xxxxx

Now mlmmj-receive executes when I send an email to [email protected]!

Unfortunately, I'm now getting the following bounce-error message:

----- The following addresses had permanent fatal errors -----
"|mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

    (reason: 1)
    (expanded from:<[email protected]>)

----- Transcript of session follows -----
Have to invoke either as root or as the user owning listdir 554 5.3.0 unknown mailer error 1

The symlinks and the actual mlmmj-xxxx files are all chmod as 755, but I'm not sure how or where to effect a permissions change to get sendmail to "invoke" mlmmj-receive with the proper permissions.

As you can see, this is progress from where I was before... any ideas on how I should address the permissions error coming from mlmmj-receive?

Philip

Quoted 28 lines · Ben Schmidt

Hi, Philip,

Yes, we are definitely still here! Development has slowed a bit recently, but not stopped, and the mailing list is small, but friendly; we help when we can.

Looks like not many people know how to configure Sendmail. I toyed with it many years ago, and can remember nothing.

Perhaps if you send some configuration snippets we will have a better chance helping.

It seems to me like the mail is never even getting to Mlmmj, i.e. that it is a Sendmail issue, not an Mlmmj issue. Maybe the Sendmail mailing list would be a better source of help.

Perhaps worth a try is putting some other program in place of Mlmmj, e.g. a script that just does cat > /tmp/mymail. Perhaps even temporarily replacing the mlmmj-receive binary with that script is smartest, as you are changing fewest things in the system, then. Then you can send an email to the list address and see if it ends up in /tmp/mymail. If so, it looks more like an Mlmmj-related issue. If not, get that working first, and then replace with Mlmmj and see if you have more luck.

Let us know how you go!

Ben.

#5 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 12 lines
Oct 15 18:45:22 cloud smrsh: uid 8: attempt to use "mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname" (stat failed)

Unfortunately, I'm now getting the following bounce-error message:

----- The following addresses had permanent fatal errors -----
"|mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

     (reason: 1)
     (expanded from:<[email protected]>)

Have to invoke either as root or as the user owning listdir 554 5.3.0 unknown mailer error 1

Quoted 7 lines

The symlinks and the actual mlmmj-xxxx files are all chmod as 755, but I'm not sure how or where to effect a permissions change to get sendmail to "invoke" mlmmj-receive with the proper permissions.

As you can see, this is progress from where I was before... any ideas on how I should address the permissions error coming from mlmmj-receive?

This may do it (but obviously understand it; don't execute it blindly!). 8 is the UID/user indicated in the sendmail log.

sudo chown 8 /var/spool/mlmmj/listname

Make sure Mlmmj through smrsh can also get to that dir (do you need more symlinks, e.g. because you're chrooted?).

Ben.

#7 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Ben,

Thanks for the feedback!

I was able to use chown to change the ownership for all the list files as you suggested, and now I've moved several steps closer to getting mlmmj working! (for anyone interested, uid = 8 on my server turned out to be user = "mail" )

mlmmj-receive is beginning to process posts sent to my test list, but so far they are ending up in

../listname/queue/discarded

and the maillog is reporting this as:

Oct 16 18:29:59 cloud sendmail[5502]: STARTTLS=server, relay=eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com [69.89.2.76], version=TLSv1/SSLv3, verify=NO, cipher=DHE-RSA-AES256-SHA, bits=256/256
Oct 16 18:29:59 cloud sendmail[5502]: s9GITxnP005502: from=<[email protected]>, size=6474, class=0, nrcpts=1, msgid=<[email protected]>, proto=ESMTP, daemon=MTA, relay=eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com [69.89.2.76]
Oct 16 18:30:00 cloud sendmail[5504]: s9GITxnP005502: to="|mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/sail2", ctladdr=<[email protected]> (8/0), delay=00:00:01, xdelay=00:00:00, mailer=prog, pri=36735, dsn=2.0.0, stat=Sent
Oct 16 18:30:00 cloud /etc/smrsh/mlmmj-process[5506]: mlmmj-process.c:811: Discarding /var/spool/mlmmj/listname/incoming/6386743745f1a098 due to missing envelope from address: Success

I understand the "due to missing envelope from address" error is a reference to an (empty) envelope from address, but I'm not sure why this is being triggered. I've seen some references to this being a problem if the envelope from address is in < > brackets, but its unclear to me how I can address this. Here's the header from the post file that ended up in ../discarded

From [email protected] Thu Oct 16 18:29:59 2014

Received: from eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com (eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com [69.89.2.76])

    by cloud.mydomain.com (8.14.4/8.14.4) with ESMTP id s9GITxnP005502

    (version=TLSv1/SSLv3 cipher=DHE-RSA-AES256-SHA bits=256 verify=NO)

    for <[email protected]>; Thu, 16 Oct 2014 18:29:59 GMT

Received: from sagediagram.com ([216.154.217.29])

    by eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com with esmtps (TLSv1:DHE-RSA-AES256-SHA:256)

    (Exim 4.84)

    (envelope-from <[email protected]>)

    id 1Xepnz-0006F6-M5

    for [email protected]; Thu, 16 Oct 2014 14:29:56 -0400

Received-SPF: softfail (sagediagram.com: domain of transitioning [email protected] does not designate 24.22.61.28 as permitted sender) receiver=sagediagram.com; client-ip=24.22.61.28; helo=[192.168.1.104]; [email protected]; x-software=spfmilter 0.97 http://www.acme.com/software/spfmilter/ with libspf2-1.0.0;

Received: from [192.168.1.104] (c-24-22-61-28.hsd1.or.comcast.net [24.22.61.28])

    by sagediagram.com (8.14.2/8.14.2) with ESMTP id s9GITgEh026480

    for <[email protected]>; Thu, 16 Oct 2014 14:29:42 -0400

Message-ID: <[email protected]>

Date: Thu, 16 Oct 2014 11:26:27 -0700

From: Philip <[email protected]>

User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64; rv:24.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/24.6.0

MIME-Version: 1.0

To: [email protected]

Subject: re. test results

Content-Type: multipart/alternative;

boundary="------------030407040502070403070707"

Received-SPF: pass (eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com: domain of parshley.net designates 216.154.217.29 as permitted sender) client-ip=216.154.217.29; [email protected]; helo=sagediagram.com;

X-SPF-Result: eapps-spx02.vm.eapps.com: domain of parshley.net designates 216.154.217.29 as permitted sender

X-Filter-ID: s0sct1PQhAABKnZB5plbIQgsumjrb/qn8pvMb0r31ZUkfdChetB4bt5LiDYVEZByx1wTMkEUUoeb

KIhkyzl2dF32XZvZInsoHjme/WxkkRcTakFHLT/0qfWMlO3/QqSFNUDTyjn1ef5evEDDyypLgbJU

gtOJAkXSMx9YVHdPqxKcv/HxuQ3Apsj8YeBnVa1ZUAt8TTxonK45J05twrVY/P1GDNZ9gBCIxxGx

VFpn7AN/U/jsH4EXGgfUT7LIXyPec67TIvOBTd6L1MGTcnqLu/y5q0C++Lv/QUF02g1+DZxb5wxw

q6a5JGTNj4jSCHVb8vzKnEie5ViFLOjCzG8IF5e2XAcAqWhPNQt97ku/DxR4FjctpFCe7sYB5/us

QEK/UJK+F9HDeJw2f5+jo8HgFDRtF2Igz0UWV+HgG70TkVxp7cowWC4sdJbvT/6MXLfExH4YaDRm

graL79jkgrbL24PAgTtUp75uqlx0KezvZHVB9dYBSu5jRStj6zksZS+oTOevt9oQNLQ4Wz40vjTd

BGiH1Wgh6RAenBR+licROGZUa05SLII8ZnNgIPr9luPC4iXwjlL8lh+/xwVCxffWBA==

X-Report-Abuse-To: [email protected]

X-Filter-Fingerprint: IFrWXGses7OKB5S5G8/dJRn/7L7+nnclbWGk7OJ1jHJA3cTUQ1R++keuE7RDJ8Kg3RbMLUalw1oC

mj99/u+PoqoVy8a3lsStJtAvpObFX0XnhRv/ZJ3kEy8bfiAr+Fb/UpndEJ0YoaLytXXo8BMTaX2p

Mk7LBarWD9Fj4R3eIu6C5spubTEXAEkuBKN3yOZvUxf7JO+oAUByCkP7cAJnEooJtGZFyF6tI/I5

CWVQH2sjWUvnt4XQmbZjx+Gtm4/p

Authentication-Results: vm.eapps.com; spf=pass [email protected]

X-eAppsHosting-Class: ham

X-eAppsHosting-Evidence: Combined (0.20)

X-Recommended-Action: accept

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

--------------030407040502070403070707

I can see

envelope-from <[email protected]>

in the header, but not sure why this would trigger the discard action, and how to fix this... any ideas?

I greatly appreciate all the help you've been providing, and I feel like I'm nearly there, but it's still just out of reach...

Philip

Quoted 42 lines · Ben Schmidt
Quoted 12 lines
Oct 15 18:45:22 cloud smrsh: uid 8: attempt to use "mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname" (stat failed)

Unfortunately, I'm now getting the following bounce-error message:

----- The following addresses had permanent fatal errors -----
"|mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

     (reason: 1)
     (expanded from:<[email protected]>)

Have to invoke either as root or as the user owning listdir 554 5.3.0 unknown mailer error 1

Quoted 7 lines

The symlinks and the actual mlmmj-xxxx files are all chmod as 755, but I'm not sure how or where to effect a permissions change to get sendmail to "invoke" mlmmj-receive with the proper permissions.

As you can see, this is progress from where I was before... any ideas on how I should address the permissions error coming from mlmmj-receive?

This may do it (but obviously understand it; don't execute it blindly!). 8 is the UID/user indicated in the sendmail log.

sudo chown 8 /var/spool/mlmmj/listname

Make sure Mlmmj through smrsh can also get to that dir (do you need more symlinks, e.g. because you're chrooted?).

Ben.

-----
No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4765 / Virus Database: 4040/8394 - Release Date: 10/15/14

#8 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 4 lines · On 17/10/14 6:02 AM, [email protected] wrote:
Oct 16 18:30:00 cloud /etc/smrsh/mlmmj-process[5506]: mlmmj-process.c:811: Discarding /var/spool/mlmmj/listname/incoming/6386743745f1a098 due to missing envelope from address: Success

I understand the "due to missing envelope from address" error is a reference to an (empty) envelope from address, but I'm not sure why this is being triggered.

The envelope from isn't empty, it's just not passing from Sendmail to Mlmmj properly.

Strangely, Mlmmj doesn't look for a Unix/mbox "From " line to extract an envelope from address. I actually think this is an Mlmmj shortcoming, and I will attempt to address it in a future release.

However, Mlmmj does look for a Return-Path header, and that is conspicuously missing from the headers you posted. Did you include

define(LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS', eu9P')dnl

in your Sendmail config as per <http://mlmmj.org/docs/readme-sendmail/>?

It's the capital P that is necessary to include the Return-Path header.

Best regards,

Ben.

#9 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 10 lines

Have been away for a while. The following are some facts about my system setup :

openSUSE 12.3 : Sendmail 8.14.5-85.1.2

The config files are located /usr/share/sendmail, so cd to there

README has the following :
LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS [eu9] The flags used by the shell mailer. The
flags lsDFMoq are always included.

The Mlmmj reference for this is <http://mlmmj.org/docs/readme-sendmail/>
which suggests setting LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS to 'eu9P' (i.e. the default, plus 'P').

A Sendmail reference for what the flags mean is
<http://www.sendmail.org/~ca/email/doc8.8/op-sh-5.html#sh-5.4>

Quoted 5 lines

cd feature/; grep LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS * shows :
msp.m4:define(LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS', lmDFMuXk5')dnl

Note the absence of a 'P' in the README reference - and the disconcerting use of flags in file msp.m4 that are not noted in the README.

Googling suggests the 'msp' feature is the 'mail submission program'. I have no idea why it's defining LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS, but I also know next to nothing about m4 or Sendmail (and have no real inclination to learn more), so for all I know, it could be a different scope.

Quoted 3 lines

So where is the all important Return-Path documented and set? I have 'grep -i return-path *' till I am blue in the face and have not found anything that helps me. <sigh>

It took me quite a while to find the references above, too.... Sendmail's documentation is pretty esoteric. I feel like unless you already know what you're looking for, you don't know where to even look for it.... I vastly prefer Postfix and Exim, both of which I have set up in very little time, including with Mlmmj. In my experience, Qmail and Sendmail are both significantly harder to get working, and if there's any real benefit once they're up and running, it's lost on me!

Smiles,

Ben.

#10 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Ben,

Success!!!

The LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS entry for sendmail.cf worked, and I'm now able to send posts to my mlmmj email list.

To recap my steps to getting mlmmj working with Sendmail on a CentOS server:

- mlmmj installed into /usr/local/bin/ by default... but I had to create symlinks, one for each mlmmj script, in the /etc/smrsh/ directory before they would run when called from sendmail (which uses the smrsh shell).

- to get sendmail to include a Return Path, I added this line to /etc/mail/sendmail.mc:

    define(`LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS', `eu9P')dnl

...then ran "m4 /etc/mail/sendmail.mc > /etc/mail/sendmail.cf" ...to update the changes to the real sendmail.cf file, and restarted the sendmail service

- I ran mlmmj-make-ml to create a mailing list

- I created an entry in the /etc/mail/virtusertable file:

[email protected] listname.mydomain.com

- I had to update/change the /etc/aliases entry that was auto-created by mlmmj-make-ml, from:

listname: "|/usr/local/bin/mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

to:

listname.mydomain.com : "|mlmmj-receive -L /var/spool/mlmmj/listname"

to correctly match the list alias in the virtusertable file, and because the symlinks were now directly in the /etc/mail/smrsh directory

- I ran the following chown command, to set the owner of the list dir and files to the "mail" user:

chown -R mail /var/spool/mlmmj/[listdir]

- I'm not sure I needed to, but I also created a list-owner entry in the virtusertable file:

[email protected] listname-owner.mydomain.com

and an entry in the /etc/aliases file:

listname-owner.mydomain.com [email protected]

I think this covers all the steps I took to successfully configure mlmmj for the Sendmail MTA on my CentOS server. It looks complicated, but it's actually not that much work to get it running. (it was a long slog to figure out, though!)

I've already created a couple of our small working lists already, and have several more to build - which leads me to a couple follow-on questions, but I'll send them to the support list under a new thread heading.

Thanks again to Ben and Geof for helping me get from zero to 100% up and running!

Philip

Quoted 38 lines · Ben Schmidt
Quoted 4 lines · On 17/10/14 6:02 AM, [email protected] wrote:
Oct 16 18:30:00 cloud /etc/smrsh/mlmmj-process[5506]: mlmmj-process.c:811: Discarding /var/spool/mlmmj/listname/incoming/6386743745f1a098 due to missing envelope from address: Success

I understand the "due to missing envelope from address" error is a reference to an (empty) envelope from address, but I'm not sure why this is being triggered.

The envelope from isn't empty, it's just not passing from Sendmail to Mlmmj properly.

Strangely, Mlmmj doesn't look for a Unix/mbox "From " line to extract an envelope from address. I actually think this is an Mlmmj shortcoming, and I will attempt to address it in a future release.

However, Mlmmj does look for a Return-Path header, and that is conspicuously missing from the headers you posted. Did you include

define(LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS', eu9P')dnl

in your Sendmail config as per <http://mlmmj.org/docs/readme-sendmail/>?

It's the capital P that is necessary to include the Return-Path header.

Best regards,

Ben.

-----
No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4765 / Virus Database: 4040/8403 - Release Date: 10/16/14

#11 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

:) It was a PITB to get this figured out, so I did take the time to write it up, in case it would help someone else down the road.

I agree that sendmail isn't necessarily a good choice to start with, but it's still the default MTA on a lot of canned virtual servers that are made available - like the one we use from eapps.com - so I didn't want to wade into changing something that was already otherwise working Ok on the server (and supported by eapps.com).

In hindsight it might have been easier to simply get Postfix or Exim installed and running, but hindsight is always 20-20 :)

Philip

Quoted 57 lines · Ben Schmidt
Quoted 10 lines

Have been away for a while. The following are some facts about my system setup :

openSUSE 12.3 : Sendmail 8.14.5-85.1.2

The config files are located /usr/share/sendmail, so cd to there

README has the following :
LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS [eu9] The flags used by the shell mailer. The
flags lsDFMoq are always included.

The Mlmmj reference for this is <http://mlmmj.org/docs/readme-sendmail/>
which suggests setting LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS to 'eu9P' (i.e. the default, plus 'P').

A Sendmail reference for what the flags mean is
<http://www.sendmail.org/~ca/email/doc8.8/op-sh-5.html#sh-5.4>

Quoted 5 lines

cd feature/; grep LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS * shows :
msp.m4:define(LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS', lmDFMuXk5')dnl

Note the absence of a 'P' in the README reference - and the disconcerting use of flags in file msp.m4 that are not noted in the README.

Googling suggests the 'msp' feature is the 'mail submission program'. I have no idea why it's defining LOCAL_SHELL_FLAGS, but I also know next to nothing about m4 or Sendmail (and have no real inclination to learn more), so for all I know, it could be a different scope.

Quoted 3 lines

So where is the all important Return-Path documented and set? I have 'grep -i return-path *' till I am blue in the face and have not found anything that helps me. <sigh>

It took me quite a while to find the references above, too.... Sendmail's documentation is pretty esoteric. I feel like unless you already know what you're looking for, you don't know where to even look for it.... I vastly prefer Postfix and Exim, both of which I have set up in very little time, including with Mlmmj. In my experience, Qmail and Sendmail are both significantly harder to get working, and if there's any real benefit once they're up and running, it's lost on me!

Smiles,

Ben.

-----
No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4765 / Virus Database: 4040/8407 - Release Date: 10/17/14

#12 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]

Thanks for documenting your experience. One day hopefully we can integrate anything that's missing into Mlmmj's README.sendmail. I think if nothing else, README.sendmail is only for non-virtual setups, so could definitely be improved, as virtual setups seem more common these days.

Quoted 8 lines · On 18/10/14 7:56 AM, [email protected] wrote:

- I'm not sure I needed to, but I also created a list-owner entry in the virtusertable file:

[email protected] listname-owner.mydomain.com

and an entry in the /etc/aliases file:

[email protected]

You shouldn't need this.

Mlmmj provides [email protected] (note the + where you had -) which forwards to the address(es) listed in the owner tunable for the list. Other Mlmmj features, e.g. subscription, also use +, such as in listname+subscribe.

Ben.