OT: Crowdfunding to port OpenBMC to Asus KGPE-D16
[Please CC me, as I am not subscribed.]
Dear OpenBMC people,
If you haven’t heard yet, there is a crowdfunding campaign going on to fund a port of OpenBMC to the Asus KGPE-D16 [1].
The free firmware coreboot [2] runs on that board, and no BLOBs have to be used with it. Having OpenBMC run on that board, would be the last step, to have a fully free, owner-controlled server mainboard. I am citing a message from Timothy to the coreboot mailing list below from February 6th, 2017 [3].
Quoted 11 lines
As of today, we have $10,250 pledged out of $20,000 required to start work on the OpenBMC support for KGPE-D16 systems using coreboot. Raptor is, as before, contributing an additional $25,000+ toward development should the $20,000 community goal be reached.
If you would like to help get this port started, please contact Martin Roth ([email protected]) with information on what you would like to pledge. This offer is time limited; we are looking to end the offer in the next month or so, so if this is something you would like to see please step up and contribute something to this goal!
Quoted 6 lines
As a general reminder, the KGPE-D16 is the last, most powerful owner-controllable X86 workstation / server class machine available. It is still in production along with its Opteron CPUs, so it occupies a unique position in coreboot's tree. Providing a libre BMC for this system could help adoption of coreboot in server environments, strengthening its position some in the market.
As of today there are still $6,000 USD missing. As the coreboot community does not seem big enough to fund such a project, I am kindly asking you for support. If you can’t or don’t want to spend money, it’d be great if you could spread the word (Twitter message [4]).
Thanks,
Paul
[1] https://www.raptorengineering.com/coreboot/kgpe-d16-bmc-port-offer.php
[2] https://www.coreboot.org/
[3] https://www.coreboot.org/pipermail/coreboot/2017-February/083176.html
[4] https://twitter.com/RaptorEng/status/833738989840584704
I replied to Raptor's tweet asking why they preferred Facebook's OpenBMC over the IBM one. I find it odd that you are asking developers on the latter to fund development for the former.
Rick
Quoted 47 lines · Paul Menzel
[Please CC me, as I am not subscribed.]
Dear OpenBMC people,
If you haven’t heard yet, there is a crowdfunding campaign going on to fund a port of OpenBMC to the Asus KGPE-D16 [1].
The free firmware coreboot [2] runs on that board, and no BLOBs have to be used with it. Having OpenBMC run on that board, would be the last step, to have a fully free, owner-controlled server mainboard. I am citing a message from Timothy to the coreboot mailing list below from February 6th, 2017 [3].
Quoted 11 lines
As of today, we have $10,250 pledged out of $20,000 required to start work on the OpenBMC support for KGPE-D16 systems using coreboot. Raptor is, as before, contributing an additional $25,000+ toward development should the $20,000 community goal be reached.
If you would like to help get this port started, please contact Martin Roth ([email protected]) with information on what you would like to pledge. This offer is time limited; we are looking to end the offer in the next month or so, so if this is something you would like to see please step up and contribute something to this goal!
Quoted 6 lines
As a general reminder, the KGPE-D16 is the last, most powerful owner-controllable X86 workstation / server class machine available. It is still in production along with its Opteron CPUs, so it occupies a unique position in coreboot's tree. Providing a libre BMC for this system could help adoption of coreboot in server environments, strengthening its position some in the market.
As of today there are still $6,000 USD missing. As the coreboot community does not seem big enough to fund such a project, I am kindly asking you for support. If you can’t or don’t want to spend money, it’d be great if you could spread the word (Twitter message [4]).
Thanks,
Paul
[1] https://www.raptorengineering.com/coreboot/kgpe-d16-bmc-port-offer.php
[2] https://www.coreboot.org/
[3] https://www.coreboot.org/pipermail/coreboot/2017-February/083176.html
[4] https://twitter.com/RaptorEng/status/833738989840584704
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Quoted 5 lines · Rick Altherr
I replied to Raptor's tweet asking why they preferred Facebook's OpenBMC over the IBM one. I find it odd that you are asking developers on the latter to fund development for the former.
Rick
Perhaps I should clarify a bit.
The KGPE-D16 uses an older ASpeed device not supported by either version of OpenBMC. This ASpeed device is not only limited in computational power, but ASUS limited the device further in the board design to the point where we are not sure that the IBM OpenBMC will actually fit or work without hardware modifications (in fact, I am fairly certain hardware modifications would be required). Given our past experience with crowdfunding efforts we prioritized the total project cost over the more expansive feature set of IBM's OpenBMC in order to get something functional into the community's hands. We hope that once the larger community has had a chance to experience software freedom on the BMC level using lower-cost commercially available hardware that they will support the manufacturers (such as IBM) that are selling hardware with OpenBMC available.
We have also added a stretch goal to the project to initiate a port of IBM's OpenBMC, built on the common code and reverse engineering efforts from the base Facebook port. This process is expected to involve creating new hardware to replace the limited firmware module of the KGPE-D16, as well as integrating new x86-specific drivers into the upstream IBM OpenBMC tree. Perhaps this stretch goal is more interesting to the members on this list?
Thanks!
- --
Timothy Pearson
Raptor Engineering
+1 (415) 727-8645 (direct line)
+1 (512) 690-0200 (switchboard)
https://www.raptorengineering.com
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/
iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJYtJbaAAoJEK+E3vEXDOFbRJoIALLUZzWr7zmZCKivjaS32BA4 nAPRVTfImuEuh1AD6zmFL6WlHjv3NNyMEuBdaZRv7xoizlhHL/ua0XeCFws8Qtyw 3VUHsRMB5THvzcie+ooDPv3GoBQPc4MW70ZuDs5VV0pzp2HcHSeoaiTgDpA6z0ga GyP4cbFvBwgid7pvMAA4I+LujpgQLdui19o8QhO26GA13KUQhEDoSzKWg5C7xJFz vgTCwrF1u1avuA5RIth9+aGzOOJxgeRwT8tDzEAuwS+cC7dZGP6KXGVGfPPb8Qir b9ZRU/4Q0Ig7QnLaDp/zeua9MWXLyCaUMaaCAhmmbMFbCdzQ75e5Z2R7JFSDj9E= =rGB+
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
I'm assuming the core work of booting u-boot and linux on the BMC used on KGPE-D16
(AST2300?) is usable by both projects. I'll gladly support bringup on a new SoC as long as the patches are headed to mainline linux and u-boot.
AFAIK, the only limit on whether IBM OpenBMC can be used is the amount of RAM and flash available. My work on a Quanta Q71L has it booting on an AST2400 with 128MB of RAM and 32MB of flash.
My concerns with contributing to the campaign are that I don't understand what work is planned and where those changes will end up.
Rick
Quoted 55 lines · Timothy Pearson
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1Quoted 5 lines · Rick Altherr
I replied to Raptor's tweet asking why they preferred Facebook's OpenBMC over the IBM one. I find it odd that you are asking developers on the latter to fund development for the former.
Rick
Perhaps I should clarify a bit.
The KGPE-D16 uses an older ASpeed device not supported by either version of OpenBMC. This ASpeed device is not only limited in computational power, but ASUS limited the device further in the board design to the point where we are not sure that the IBM OpenBMC will actually fit or work without hardware modifications (in fact, I am fairly certain hardware modifications would be required). Given our past experience with crowdfunding efforts we prioritized the total project cost over the more expansive feature set of IBM's OpenBMC in order to get something functional into the community's hands. We hope that once the larger community has had a chance to experience software freedom on the BMC level using lower-cost commercially available hardware that they will support the manufacturers (such as IBM) that are selling hardware with OpenBMC available.
We have also added a stretch goal to the project to initiate a port of IBM's OpenBMC, built on the common code and reverse engineering efforts from the base Facebook port. This process is expected to involve creating new hardware to replace the limited firmware module of the KGPE-D16, as well as integrating new x86-specific drivers into the upstream IBM OpenBMC tree. Perhaps this stretch goal is more interesting to the members on this list?
Thanks!
- --
Timothy Pearson
Raptor Engineering
+1 (415) 727-8645 (direct line)
+1 (512) 690-0200 (switchboard)
https://www.raptorengineering.com
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJYtJbaAAoJEK+E3vEXDOFbRJoIALLUZzWr7zmZCKivjaS32BA4 nAPRVTfImuEuh1AD6zmFL6WlHjv3NNyMEuBdaZRv7xoizlhHL/ua0XeCFws8Qtyw 3VUHsRMB5THvzcie+ooDPv3GoBQPc4MW70ZuDs5VV0pzp2HcHSeoaiTgDpA6z0ga GyP4cbFvBwgid7pvMAA4I+LujpgQLdui19o8QhO26GA13KUQhEDoSzKWg5C7xJFz vgTCwrF1u1avuA5RIth9+aGzOOJxgeRwT8tDzEAuwS+cC7dZGP6KXGVGfPPb8Qir b9ZRU/4Q0Ig7QnLaDp/zeua9MWXLyCaUMaaCAhmmbMFbCdzQ75e5Z2R7JFSDj9E= =rGB+
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Quoted 2 lines · Rick Altherr
I'm assuming the core work of booting u-boot and linux on the BMC used on KGPE-D16 (AST2300?) is usable by both projects.
Exactly.
I'll gladly support
Quoted 2 lines
bringup on a new SoC as long as the patches are headed to mainline linux and u-boot.
This would be part of the third stretch goal (IBM OpenBMC support). Any of the stretch goals can be funded in any order, and you can also earmark a contribution specifically for any of the stretch goal(s) you may be interested in.
To keep the overall costs reasonable and to allow adapting to the needs of the community, the base goal consists of a port of the Facebook OpenBMC system, released as a buildable source tree, and includes creation and upstreaming of the necessary changes to coreboot and flashrom. More advanced features are then implemented as stretch goals, including the work of trying to upstream the drivers into Linux and u-boot.
Quoted 3 lines
AFAIK, the only limit on whether IBM OpenBMC can be used is the amount of RAM and flash available. My work on a Quanta Q71L has it booting on an AST2400 with 128MB of RAM and 32MB of flash.
The KGPE-D16 is even more limited than that. Even making Facebook's OpenBMC function on an unmodified KGPE-D16 will be an interesting challenge.
Quoted 2 lines
My concerns with contributing to the campaign are that I don't understand what work is planned and where those changes will end up.
I hope this has helped clarify some. If you have any other questions please feel free to ask!
Timothy Pearson
Raptor Engineering
+1 (415) 727-8645 (direct line)
+1 (512) 690-0200 (switchboard)
https://www.raptorengineering.com
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/
iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJYtJr2AAoJEK+E3vEXDOFbbdwH/3lLbyA5NsZ1iGvej9+Vkvaj JOjfqyxZ4+2OJgiq3laLSSNOefGn6CDOXub+TTFKv+Cb/02zqVb1NUcUauK1QCGK IlMkQxG5o+kxA7vJ+7p3UTbpeZGPRdDVf008IBneWEmsOcI8lYnSFh7VyCvJb9eR dE4HltGIr5z9zKaOWO8IMYQIjUcbnOucpaA2xbjGxPpwDtebwetqgY7wQ+dR6qyc VNg6jOESZY3AsQB+AIEEwP8bGx+i7rLkNMYCnHdem837mUXrQ3M5aFpT2McoNV3a Ut3sTUH1A9sE99qEx8Ka113CWI/myco53YyVe4xtQbXC/m+ttMhX+8+QcesXqEQ= =rI1I
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Dear Rick,
Am Montag, den 27.02.2017, 13:01 -0800 schrieb Rick Altherr:
Quoted 3 lines
I replied to Raptor's tweet asking why they preferred Facebook's OpenBMC over the IBM one. I find it odd that you are asking developers on the latter to fund development for the former.
I am sorry about that. It was solely my ignorance. I just search for *OpenBMC* and *mailing list*, and used that list address. I didn’t know that there is a Facebook OpenBMC and an IBM one, as I had just read about Facebook’s OpenBMC a few years ago in the press, and nothing else.
Now I am smarter, and hope that will get IBM’s OpenBMC funded and running on that device/board too.
So please spread the word.
Thanks,
Paul