Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Regarding threats to "CoC" you. - You do have recourse - license rescission

DISCUSSION [email protected] 1 participant 2 messages May 9, 2019 – May 13, 2019 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Dear Poul-Henning "UNIX guru at large" Kamp;
Many have noticed threats made against you recently to seek your
ejectment from the FreeBSD project as retaliation for statements you made protesting the ceaseless and ever on-going slaughter of innocents; A transparent attempt to censor your political speech, if there ever was one.

I am forwarding this message below to you because if such is
attempted, you do have recourse: and that is the rescind the gratis license you have granted regarding the use of your works of authorship. You may rescind these grantsfrom your attackers, those who fail to defend your right to free speech, from the project itself, or from all free-takers (if such is your wish).

Remeber: A non-exclusive license grant is not a transfer of
copyright, and such a license absent bargained-for consideration
is just that: a license (permission); it is not a contract and does not bind the /grantor/ to any terms. It can be revocated at any time, for any or no reason.

This applies to all the "classic" free licenses, from the MIT
license, to the BSD license, to the GPL.

-------
The proclamations made by some as to the irrevocability of freely given non-exclusive licenses are incorrect.

If the non-exclusive licensee did not pay the copyright holder consideration for receipt of the permissions given regarding the copyrighted work, the copyright holder can freely rescind those permissions _AT_ANY_TIME_ .

The reasons are as follows: For the licensee to "hold" the licensor to any promise regarding when and how rescission is to take place there must be a contract between the two. A contract requires valid bargained-for consideration. Otherwise any "promise" made is an Illusory Promise (unenforceable).

"Nothing" is not valid consideration.

Obeying a pre-existing duty is not valid consideration.

The licensee has a pre-existing duty to obey copyright law, without permission from the copyright holder he may not use/modify/make-derivative-works-of/distribute/distribute-derivative-works-of. That permission is what he is attempting to "contract" for. Saying one will follow those permissions is not valid consideration to "pay" for those permissions. Promising not to violate the copyright holder's rights -by promising to only use the copyrighted works as freely permitted by the copyright holder, is not valid consideration as that is a pre-existing duty.

Yes: you _C_A_N_ revoke GPL/BSD/MIT/etc permissions from free-takers at your will. And you should do so if that is needed for your livelihood to succeed.

You should do so if it is simply your want.
(And you should do so if you are attacked by those free-takers)

Do not the pennyless leaches intimidate you from making your own decisions regarding your work of authorship. They gave you nothing, you asked for nothing, they have nothing. Remember: a non-exclusive license is not a transfer, it is permission. Permission that can be ended at any time unless there exists an attached interest (ie: the other side payed you for a license contract) Also Remember: The FSF has _always_ (and still does) required Copyright Transfers before it would accept a contribution.

And yes: I am a lawyer.

Of course: consult your local copyright attorney. Strategy is important in these cases. The free-loaders feel they have the 9th circuit judges in the bag, and that the 9th circuit will invalidate the concept of consideration if needed to protect the California tech industry (so revoke from those outside the 9th circuit first).

For easy to read by lay-people discussions on this topic:
lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/4/334 lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/3/698

For legal articles and treatises that agree: no consideration from GPL free-taker, no contract, revocable by the copyright holder:
scholarship.law.duke.edu/faculty_scholarship/1857/ www.amazon.com/Open-Source-Licensing-Software-Intellectual/dp/0131487876 papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=243237

Sincerely;
Pro-Bono Attorney

(Note: all discussion herein is in relevance to US law)

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): CAM9wqY8HhUujMkX8d3TLL5SHWxL-+XOMFaWPQoKnZjePQuTqmA@mail.gmail.com

#2 lore raw

I'm not seeking remuneration for the information, nor suggesting any specific attorney, nor will I profit from this is any way. Many of the programmers are completely unaware of their rights regarding their works of authorship and the FSF, SFLC and whomever else have been spreading misleading information. They deserve to know the truth so their works are not, effectively, converted, while they are cast aside.

As a BSD-grrl you probably have ample experience with such misleading statements from said outlets in the past, again and again and again and again.

As for whatever the webhost DNS string means: I don't keep up with social media.

Quoted 143 lines · Randi Harper

Hm.

You know, as a lawyer, it might be wise to not send people unsolicited legal advice. Most lawyers tend to shy away from that. But what do I know, I'm sure any email service that is associated with cryptocurrency and was named after an SVU episode where women developers were sexually assaulted by gamers is totally on the up and up. 100% legit. Thank you, sir, for this valuable service you have provided to the community. I applaud you and your bravery at ignoring common wisdom and legal convention. You have done us all a great service today.

-- randi

Quoted 43 lines · On Thu, May 9, 2019 at 8:25 AM <[email protected]> wrote:

Dear Poul-Henning "UNIX guru at large" Kamp;
Many have noticed threats made against you recently to seek your ejectment from the FreeBSD project as retaliation for statements you made protesting the ceaseless and ever on-going slaughter of innocents; A transparent attempt to censor your political speech, if there ever was one.

I am forwarding this message below to you because if such is attempted, you do have recourse: and that is the rescind the gratis license you have granted regarding the use of your works of authorship. You may rescind these grantsfrom your attackers, those who fail to defend your right to free speech, from the project itself, or from all free-takers (if such is your wish).

Remeber: A non-exclusive license grant is not a transfer of copyright, and such a license absent bargained-for consideration is just that: a license (permission); it is not a contract and does not
bind the /grantor/ to any terms. It can be revocated at any time, for any or no reason.

This applies to all the "classic" free licenses, from the MIT license, to the BSD license, to the GPL.

-------
The proclamations made by some as to the irrevocability of freely given
non-exclusive licenses are incorrect.

If the non-exclusive licensee did not pay the copyright holder consideration for receipt of the permissions given regarding the copyrighted work, the copyright holder can freely rescind those permissions _AT_ANY_TIME_ .

The reasons are as follows: For the licensee to "hold" the licensor to
any promise regarding when and how rescission is to take place there

must be a contract between the two. A contract requires valid bargained-for consideration. Otherwise any "promise" made is an Illusory
Promise (unenforceable).

Quoted 7 lines

"Nothing" is not valid consideration.

Obeying a pre-existing duty is not valid consideration.

The licensee has a pre-existing duty to obey copyright law, without permission from the copyright holder he may not

use/modify/make-derivative-works-of/distribute/distribute-derivative-works-of.

Quoted 44 lines

That permission is what he is attempting to "contract" for. Saying one
will follow those permissions is not valid consideration to "pay" for
those permissions. Promising not to violate the copyright holder's rights -by promising to only use the copyrighted works as freely permitted by the copyright holder, is not valid consideration as that is
a pre-existing duty.

Yes: you _C_A_N_ revoke GPL/BSD/MIT/etc permissions from free-takers at
your will. And you should do so if that is needed for your livelihood to
succeed.

You should do so if it is simply your want.
(And you should do so if you are attacked by those free-takers)

Do not the pennyless leaches intimidate you from making your own decisions regarding your work of authorship. They gave you nothing, you
asked for nothing, they have nothing. Remember: a non-exclusive license
is not a transfer, it is permission. Permission that can be ended at any
time unless there exists an attached interest (ie: the other side payed
you for a license contract)
Also Remember: The FSF has _always_ (and still does) required Copyright
Transfers before it would accept a contribution.

And yes: I am a lawyer.

Of course: consult your local copyright attorney. Strategy is important
in these cases. The free-loaders feel they have the 9th circuit judges
in the bag, and that the 9th circuit will invalidate the concept of consideration if needed to protect the California tech industry (so revoke from those outside the 9th circuit first).

Quoted 9 lines

For easy to read by lay-people discussions on this topic:
lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/4/334 [1] lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/3/698 [2]

For legal articles and treatises that agree: no consideration from GPL
free-taker, no contract, revocable by the copyright holder:
scholarship.law.duke.edu/faculty_scholarship/1857/ [3]

www.amazon.com/Open-Source-Licensing-Software-Intellectual/dp/0131487876

Quoted 6 lines

[4] papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=243237 [5]

Sincerely;
Pro-Bono Attorney

Quoted 6 lines

(Note: all discussion herein is in relevance to US law)
_______________________________________________
[email protected] mailing list
https://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-chat
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[email protected]"

Links:
------
[1] http://lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/4/334
[2] http://lkml.org/lkml/2019/5/3/698
[3] http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/faculty_scholarship/1857/
[4]
http://www.amazon.com/Open-Source-Licensing-Software-Intellectual/dp/0131487876
[5] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=243237