Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Yet another hang after network disruption or smb restart -- multiple file writers

DISCUSSION Frank Sorenson 3 participants 3 messages Oct 25, 2019 – Oct 26, 2019

Subsystems (2)
lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

fI'm testing out multiple processes simultaneously doing an open/read/write/close of the same file + smb restart test (next step after the open/read/close + smb restart), and I'm hitting a different hang.

It's a bit more complex, so I haven't been able to unravel it like the other hangs.

I'm using upstream 531e93d11470 with additional patches to fix the recent crashes and deadlocks that the multiple-process open/read/close + smb restart test hits:

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <[email protected]>
Date:   2019-10-23 15:55:40 -0700

CIFS: Fix use after free of file info structures

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <piastryyy@xxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-22 15:35:34 -0700

CIFS: Fix retry mid list corruption on reconnects

Author: Dave Wysochanski <dwysocha@xxxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-23 22:08:22 -0400

cifs: Fix cifsInodeInfo lock_sem deadlock when reconnect occurs

(I've hit this hang both with and without the 'lock_sem deadlock' patch, so at least the patch does not make things worse)

on the client, I'm running 50 processes:
fd = open(testfile_path, O_RDWR|O_CREAT, 0644)
read(fd, buf, 32768);
write(fd, testfile_path, strlen(testfile_path);
close(fd);

on smb server (once):
systemctl restart smb.service

there are 6 processes looping to while trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem, 5 of them from _cifsFileInfo_put, and one from cifs_new_fileinfo

and there are 5 other processes which are blocked, several of them waiting on either PG_writeback or PG_locked (which are both set), all for the same page of the file

2 inode_lock() (inode->i_rwsem) for the file
1 wait_on_page_writeback() for the page
1 down_read(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 inode_lock()(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 __lock_page

so processes are blocked waiting on:
page flags PG_locked and PG_writeback for one specific page inode->i_rwsem for the directory
inode->i_rwsem for the file cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem

here are the more gory details (let me know if I need to provide anything more/better):

[0 00:48:22.765] [UN] PID: 8863 TASK: ffff8c691547c5c0 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007e3ba8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007e3c38] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007e3c48] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965007e3cb8] legitimize_path at ffffffff9b0f975d #4 [ffff9965007e3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe55d
#5 [ffff9965007e3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33 #6 [ffff9965007e3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#7 [ffff9965007e3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315
* (I think legitimize_path is bogus)

in path_openat

        } else {
                const char *s = path_init(nd, flags);
                while (!(error = link_path_walk(s, nd)) &&
                        (error = do_last(nd, file, op)) > 0) {  <<<<

do_last:
if (open_flag & O_CREAT)
inode_lock(dir->d_inode); <<<<
else
so it's trying to take inode->i_rwsem for the directory

DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68bb8e79c0 ffff8c691158ef20 ffff8c6915bf9000 DIR /mnt/vm1_smb/ inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c691158efc0

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c691158efc0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914275d00> (UN -   8856 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 2
        0xffff9965007e3c90     8863   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.926
  RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE
        0xffff996500393e00     9802   ls               UN 0  1:17:26.700

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_READ

the owner of the inode.i_rwsem of the directory is:

[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8856 TASK: ffff8c6914275d00 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650065b828] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650065b8b8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650065b8c8] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff99650065b940] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff99650065b948] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff99650065ba38] cifs_writepage_locked at ffffffffc0a0b8f3 [cifs] #6 [ffff99650065bab0] cifs_launder_page at ffffffffc0a0bb72 [cifs] #7 [ffff99650065bb30] invalidate_inode_pages2_range at ffffffff9b04d4bd #8 [ffff99650065bcb8] cifs_invalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a11339 [cifs] #9 [ffff99650065bcd0] cifs_revalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a1139a [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650065bcf0] cifs_d_revalidate at ffffffffc0a014f6 [cifs] #11 [ffff99650065bd08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe7f7
#12 [ffff99650065bdd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#13 [ffff99650065bee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#14 [ffff99650065bf38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

cifs_launder_page is for page 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

crash> page.index,mapping,flags 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

      index = 0x8
      mapping = 0xffff8c68f3cd0db0

flags = 0xfffffc0008095

  PAGE-FLAG       BIT  VALUE
  PG_locked         0  0000001
  PG_uptodate       2  0000004
  PG_lru            4  0000010
  PG_waiters        7  0000080
  PG_writeback     15  0008000

inode is ffff8c68f3cd0c40
inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c68f3cd0ce0
DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68a1f1b480 ffff8c68f3cd0c40 ffff8c6915bf9000 REG /mnt/vm1_smb/testfile.8853

this process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the parent directory, is laundering a page attached to the inode of the file it's opening, and in _cifsFileInfo_put is trying to down_write the cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem for the file itself.

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c68f3cd0ce0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914272e80> (UN -   8854 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 1
        0xffff9965005dfd80     8855   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.912

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE

this is the inode.i_rwsem for the file

the owner:

[0 00:48:22.739] [UN] PID: 8854 TASK: ffff8c6914272e80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650054fb38] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650054fbc8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650054fbd8] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff99650054fbe8] __lock_page at ffffffff9b03c56f
#4 [ffff99650054fc80] pagecache_get_page at ffffffff9b03dcdf
#5 [ffff99650054fcc0] grab_cache_page_write_begin at ffffffff9b03ef4c #6 [ffff99650054fcd0] cifs_write_begin at ffffffffc0a064ec [cifs] #7 [ffff99650054fd30] generic_perform_write at ffffffff9b03bba4 #8 [ffff99650054fda8] __generic_file_write_iter at ffffffff9b04060a #9 [ffff99650054fdf0] cifs_strict_writev.cold.70 at ffffffffc0a4469b [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650054fe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd
#11 [ffff99650054fed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#12 [ffff99650054ff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#13 [ffff99650054ff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

the process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the file to which it's writing, and is trying to __lock_page for the same page as in the other processes

the other tasks:
[0 00:00:00.028] [UN] PID: 8859 TASK: ffff8c6915479740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007b39d8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007b3a68] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007b3a78] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007b3af0] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007b3af8] cifs_new_fileinfo.cold.61 at ffffffffc0a42a07 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007b3b78] cifs_open at ffffffffc0a0709d [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007b3cd8] do_dentry_open at ffffffff9b0e9b7a
#7 [ffff9965007b3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe34f
#8 [ffff9965007b3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#9 [ffff9965007b3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#10 [ffff9965007b3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

this is opening the file, and is trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem

[0 00:00:00.041] [UN] PID: 8860 TASK: ffff8c691547ae80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.057] [UN] PID: 8861 TASK: ffff8c6915478000 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.059] [UN] PID: 8858 TASK: ffff8c6914271740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8862 TASK: ffff8c691547dd00 CPU: 6
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007c3c78] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007c3d08] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007c3d18] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007c3d90] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007c3d98] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007c3e88] cifs_close at ffffffffc0a07aaf [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007c3ea0] __fput at ffffffff9b0efa6e
#7 [ffff9965007c3ee8] task_work_run at ffffffff9aef1614
#8 [ffff9965007c3f20] exit_to_usermode_loop at ffffffff9ae03d6f #9 [ffff9965007c3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae0444c

closing the file, and trying to down_write cifsi->lock_sem

[0 00:48:22.839] [UN] PID: 8857 TASK: ffff8c6914270000 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965006a7cc8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965006a7d58] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965006a7d68] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff9965006a7d78] wait_on_page_bit at ffffffff9b03cac6 #4 [ffff9965006a7e10] __filemap_fdatawait_range at ffffffff9b03b028 #5 [ffff9965006a7ed8] filemap_write_and_wait at ffffffff9b040165 #6 [ffff9965006a7ef0] cifs_flush at ffffffffc0a0c2fa [cifs] #7 [ffff9965006a7f10] filp_close at ffffffff9b0e93f1
#8 [ffff9965006a7f30] __x64_sys_close at ffffffff9b0e9a0e #9 [ffff9965006a7f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in __filemap_fdatawait_range

                        wait_on_page_writeback(page);

for the same page of the file

[0 00:48:22.718] [UN] PID: 8855 TASK: ffff8c69142745c0 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965005dfc98] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965005dfd28] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965005dfd38] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965005dfdf0] cifs_strict_writev at ffffffffc0a0c40a [cifs] #4 [ffff9965005dfe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd #5 [ffff9965005dfed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#6 [ffff9965005dff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#7 [ffff9965005dff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

        inode_lock(inode);

and one 'ls' later on, to see whether the rest of the mount is available (the test file is in the root, so we get blocked up on the directory ->i_rwsem), so the entire mount is unavailable

[0 00:36:26.473] [UN] PID: 9802 TASK: ffff8c691436ae80 CPU: 4
COMMAND: "ls"
#0 [ffff996500393d28] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff996500393db8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff996500393dc8] rwsem_down_read_slowpath at ffffffff9b6e9421 #3 [ffff996500393e78] down_read_killable at ffffffff9b6e95e2 #4 [ffff996500393e88] iterate_dir at ffffffff9b103c56 #5 [ffff996500393ec8] ksys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104b0c #6 [ffff996500393f30] __x64_sys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104bb6 #7 [ffff996500393f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in iterate_dir:

        if (shared)
                res = down_read_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);  <<<<
        else
                res = down_write_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);

mount looks like:
271 97 0:51 / /mnt/vm1_smb rw,relatime shared:143 - cifs //vm1/cifs rw,vers=2.1,sec=ntlmssp,cache=strict,username=user1,uid=0,noforceuid,gid=0,noforcegid,addr=192.168.122.73,file_mode=0755,dir_mode=0755,hard,nounix,serverino,mapposix,rsize=1048576,wsize=1048576,bsize=1048576,echo_interval=60,actimeo=1

# cat /proc/fs/cifs/DebugData
Display Internal CIFS Data Structures for Debugging
---------------------------------------------------
CIFS Version 2.23
Features:
DFS,STATS2,DEBUG,ALLOW_INSECURE_LEGACY,WEAK_PW_HASH,CIFS_POSIX,UPCALL(SPNEGO),XATTR,ACL
CIFSMaxBufSize: 16384
Active VFS Requests: 2
Servers:
Number of credits: 241 Dialect 0x210
1) Name: 192.168.122.73 Uses: 1 Capability: 0x300007	Session Status: 1
TCP status: 1 Instance: 3
	Local Users To Server: 1 SecMode: 0x1 Req On Wire: 0 In Send: 0 In
MaxReq Wait: 0 SessionId: 0xd90a3306
	Shares:
	0) IPC: \\vm1\IPC$ Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x0 Attributes: 0x0
	PathComponentMax: 0 Status: 1 type: 0 Serial Number: 0x0
	1) \\vm1\cifs Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x20 Attributes: 0x1006f
	PathComponentMax: 255 Status: 1 type: DISK Serial Number: 0x0

	MIDs:

Frank
--
Frank Sorenson
[email protected]
Principal Software Maintenance Engineer
Global Support Services - filesystems
Red Hat

#1 lore raw

пт, 25 окт. 2019 г. в 13:52, Frank Sorenson <[email protected]>:

Quoted 313 lines

fI'm testing out multiple processes simultaneously doing an open/read/write/close of the same file + smb restart test (next step after the open/read/close + smb restart), and I'm hitting a different hang.

It's a bit more complex, so I haven't been able to unravel it like the other hangs.

I'm using upstream 531e93d11470 with additional patches to fix the recent crashes and deadlocks that the multiple-process open/read/close + smb restart test hits:

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <[email protected]>
Date:   2019-10-23 15:55:40 -0700

CIFS: Fix use after free of file info structures

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <piastryyy@xxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-22 15:35:34 -0700

CIFS: Fix retry mid list corruption on reconnects

Author: Dave Wysochanski <dwysocha@xxxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-23 22:08:22 -0400

cifs: Fix cifsInodeInfo lock_sem deadlock when reconnect occurs

(I've hit this hang both with and without the 'lock_sem deadlock' patch, so at least the patch does not make things worse)

on the client, I'm running 50 processes:
fd = open(testfile_path, O_RDWR|O_CREAT, 0644)
read(fd, buf, 32768);
write(fd, testfile_path, strlen(testfile_path);
close(fd);

on smb server (once):
systemctl restart smb.service

there are 6 processes looping to while trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem, 5 of them from _cifsFileInfo_put, and one from cifs_new_fileinfo

and there are 5 other processes which are blocked, several of them waiting on either PG_writeback or PG_locked (which are both set), all for the same page of the file

2 inode_lock() (inode->i_rwsem) for the file
1 wait_on_page_writeback() for the page
1 down_read(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 inode_lock()(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 __lock_page

so processes are blocked waiting on:
page flags PG_locked and PG_writeback for one specific page inode->i_rwsem for the directory
inode->i_rwsem for the file cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem

here are the more gory details (let me know if I need to provide anything more/better):

[0 00:48:22.765] [UN] PID: 8863 TASK: ffff8c691547c5c0 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007e3ba8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007e3c38] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007e3c48] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965007e3cb8] legitimize_path at ffffffff9b0f975d #4 [ffff9965007e3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe55d
#5 [ffff9965007e3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33 #6 [ffff9965007e3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#7 [ffff9965007e3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315
* (I think legitimize_path is bogus)

in path_openat

        } else {
                const char *s = path_init(nd, flags);
                while (!(error = link_path_walk(s, nd)) &&
                        (error = do_last(nd, file, op)) > 0) {  <<<<

do_last:
if (open_flag & O_CREAT)
inode_lock(dir->d_inode); <<<<
else
so it's trying to take inode->i_rwsem for the directory

DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68bb8e79c0 ffff8c691158ef20 ffff8c6915bf9000 DIR /mnt/vm1_smb/ inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c691158efc0

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c691158efc0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914275d00> (UN -   8856 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 2
        0xffff9965007e3c90     8863   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.926
  RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE
        0xffff996500393e00     9802   ls               UN 0  1:17:26.700

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_READ

the owner of the inode.i_rwsem of the directory is:

[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8856 TASK: ffff8c6914275d00 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650065b828] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650065b8b8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650065b8c8] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff99650065b940] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff99650065b948] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff99650065ba38] cifs_writepage_locked at ffffffffc0a0b8f3 [cifs] #6 [ffff99650065bab0] cifs_launder_page at ffffffffc0a0bb72 [cifs] #7 [ffff99650065bb30] invalidate_inode_pages2_range at ffffffff9b04d4bd #8 [ffff99650065bcb8] cifs_invalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a11339 [cifs] #9 [ffff99650065bcd0] cifs_revalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a1139a [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650065bcf0] cifs_d_revalidate at ffffffffc0a014f6 [cifs] #11 [ffff99650065bd08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe7f7
#12 [ffff99650065bdd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#13 [ffff99650065bee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#14 [ffff99650065bf38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

cifs_launder_page is for page 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

crash> page.index,mapping,flags 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

      index = 0x8
      mapping = 0xffff8c68f3cd0db0

flags = 0xfffffc0008095

  PAGE-FLAG       BIT  VALUE
  PG_locked         0  0000001
  PG_uptodate       2  0000004
  PG_lru            4  0000010
  PG_waiters        7  0000080
  PG_writeback     15  0008000

inode is ffff8c68f3cd0c40
inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c68f3cd0ce0
DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68a1f1b480 ffff8c68f3cd0c40 ffff8c6915bf9000 REG /mnt/vm1_smb/testfile.8853

this process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the parent directory, is laundering a page attached to the inode of the file it's opening, and in _cifsFileInfo_put is trying to down_write the cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem for the file itself.

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c68f3cd0ce0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914272e80> (UN -   8854 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 1
        0xffff9965005dfd80     8855   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.912

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE

this is the inode.i_rwsem for the file

the owner:

[0 00:48:22.739] [UN] PID: 8854 TASK: ffff8c6914272e80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650054fb38] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650054fbc8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650054fbd8] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff99650054fbe8] __lock_page at ffffffff9b03c56f
#4 [ffff99650054fc80] pagecache_get_page at ffffffff9b03dcdf
#5 [ffff99650054fcc0] grab_cache_page_write_begin at ffffffff9b03ef4c #6 [ffff99650054fcd0] cifs_write_begin at ffffffffc0a064ec [cifs] #7 [ffff99650054fd30] generic_perform_write at ffffffff9b03bba4 #8 [ffff99650054fda8] __generic_file_write_iter at ffffffff9b04060a #9 [ffff99650054fdf0] cifs_strict_writev.cold.70 at ffffffffc0a4469b [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650054fe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd
#11 [ffff99650054fed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#12 [ffff99650054ff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#13 [ffff99650054ff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

the process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the file to which it's writing, and is trying to __lock_page for the same page as in the other processes

the other tasks:
[0 00:00:00.028] [UN] PID: 8859 TASK: ffff8c6915479740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007b39d8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007b3a68] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007b3a78] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007b3af0] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007b3af8] cifs_new_fileinfo.cold.61 at ffffffffc0a42a07 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007b3b78] cifs_open at ffffffffc0a0709d [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007b3cd8] do_dentry_open at ffffffff9b0e9b7a
#7 [ffff9965007b3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe34f
#8 [ffff9965007b3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#9 [ffff9965007b3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#10 [ffff9965007b3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

this is opening the file, and is trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem

[0 00:00:00.041] [UN] PID: 8860 TASK: ffff8c691547ae80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.057] [UN] PID: 8861 TASK: ffff8c6915478000 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.059] [UN] PID: 8858 TASK: ffff8c6914271740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8862 TASK: ffff8c691547dd00 CPU: 6
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007c3c78] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007c3d08] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007c3d18] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007c3d90] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007c3d98] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007c3e88] cifs_close at ffffffffc0a07aaf [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007c3ea0] __fput at ffffffff9b0efa6e
#7 [ffff9965007c3ee8] task_work_run at ffffffff9aef1614
#8 [ffff9965007c3f20] exit_to_usermode_loop at ffffffff9ae03d6f #9 [ffff9965007c3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae0444c

closing the file, and trying to down_write cifsi->lock_sem

[0 00:48:22.839] [UN] PID: 8857 TASK: ffff8c6914270000 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965006a7cc8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965006a7d58] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965006a7d68] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff9965006a7d78] wait_on_page_bit at ffffffff9b03cac6 #4 [ffff9965006a7e10] __filemap_fdatawait_range at ffffffff9b03b028 #5 [ffff9965006a7ed8] filemap_write_and_wait at ffffffff9b040165 #6 [ffff9965006a7ef0] cifs_flush at ffffffffc0a0c2fa [cifs] #7 [ffff9965006a7f10] filp_close at ffffffff9b0e93f1
#8 [ffff9965006a7f30] __x64_sys_close at ffffffff9b0e9a0e #9 [ffff9965006a7f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in __filemap_fdatawait_range

                        wait_on_page_writeback(page);

for the same page of the file

[0 00:48:22.718] [UN] PID: 8855 TASK: ffff8c69142745c0 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965005dfc98] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965005dfd28] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965005dfd38] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965005dfdf0] cifs_strict_writev at ffffffffc0a0c40a [cifs] #4 [ffff9965005dfe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd #5 [ffff9965005dfed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#6 [ffff9965005dff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#7 [ffff9965005dff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

        inode_lock(inode);

and one 'ls' later on, to see whether the rest of the mount is available (the test file is in the root, so we get blocked up on the directory ->i_rwsem), so the entire mount is unavailable

[0 00:36:26.473] [UN] PID: 9802 TASK: ffff8c691436ae80 CPU: 4
COMMAND: "ls"
#0 [ffff996500393d28] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff996500393db8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff996500393dc8] rwsem_down_read_slowpath at ffffffff9b6e9421 #3 [ffff996500393e78] down_read_killable at ffffffff9b6e95e2 #4 [ffff996500393e88] iterate_dir at ffffffff9b103c56 #5 [ffff996500393ec8] ksys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104b0c #6 [ffff996500393f30] __x64_sys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104bb6 #7 [ffff996500393f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in iterate_dir:

        if (shared)
                res = down_read_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);  <<<<
        else
                res = down_write_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);

mount looks like:
271 97 0:51 / /mnt/vm1_smb rw,relatime shared:143 - cifs //vm1/cifs rw,vers=2.1,sec=ntlmssp,cache=strict,username=user1,uid=0,noforceuid,gid=0,noforcegid,addr=192.168.122.73,file_mode=0755,dir_mode=0755,hard,nounix,serverino,mapposix,rsize=1048576,wsize=1048576,bsize=1048576,echo_interval=60,actimeo=1

# cat /proc/fs/cifs/DebugData
Display Internal CIFS Data Structures for Debugging
---------------------------------------------------
CIFS Version 2.23
Features:
DFS,STATS2,DEBUG,ALLOW_INSECURE_LEGACY,WEAK_PW_HASH,CIFS_POSIX,UPCALL(SPNEGO),XATTR,ACL
CIFSMaxBufSize: 16384
Active VFS Requests: 2
Servers:
Number of credits: 241 Dialect 0x210
1) Name: 192.168.122.73 Uses: 1 Capability: 0x300007    Session Status: 1
TCP status: 1 Instance: 3
        Local Users To Server: 1 SecMode: 0x1 Req On Wire: 0 In Send: 0 In
MaxReq Wait: 0 SessionId: 0xd90a3306
        Shares:
        0) IPC: \\vm1\IPC$ Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x0 Attributes: 0x0
        PathComponentMax: 0 Status: 1 type: 0 Serial Number: 0x0

1) \\vm1\cifs Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x20 Attributes: 0x1006f
PathComponentMax: 255 Status: 1 type: DISK Serial Number: 0x0

MIDs:

Quoted 7 lines

Frank
--
Frank Sorenson
[email protected]
Principal Software Maintenance Engineer
Global Support Services - filesystems
Red Hat

Hi Frank,

Thanks for the detailed analysis. So, there is a deadlock between a page lock and a cinode->lock_sem.

It seems that the easiest fix would be to change all the places where we use get/put reference to a file info to offload the last step (to put a file info back) into a work queue, so, it can be lazily closed from a separate process that doesn't hold other locks.

--
Best regards,
Pavel Shilovsky

#2 lore raw
Quoted 325 lines · Pavel Shilovsky

пт, 25 окт. 2019 г. в 13:52, Frank Sorenson <[email protected]>:

Quoted 313 lines

fI'm testing out multiple processes simultaneously doing an open/read/write/close of the same file + smb restart test (next step after the open/read/close + smb restart), and I'm hitting a different hang.

It's a bit more complex, so I haven't been able to unravel it like the other hangs.

I'm using upstream 531e93d11470 with additional patches to fix the recent crashes and deadlocks that the multiple-process open/read/close + smb restart test hits:

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <[email protected]>
Date:   2019-10-23 15:55:40 -0700

CIFS: Fix use after free of file info structures

Author: Pavel Shilovsky <piastryyy@xxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-22 15:35:34 -0700

CIFS: Fix retry mid list corruption on reconnects

Author: Dave Wysochanski <dwysocha@xxxxxxxxxx>
Date:   2019-10-23 22:08:22 -0400

cifs: Fix cifsInodeInfo lock_sem deadlock when reconnect occurs

(I've hit this hang both with and without the 'lock_sem deadlock' patch, so at least the patch does not make things worse)

on the client, I'm running 50 processes:
fd = open(testfile_path, O_RDWR|O_CREAT, 0644)
read(fd, buf, 32768);
write(fd, testfile_path, strlen(testfile_path);
close(fd);

on smb server (once):
systemctl restart smb.service

there are 6 processes looping to while trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem, 5 of them from _cifsFileInfo_put, and one from cifs_new_fileinfo

and there are 5 other processes which are blocked, several of them waiting on either PG_writeback or PG_locked (which are both set), all for the same page of the file

2 inode_lock() (inode->i_rwsem) for the file
1 wait_on_page_writeback() for the page
1 down_read(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 inode_lock()(inode->i_rwsem) for the inode of the directory 1 __lock_page

so processes are blocked waiting on:
page flags PG_locked and PG_writeback for one specific page inode->i_rwsem for the directory
inode->i_rwsem for the file cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem

here are the more gory details (let me know if I need to provide anything more/better):

[0 00:48:22.765] [UN] PID: 8863 TASK: ffff8c691547c5c0 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007e3ba8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007e3c38] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007e3c48] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965007e3cb8] legitimize_path at ffffffff9b0f975d #4 [ffff9965007e3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe55d
#5 [ffff9965007e3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33 #6 [ffff9965007e3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#7 [ffff9965007e3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315
* (I think legitimize_path is bogus)

in path_openat

        } else {
                const char *s = path_init(nd, flags);
                while (!(error = link_path_walk(s, nd)) &&
                        (error = do_last(nd, file, op)) > 0) {  <<<<

do_last:
if (open_flag & O_CREAT)
inode_lock(dir->d_inode); <<<<
else
so it's trying to take inode->i_rwsem for the directory

DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68bb8e79c0 ffff8c691158ef20 ffff8c6915bf9000 DIR /mnt/vm1_smb/ inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c691158efc0

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c691158efc0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914275d00> (UN -   8856 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 2
        0xffff9965007e3c90     8863   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.926
  RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE
        0xffff996500393e00     9802   ls               UN 0  1:17:26.700

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_READ

the owner of the inode.i_rwsem of the directory is:

[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8856 TASK: ffff8c6914275d00 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650065b828] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650065b8b8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650065b8c8] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff99650065b940] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff99650065b948] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff99650065ba38] cifs_writepage_locked at ffffffffc0a0b8f3 [cifs] #6 [ffff99650065bab0] cifs_launder_page at ffffffffc0a0bb72 [cifs] #7 [ffff99650065bb30] invalidate_inode_pages2_range at ffffffff9b04d4bd #8 [ffff99650065bcb8] cifs_invalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a11339 [cifs] #9 [ffff99650065bcd0] cifs_revalidate_mapping at ffffffffc0a1139a [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650065bcf0] cifs_d_revalidate at ffffffffc0a014f6 [cifs] #11 [ffff99650065bd08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe7f7
#12 [ffff99650065bdd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#13 [ffff99650065bee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#14 [ffff99650065bf38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

cifs_launder_page is for page 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

crash> page.index,mapping,flags 0xffffd1e2c07d2480

      index = 0x8
      mapping = 0xffff8c68f3cd0db0

flags = 0xfffffc0008095

  PAGE-FLAG       BIT  VALUE
  PG_locked         0  0000001
  PG_uptodate       2  0000004
  PG_lru            4  0000010
  PG_waiters        7  0000080
  PG_writeback     15  0008000

inode is ffff8c68f3cd0c40
inode.i_rwsem is ffff8c68f3cd0ce0
DENTRY INODE SUPERBLK TYPE PATH
ffff8c68a1f1b480 ffff8c68f3cd0c40 ffff8c6915bf9000 REG /mnt/vm1_smb/testfile.8853

this process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the parent directory, is laundering a page attached to the inode of the file it's opening, and in _cifsFileInfo_put is trying to down_write the cifsInodeInfo->lock_sem for the file itself.

<struct rw_semaphore 0xffff8c68f3cd0ce0>:

        owner: <struct task_struct 0xffff8c6914272e80> (UN -   8854 -
reopen_file), counter: 0x0000000000000003
        waitlist: 1
        0xffff9965005dfd80     8855   reopen_file      UN 0  1:29:22.912

RWSEM_WAITING_FOR_WRITE

this is the inode.i_rwsem for the file

the owner:

[0 00:48:22.739] [UN] PID: 8854 TASK: ffff8c6914272e80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff99650054fb38] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff99650054fbc8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff99650054fbd8] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff99650054fbe8] __lock_page at ffffffff9b03c56f
#4 [ffff99650054fc80] pagecache_get_page at ffffffff9b03dcdf
#5 [ffff99650054fcc0] grab_cache_page_write_begin at ffffffff9b03ef4c #6 [ffff99650054fcd0] cifs_write_begin at ffffffffc0a064ec [cifs] #7 [ffff99650054fd30] generic_perform_write at ffffffff9b03bba4 #8 [ffff99650054fda8] __generic_file_write_iter at ffffffff9b04060a #9 [ffff99650054fdf0] cifs_strict_writev.cold.70 at ffffffffc0a4469b [cifs]
#10 [ffff99650054fe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd
#11 [ffff99650054fed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#12 [ffff99650054ff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#13 [ffff99650054ff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

the process holds the inode->i_rwsem for the file to which it's writing, and is trying to __lock_page for the same page as in the other processes

the other tasks:
[0 00:00:00.028] [UN] PID: 8859 TASK: ffff8c6915479740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007b39d8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007b3a68] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007b3a78] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007b3af0] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007b3af8] cifs_new_fileinfo.cold.61 at ffffffffc0a42a07 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007b3b78] cifs_open at ffffffffc0a0709d [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007b3cd8] do_dentry_open at ffffffff9b0e9b7a
#7 [ffff9965007b3d08] path_openat at ffffffff9b0fe34f
#8 [ffff9965007b3dd8] do_filp_open at ffffffff9b100a33
#9 [ffff9965007b3ee0] do_sys_open at ffffffff9b0eb2d6
#10 [ffff9965007b3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

this is opening the file, and is trying to down_write cinode->lock_sem

[0 00:00:00.041] [UN] PID: 8860 TASK: ffff8c691547ae80 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.057] [UN] PID: 8861 TASK: ffff8c6915478000 CPU: 3
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.059] [UN] PID: 8858 TASK: ffff8c6914271740 CPU: 2
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
[0 00:00:00.109] [UN] PID: 8862 TASK: ffff8c691547dd00 CPU: 6
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965007c3c78] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965007c3d08] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965007c3d18] schedule_timeout at ffffffff9b6e9f89
#3 [ffff9965007c3d90] msleep at ffffffff9af573a9
#4 [ffff9965007c3d98] _cifsFileInfo_put.cold.63 at ffffffffc0a42dd6 [cifs] #5 [ffff9965007c3e88] cifs_close at ffffffffc0a07aaf [cifs]
#6 [ffff9965007c3ea0] __fput at ffffffff9b0efa6e
#7 [ffff9965007c3ee8] task_work_run at ffffffff9aef1614
#8 [ffff9965007c3f20] exit_to_usermode_loop at ffffffff9ae03d6f #9 [ffff9965007c3f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae0444c

closing the file, and trying to down_write cifsi->lock_sem

[0 00:48:22.839] [UN] PID: 8857 TASK: ffff8c6914270000 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965006a7cc8] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965006a7d58] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965006a7d68] io_schedule at ffffffff9b6e68e2
#3 [ffff9965006a7d78] wait_on_page_bit at ffffffff9b03cac6 #4 [ffff9965006a7e10] __filemap_fdatawait_range at ffffffff9b03b028 #5 [ffff9965006a7ed8] filemap_write_and_wait at ffffffff9b040165 #6 [ffff9965006a7ef0] cifs_flush at ffffffffc0a0c2fa [cifs] #7 [ffff9965006a7f10] filp_close at ffffffff9b0e93f1
#8 [ffff9965006a7f30] __x64_sys_close at ffffffff9b0e9a0e #9 [ffff9965006a7f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in __filemap_fdatawait_range

                        wait_on_page_writeback(page);

for the same page of the file

[0 00:48:22.718] [UN] PID: 8855 TASK: ffff8c69142745c0 CPU: 7
COMMAND: "reopen_file"
#0 [ffff9965005dfc98] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff9965005dfd28] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff9965005dfd38] rwsem_down_write_slowpath at ffffffff9af283d7 #3 [ffff9965005dfdf0] cifs_strict_writev at ffffffffc0a0c40a [cifs] #4 [ffff9965005dfe48] new_sync_write at ffffffff9b0ec1dd #5 [ffff9965005dfed0] vfs_write at ffffffff9b0eed35
#6 [ffff9965005dff00] ksys_write at ffffffff9b0eefd9
#7 [ffff9965005dff38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

        inode_lock(inode);

and one 'ls' later on, to see whether the rest of the mount is available (the test file is in the root, so we get blocked up on the directory ->i_rwsem), so the entire mount is unavailable

[0 00:36:26.473] [UN] PID: 9802 TASK: ffff8c691436ae80 CPU: 4
COMMAND: "ls"
#0 [ffff996500393d28] __schedule at ffffffff9b6e6095
#1 [ffff996500393db8] schedule at ffffffff9b6e64df
#2 [ffff996500393dc8] rwsem_down_read_slowpath at ffffffff9b6e9421 #3 [ffff996500393e78] down_read_killable at ffffffff9b6e95e2 #4 [ffff996500393e88] iterate_dir at ffffffff9b103c56 #5 [ffff996500393ec8] ksys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104b0c #6 [ffff996500393f30] __x64_sys_getdents64 at ffffffff9b104bb6 #7 [ffff996500393f38] do_syscall_64 at ffffffff9ae04315

in iterate_dir:

        if (shared)
                res = down_read_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);  <<<<
        else
                res = down_write_killable(&inode->i_rwsem);

mount looks like:
271 97 0:51 / /mnt/vm1_smb rw,relatime shared:143 - cifs //vm1/cifs rw,vers=2.1,sec=ntlmssp,cache=strict,username=user1,uid=0,noforceuid,gid=0,noforcegid,addr=192.168.122.73,file_mode=0755,dir_mode=0755,hard,nounix,serverino,mapposix,rsize=1048576,wsize=1048576,bsize=1048576,echo_interval=60,actimeo=1

# cat /proc/fs/cifs/DebugData
Display Internal CIFS Data Structures for Debugging
---------------------------------------------------
CIFS Version 2.23
Features:
DFS,STATS2,DEBUG,ALLOW_INSECURE_LEGACY,WEAK_PW_HASH,CIFS_POSIX,UPCALL(SPNEGO),XATTR,ACL
CIFSMaxBufSize: 16384
Active VFS Requests: 2
Servers:
Number of credits: 241 Dialect 0x210
1) Name: 192.168.122.73 Uses: 1 Capability: 0x300007    Session Status: 1
TCP status: 1 Instance: 3
        Local Users To Server: 1 SecMode: 0x1 Req On Wire: 0 In Send: 0 In
MaxReq Wait: 0 SessionId: 0xd90a3306
        Shares:
        0) IPC: \\vm1\IPC$ Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x0 Attributes: 0x0
        PathComponentMax: 0 Status: 1 type: 0 Serial Number: 0x0

1) \\vm1\cifs Mounts: 1 DevInfo: 0x20 Attributes: 0x1006f
PathComponentMax: 255 Status: 1 type: DISK Serial Number: 0x0

MIDs:

Quoted 7 lines

Frank
--
Frank Sorenson
[email protected]
Principal Software Maintenance Engineer
Global Support Services - filesystems
Red Hat

Hi Frank,

Quoted 9 lines

Thanks for the detailed analysis. So, there is a deadlock between a page lock and a cinode->lock_sem.

It seems that the easiest fix would be to change all the places where we use get/put reference to a file info to offload the last step (to put a file info back) into a work queue, so, it can be lazily closed from a separate process that doesn't hold other locks.

I have also reproduced this while testing the latest patches.

I agree with what you're suggesting - sounds like a good approach.

Thanks.