Not a typewriter
On 05/11/2001 at 04:43:13 PM Hacksaw <[email protected]> wrote:
<snip>
Quoted 5 lines
Well, I can't disagree. Unix's biggest turn off was the stupid command names. It's a big reason why Unixoid systems aren't more commonplace. I only learned it because I was stuck at a desk with a Wyse terminal. Otherwise I probably would have played with the Autocad machines more. Once I understood the basics, I understood the power of the system.
My first exposure to Unix came in 1987 when I was assigned to write a datacomm package in C on a Unix (AIX) workstation the company had just bought. I was the only one in our shop who knew C, and no one else there had ever dealt with Unix either. (I had heard of Unix, but didn't know anything about it.) My training consisted of my boss handing me the manuals and saying, "Figure it out." For the first two weeks I absolutely HATED that system; nothing made sense, vi seemed insane, and I was stumbling blindly through the documentation (I'd never seen a permuted index before). Then suddenly something clicked, it all started to make sense, and I fell in love with it. That's why I think it's so important for people to learn the Unix mindset before trying to deal with Unix systems. It's also why I have so little patience with people who don't have the patience to work through the learning curve.
<snip>
Quoted 3 lines
But first we need a better help system. The absolute most stupid convention of Unix is the man command. The fact that SCCS before, and now Bash usurp the keyword "help" is beyond the pale.
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree, because we have exactly opposite opinions on all this. I love the short, cryptic command names, and I think man is the best help system ever devised. (The GNU Info system, however, is the spawn of Satan. :-) In case you haven't guessed, I love vi, too, and use it whenever possible. If Unix (or Linux) ever gets to the point of losing things like this, I'll have no desire to use it.
Wayne
[email protected] wrote on 11.05.01 in <[email protected]>:
Quoted 2 lines
I think man is the best help system ever devised. (The GNU Info system, however, is the spawn of Satan. :-)
Both have good and bad parts. HTML and PDF are yet other such candidates.
Something better is needed, but no two people seem to agree on what exactly it should be.
What I want: search support at least as good as Info (which is not very, but better than the other two); structure like man; support for both short refcard style and long reference book style treatments; one standard format that can be supported on console, X, or via a Web interface ... oh, and standard key bindings at least don't force people to play at Emacs.
MfG Kai