alevt-dvb 1.7.0: new version, should be free from bugs now
Hi,
my way to say "Thank you".
Just enjoy this tiny little program with the latest kernel. Debian files for producing a Debian binary included. This version needs libzvbi as dependency to run. Thanks to Tom Zoerne for the implemention patch that I found by accident.
Cheers
CS
P. S.: There are two issues in the TODO list.
Please drop me a note if you can fix those issues mentioned there.
ENJOY!
Quoted 10 lines · Chicken Shack
Hi,
my way to say "Thank you".
Just enjoy this tiny little program with the latest kernel. Debian files for producing a Debian binary included. This version needs libzvbi as dependency to run. Thanks to Tom Zoerne for the implemention patch that I found by accident.
Quoted 7 lines
Cheers
CSP. S.: There are two issues in the TODO list.
Please drop me a note if you can fix those issues mentioned there.ENJOY!
What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under v4l2-apps/util/)? AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site where development could take place.
I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it was hosted in vl4-dvb, and it could be an additional testing tool useful for drivers development.
And it is GPL-licensed.
Francesco
Am Samstag, den 13.02.2010, 10:56 +0100 schrieb Francesco Lavra:
Quoted 27 lines · Chicken Shack
Quoted 10 lines
Hi,
my way to say "Thank you".
Just enjoy this tiny little program with the latest kernel. Debian files for producing a Debian binary included. This version needs libzvbi as dependency to run. Thanks to Tom Zoerne for the implemention patch that I found by accident.Quoted 7 lines
Cheers
CSP. S.: There are two issues in the TODO list.
Please drop me a note if you can fix those issues mentioned there.ENJOY!
What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under v4l2-apps/util/)? AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site where development could take place.
I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it was hosted in vl4-dvb, and it could be an additional testing tool useful for drivers development.
And it is GPL-licensed.
Quoted 1 line
Francesco
Hi Francesco,
I wish your point of view were right. But it isn't at all.
There are a couple of reasons for that:
1. As long as there is not at least one person doing the necessary DVB maintenance sponsored by some industry there will never be a significant change at all.
The roots of the DVB project were a company called Convergence media in Cologne, Germany. When this company broke down, the relevant persons vanished one by one leaving behind their heritage.
For details ask the administrator of linuxtv.org, Johannes Stezenbach.
2. Right now the personnel of the DVB development appears and vanishes whenever they want to. It's completely absurd to build up a kernel branch nearly only on volunteers, but that's the way it is. Even Linus Torvalds does not see that there should be a change:
Do everything to win skilled ans sponsored people for the work to be done.
3. I do not trust in the capabilities of the man who is maintaining the actual dvb-apps. His mouth is too big, his thoughts are malicious very often, his experience level is rather low, and his capabilities aren't even mediocre.
And worst of all: exaggerated egoism instead of real partnership work, real team work, same problem as with Mauro Carvalho Chehab.
Applying for a job these people wouldn't even pass at least one so-called assessment test (which is checking out the human skills). But there seem to be places in the world where this kind of tests aren't mandatory at all.
Basic rule: Centralization itself does not resolve any problem at all. You need qualified people and, as a minimum adequate demand, at least one sponsored person if the job is not only a "fun bringer" but at least in significant parts a rather "unthankful" one.
DVB development at linuxtv.org has been a stepchild for more than 5 years now.
All the former significant people have vanished.
As long as this continues we're on our own: It's us picking up the issues, it's us to investigate etc.
We cannot continue to delegate issues in the traditional paternalistic spirit - at least not with these people.
To get back to the program:
I still do not comprehend why alevt-dvb hangs when the transponder is changed.
I've found out that if you start it without any commandline parameters it does the following:
a. read and parse the PAT
b. read and parse the SDT
c. read and parse the PMT
It will always start reading the videotext of the program with the first found (i. e. the lowest) PMT.
2 effects out of its standard behaviour:
1. When you change the channel within the current transponder the program takes a short break and then comes back continuing to read the same PMT. It will not follow the external player doing the tuning to the new channel.
2. When you change the channel AND change the transponder the program will hang and will only get finished by _killall_.
The task is to change that behaviour. alevt-dvb should follow the new channel. In mtt (by Gerd Hoffmann @ bytesex.org - xawtv-4.0 pre) a module called dvb-monitor does that job.
Cheers
CS
Quoted 22 lines · Chicken Shack
From: Chicken Shack <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: alevt-dvb 1.7.0: new version, should be free from bugs now
To: "Francesco Lavra" <[email protected]>
Cc: "Linux media" <[email protected]>
Date: Saturday, February 13, 2010, 6:11 AM
Am Samstag, den 13.02.2010, 10:56
+0100 schrieb Francesco Lavra:Quoted 1 line
On Thu, 2010-02-11 at 22:26 +0100, Chicken Shack
Quoted 4 lines · wrote:
Quoted 4 lines
Hi,
my way to say "Thank you".
Just enjoy this tiny little program with thelatest kernel.
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Debian files for producing a Debian binary
included.
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
This version needs libzvbi as dependency to run. Thanks to Tom Zoerne for the implemention patch
that I found by
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
accident.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Cheers
CSP. S.: There are two issues in the TODO list. Please drop me a note if you can fix those issues
mentioned there.
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
ENJOY!
Does this version work with recent kernels without reverting dvb-demux?
Quoted 115 lines
Quoted 2 lines
What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under
v4l2-apps/util/)?
Quoted 1 line
AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site
where development
Quoted 2 lines
could take place.
I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it washosted in vl4-dvb,
Quoted 1 line
and it could be an additional testing tool useful for
drivers
Quoted 4 lines
development.
And it is GPL-licensed.Francesco
Hi Francesco,
I wish your point of view were right. But it isn't at all.
There are a couple of reasons for that:
1. As long as there is not at least one person doing the necessary DVB
maintenance sponsored by some industry there will never be a significant
change at all.
The roots of the DVB project were a company called Convergence media in
Cologne, Germany. When this company broke down, the relevant persons
vanished one by one leaving behind their heritage. For details ask the administrator of linuxtv.org, Johannes Stezenbach.2. Right now the personnel of the DVB development appears and vanishes
whenever they want to. It's completely absurd to build up a kernel
branch nearly only on volunteers, but that's the way it is.
Even Linus Torvalds does not see that there should be a change:
Do everything to win skilled ans sponsored people for the work to be
done.3. I do not trust in the capabilities of the man who is maintaining the
actual dvb-apps. His mouth is too big, his thoughts are malicious very
often, his experience level is rather low, and his capabilities aren't
even mediocre.
And worst of all: exaggerated egoism instead of real partnership work,
real team work, same problem as with Mauro Carvalho Chehab.Applying for a job these people wouldn't even pass at least one
so-called assessment test (which is checking out the human skills).
But there seem to be places in the world where this kind of tests aren't
mandatory at all.Basic rule: Centralization itself does not resolve any problem at all.
You need qualified people and, as a minimum adequate demand, at least
one sponsored person if the job is not only a "fun bringer" but at least
in significant parts a rather "unthankful" one.DVB development at linuxtv.org has been a stepchild for more than 5
years now.
All the former significant people have vanished.As long as this continues we're on our own: It's us picking up the
issues, it's us to investigate etc.
We cannot continue to delegate issues in the traditional paternalistic
spirit - at least not with these people.To get back to the program:
I still do not comprehend why alevt-dvb hangs when the transponder is
changed.
I've found out that if you start it without any commandline parameters
it does the following:a. read and parse the PAT
b. read and parse the SDT
c. read and parse the PMTIt will always start reading the videotext of the program with the first
found (i. e. the lowest) PMT.2 effects out of its standard behaviour:
1. When you change the channel within the current transponder the
program takes a short break and then comes back continuing to read the
same PMT. It will not follow the external player doing the tuning to the
new channel.
Quoted 3 lines
2. When you change the channel AND change the transponder the program
will hang and will only get finished by _killall_.
Or you can tune back to the original transponder or a transponder with the same provider, then alevt works again. So there is may be a check for the provider name.
Quoted 10 lines
The task is to change that behaviour. alevt-dvb should follow the new
channel. In mtt (by Gerd Hoffmann @ bytesex.org - xawtv-4.0 pre) a
module called dvb-monitor does that job.Cheers
CS
Thanks for your this version.
Emil
Am Mittwoch, den 17.02.2010, 15:50 -0800 schrieb Emil Meier:
Quoted 28 lines
Quoted 25 lines · Chicken Shack
From: Chicken Shack <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: alevt-dvb 1.7.0: new version, should be free from bugs now
To: "Francesco Lavra" <[email protected]>
Cc: "Linux media" <[email protected]>
Date: Saturday, February 13, 2010, 6:11 AM
Am Samstag, den 13.02.2010, 10:56
+0100 schrieb Francesco Lavra:Quoted 1 line
On Thu, 2010-02-11 at 22:26 +0100, Chicken Shack
Quoted 4 lines · wrote:
Quoted 4 lines
Hi,
my way to say "Thank you".
Just enjoy this tiny little program with thelatest kernel.
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Debian files for producing a Debian binary
included.
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
This version needs libzvbi as dependency to run. Thanks to Tom Zoerne for the implemention patch
that I found by
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
accident.
Cheers
CS
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
P. S.: There are two issues in the TODO list. Please drop me a note if you can fix those issues
mentioned there.
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
ENJOY!
Does this version work with recent kernels without reverting dvb-demux?
Good question!
Unless Greg Kroah-Hartman does not publish another sublevel of 2.6.32 this version ( plus the appended one ) will run on all kernel except from 2.6.32.
As 2.6.32 is exposed to become a reference kernel for many distros I will Cc him in this mail......
Quoted 114 lines
Quoted 114 lines
Quoted 1 line
What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under
v4l2-apps/util/)?
Quoted 1 line
AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site
where development
Quoted 2 lines
could take place.
I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it washosted in vl4-dvb,
Quoted 1 line
and it could be an additional testing tool useful for
drivers
Quoted 4 lines
development.
And it is GPL-licensed.Francesco
Hi Francesco,
I wish your point of view were right. But it isn't at all.
There are a couple of reasons for that:
1. As long as there is not at least one person doing the necessary DVB
maintenance sponsored by some industry there will never be a significant
change at all.
The roots of the DVB project were a company called Convergence media in
Cologne, Germany. When this company broke down, the relevant persons
vanished one by one leaving behind their heritage. For details ask the administrator of linuxtv.org, Johannes Stezenbach.2. Right now the personnel of the DVB development appears and vanishes
whenever they want to. It's completely absurd to build up a kernel
branch nearly only on volunteers, but that's the way it is.
Even Linus Torvalds does not see that there should be a change:
Do everything to win skilled ans sponsored people for the work to be
done.3. I do not trust in the capabilities of the man who is maintaining the
actual dvb-apps. His mouth is too big, his thoughts are malicious very
often, his experience level is rather low, and his capabilities aren't
even mediocre.
And worst of all: exaggerated egoism instead of real partnership work,
real team work, same problem as with Mauro Carvalho Chehab.Applying for a job these people wouldn't even pass at least one
so-called assessment test (which is checking out the human skills).
But there seem to be places in the world where this kind of tests aren't
mandatory at all.Basic rule: Centralization itself does not resolve any problem at all.
You need qualified people and, as a minimum adequate demand, at least
one sponsored person if the job is not only a "fun bringer" but at least
in significant parts a rather "unthankful" one.DVB development at linuxtv.org has been a stepchild for more than 5
years now.
All the former significant people have vanished.As long as this continues we're on our own: It's us picking up the
issues, it's us to investigate etc.
We cannot continue to delegate issues in the traditional paternalistic
spirit - at least not with these people.To get back to the program:
I still do not comprehend why alevt-dvb hangs when the transponder is
changed.
I've found out that if you start it without any commandline parameters
it does the following:a. read and parse the PAT
b. read and parse the SDT
c. read and parse the PMTIt will always start reading the videotext of the program with the first
found (i. e. the lowest) PMT.2 effects out of its standard behaviour:
1. When you change the channel within the current transponder the
program takes a short break and then comes back continuing to read the
same PMT. It will not follow the external player doing the tuning to the
new channel.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
2. When you change the channel AND change the transponder the program
will hang and will only get finished by _killall_.Or you can tune back to the original transponder or a transponder with the same provider, then alevt works again. So there is may be a check for the provider name.
Not exactly. As long as there is no necessity to reread the PAT (Program association table) everything is working fine. At the current state the mechanism (or system call) to restart or reset the reading and parsing process of PAT, SDT, PMT is missing. And that exactly poses the problems as soon as you change the transponder......
As long as you do not change the transponder, PAT, SDT and PMT stay the same.
Transponder is not equal to provider........
google is your friend or have a look at etsi.org.......
The required monitoring demon MUST work independently from the external player application doing the tuning.
My current script switches off and restarts alevt at every channel change, including waitstates so that the player application and alevt do not interfere when accessing the demux device (->timing issue).... But that's just a very dirty workaround.....
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines
The task is to change that behaviour. alevt-dvb should follow the new
channel. In mtt (by Gerd Hoffmann @ bytesex.org - xawtv-4.0 pre) a
module called dvb-monitor does that job.Cheers
CS
Thanks for your this version.
You're welcome as every other user is.
Quoted 1 line
Emil
Emil and others: Will you please use the appended version?
I kicked out a nasty error message that printed out an error every time when alevt was entering a zero entry in the PAT.
This error message wasn't even relevant for debug purposes, so I eliminated it.
I dropped some lines about external dependencies in the README file.
Some critical words on that one:
http://linuxtv.org/hg/dvb-apps/rev/7de0663facd9
1. alevt-dvb is not a DVB-only application. It's core origin is to address analogue cards. Only within a rather incomplete patchset alevt can address DVB cards too. In so far that's a bad idea to put it into the dvb-apps.....
2. With the exception of Christoph Pfister who has done a very good job with the latest kaffeine the personal scenery @ linuxtv.org is like a rat race in the production of appropriate drivers. Production and maintenance of applications is rather cemetary-like @ linuxtv.org, i. e. de facto not existing.
It's for instance hihghly questionable why there are still 2 formats for a channels.conf file (vdr format and the reduced zap format). The zap format is obsolete IMHO.
As the situation is as it is, this expectation at least sounds utmost naive and has got nothing to do with reality as it is:
"What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under v4l2-apps/util/)? AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site where development could take place. I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it was hosted in vl4-dvb, and it could be an additional testing tool useful for drivers development. And it is GPL-licensed. (Francesco Lavra)"
For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel regressions:
http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/2dfe2234e7ea
ENJOY!
CS
Quoted 13 lines · Chicken Shack
From: Chicken Shack <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: alevt-dvb 1.7.0: new version, should be free from bugs now
To: "Emil Meier" <[email protected]>
Cc: "Linux media" <[email protected]>, [email protected], [email protected]
Date: Thursday, February 18, 2010, 3:57 AM
Am Mittwoch, den 17.02.2010, 15:50
-0800 schrieb Emil Meier:Quoted 3 lines
Or you can tune back to the original transponder or a
transponder with the same provider, then alevt works again.
Quoted 1 line
So there is may be a check for the provider name.
Quoted 15 lines
Not exactly. As long as there is no necessity to reread the PAT (Program
association table) everything is working fine. At the current state the
mechanism (or system call) to restart or reset the reading and parsing
process of PAT, SDT, PMT is missing. And that exactly poses the problems
as soon as you change the transponder......
As long as you do not change the transponder, PAT, SDT and PMT stay the
same.
Transponder is not equal to provider........ google is your friend or have a look at etsi.org.......
Yes, but I have tested a Transponder change, where the Provider name of the new transponder is the same as before, then alevt changes to a new channel (may be the first one) and continues to work again. As I have edited my kaffeine channels.dvb on my own, I am very sure, that I have changed the transponder...
Is your version 1.7.0 connected to the version 1.7.0 which Uwe Bulga sent to me? I will test your new version this evening.
As I am using alevt since I think over 10 years, I hope that I can use this application again with vanilla kernels without reverse-patching!!! At the moment I am using 2.6.32.7 with a reverse patch Uwe sent to me...
This works fine as before...
Maybe 2.6.32.8 can correct the dvb-demux driver.
Quoted 4 lines
The required monitoring demon MUST work independently from the external
player application doing the tuning.
Quoted 8 lines
My current script switches off and restarts alevt at every channel
change, including waitstates so that the player application and alevt do
not interfere when accessing the demux device (->timing issue)....
But that's just a very dirty workaround.....
I will have a look into alevt, why the update and eventhandling stops after changing transponder/provider... May be I can find something.
Quoted 76 lines
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
The task is to change that behaviour. alevt-dvb
should
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
follow the new
channel. In mtt (by Gerd Hoffmann @ bytesex.org -xawtv-4.0
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 6 lines
pre) a
module called dvb-monitor does that job.Cheers
CS
Thanks for your this version.
You're welcome as every other user is.
Quoted 1 line
Emil
Emil and others: Will you please use the appended version?
I kicked out a nasty error message that printed out an error every time
when alevt was entering a zero entry in the PAT. This error message wasn't even relevant for debug purposes, so I
eliminated it.
I dropped some lines about external dependencies in the README file.Some critical words on that one:
http://linuxtv.org/hg/dvb-apps/rev/7de0663facd9
1. alevt-dvb is not a DVB-only application. It's core origin is to
address analogue cards. Only within a rather incomplete patchset alevt
can address DVB cards too. In so far that's a bad idea to put it into
the dvb-apps.....2. With the exception of Christoph Pfister who has done a very good job
with the latest kaffeine the personal scenery @ linuxtv.org is like a
rat race in the production of appropriate drivers. Production and maintenance of applications is rather cemetary-like @
linuxtv.org, i. e. de facto not existing.It's for instance hihghly questionable why there are still 2 formats for
a channels.conf file (vdr format and the reduced zap format).
The zap format is obsolete IMHO.As the situation is as it is, this expectation at least sounds utmost
naive and has got nothing to do with reality as it is:"What about adding this program to v4l-dvb (under v4l2-apps/util/)?
AFAIK, alevt currently doesn't have a proper site where development
could take place. I think it would enjoy a better maintenance if it was
hosted in vl4-dvb, and it could be an additional testing tool useful for
drivers development. And it is GPL-licensed. (Francesco Lavra)"For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel
regressions:
Quoted 7 lines
http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/2dfe2234e7ea
ENJOY!
CS
Thanks
Emil
Quoted 6 lines · Chicken Shack
For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel regressions:
I have no idea what you are asking me to do here.
If you need a patch in the -stable tree, send the git commit id of the patch that is in Linus's tree to the [email protected] email address.
If it is not in Linus's tree, I can not accept it.
confused,
greg k-h
Am Donnerstag, den 18.02.2010, 06:40 -0800 schrieb Greg KH:
Quoted 6 lines · Chicken Shack
Quoted 5 lines
For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel regressions:
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
I have no idea what you are asking me to do here.
If you need a patch in the -stable tree, send the git commit id of the patch that is in Linus's tree to the [email protected] email address.
OK. So this is a bit new and confusing, and it is definitely not my job, as there are so-called MAINTAINERS for that, but I will try my best:
Here is the link:
and this ought to be the commit id:
commit 691c9ae099b9bcb5c27125af00a4a90120977458
SOB etc. please see link.
Quoted 1 line
If it is not in Linus's tree, I can not accept it.
It is there, please see above!
Instead of doing a steady maintainers job, Mauro Carvalho Chehab prefers to play kiddish games by substituting functionable kernel patches with his own disfunctionable ones, as you can see here:
http://www.spinics.net/lists/linux-media/msg15749.html
and here:
http://www.spinics.net/lists/linux-media/msg15761.html
The maintainers job would have been to send the commit ID to [email protected], but foolish experiments seem to be more important than a fix for a stable kernel.
Quoted 3 lines
confused,
greg k-h
enlightened and delighted,
Chicken Shack :) :)
[email protected] Cced.....
Quoted 20 lines · Chicken Shack
Am Donnerstag, den 18.02.2010, 06:40 -0800 schrieb Greg KH:
Quoted 6 lines · Chicken Shack
Quoted 5 lines
For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel regressions:
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
I have no idea what you are asking me to do here.
If you need a patch in the -stable tree, send the git commit id of the patch that is in Linus's tree to the [email protected] email address.
OK. So this is a bit new and confusing, and it is definitely not my job, as there are so-called
MAINTAINERSfor that, but I will try my best:Here is the link:
Quoted 7 lines
and this ought to be the commit id:
commit
691c9ae099b9bcb5c27125af00a4a90120977458SOB etc. please see link.
That patch is already queued up for the next 2.6.32-stable kernel release. The people involved in that patch should have already gotten an email saying so.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
If it is not in Linus's tree, I can not accept it.
It is there, please see above!
Instead of doing a steady maintainers job, Mauro Carvalho Chehab prefers to play kiddish games by substituting functionable kernel patches with his own disfunctionable ones, as you can see here:
I have a 6 year old with better manners, please leave these kinds of insults at home. The maintainers already properly notified the stable team of that patch, as you can see by it already being queued up.
bah,
greg k-h
Am Donnerstag, den 18.02.2010, 07:34 -0800 schrieb Greg KH:
Quoted 25 lines · Chicken Shack
Quoted 24 lines
Am Donnerstag, den 18.02.2010, 06:40 -0800 schrieb Greg KH:
Quoted 6 lines · Chicken Shack
Quoted 5 lines
For Greg Kroah-Hartman:
This one should go into kernel 2.6.32, just to close a gap of kernel regressions:
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
I have no idea what you are asking me to do here.
If you need a patch in the -stable tree, send the git commit id of the patch that is in Linus's tree to the [email protected] email address.
OK. So this is a bit new and confusing, and it is definitely not my job, as there are so-called
MAINTAINERSfor that, but I will try my best:Here is the link:
and this ought to be the commit id:
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines
commit
691c9ae099b9bcb5c27125af00a4a90120977458SOB etc. please see link.
That patch is already queued up for the next 2.6.32-stable kernel release. The people involved in that patch should have already gotten an email saying so.
Thanks! This is the only thing I wanted to make sure.
Regards
CS