Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Plumbers: PM constraints micro-conf RFP

DISCUSSION mark gross 8 participants 18 messages May 2, 2012 – May 17, 2012 4 messages not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore

mark gross

author
#0 lore raw

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event. For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream. The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

Quoted 1 line

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include

limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails. Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me. I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now. I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases. Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

thanks,
--mark

author
#1 lore raw
Quoted 44 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event. For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream. The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails. Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Quoted 5 lines

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me. I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now. I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases. Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

I forgot to make clear a few things specific to the Plumbers conference.
1) they need proposals by mid may
2) if you want financial assistance to be part of this micro-conf you need to ask the conference committee and I think I need to recommend you as an important participant. --- Paul, can you clarify this?

If we don't get a critical mass as determined by the conference committee we can try again / do more stuff over email. BTW we should be doing more of anyway.

--mark

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

#2 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · mark gross

I forgot to make clear a few things specific to the Plumbers conference.
1) they need proposals by mid may
2) if you want financial assistance to be part of this micro-conf you need to ask the conference committee and I think I need to recommend you as an important participant. --- Paul, can you clarify this?

If we don't get a critical mass as determined by the conference committee we can try again / do more stuff over email. BTW we should be doing more of anyway.

--mark

Not being familiar with LPC format - does LPC expect just a presentation or should there be also a "paper"? I just registered a blueprint at

	https://blueprints.launchpad.net/lpc/+spec/lpc2012-cf-tegra

Is the format OK for a proposal?

	--Antti
author
#3 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Antti P Miettinen
Quoted 10 lines · mark gross

I forgot to make clear a few things specific to the Plumbers conference.
1) they need proposals by mid may
2) if you want financial assistance to be part of this micro-conf you need to ask the conference committee and I think I need to recommend you as an important participant. --- Paul, can you clarify this?

If we don't get a critical mass as determined by the conference committee we can try again / do more stuff over email. BTW we should be doing more of anyway.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line

--mark

Not being familiar with LPC format - does LPC expect just a presentation or should there be also a "paper"? I just registered a blueprint at

	https://blueprints.launchpad.net/lpc/+spec/lpc2012-cf-tegra

Is the format OK for a proposal?

That looks good to me. But, Paul would be right person to confirm. Please be sure to give equal time to the problem statement as well as your implementation in the presentation. Depending on time constraints, TBD, you may need to trim back on the talk or not.

The time per talk depends on how much participation we get.

--mark

#4 lore raw
In reply to mark gross

Hi Mark,

Quoted 8 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event. For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

Quoted 7 lines

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream. The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Thanks for organizing this.

I won't be at Plumbers this year (I'll be on vacation), but will certainly participate by email as I have an interest in these topics.

I've added Jean Pihet to Cc as he is also working on QoS/constraints related topics.

Kevin

#5 lore raw
In reply to mark gross

Hi Mark,

Quoted 8 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event. For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

Quoted 7 lines

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream. The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Thanks for organizing this.

I won't be at Plumbers this year (I'll be on vacation), but will certainly participate by email as I have an interest in these topics.

I've added Jean Pihet to Cc as he is also working on QoS/constraints related topics.

Kevin

#6 lore raw
In reply to mark gross

Hi Mark,

Quoted 4 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

That looks great! I hope some progress can be made in the area of the constraints frameworks design.

Quoted 10 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I can have something about the per-device PM QoS, starting from the ELC presentation [1], the current status and the next steps.

[1] https://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/embedded-linux-conference/pihet
The slides can be found at
https://events.linuxfoundation.org/images/stories/pdf/lf_elc12_pihet.pdf.

I am looking at the travel arrangements and will confirm asap.

Quoted 2 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

An agreement is needed on the APIs, especially for the user space.

Quoted 26 lines

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Quoted 8 lines

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

thanks,
--mark

Thanks for organizing!

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 5 lines

_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

author
#7 lore raw
Quoted 65 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Mark,

Quoted 4 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

That looks great! I hope some progress can be made in the area of the constraints frameworks design.

Quoted 10 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I can have something about the per-device PM QoS, starting from the ELC presentation [1], the current status and the next steps.

[1] https://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/embedded-linux-conference/pihet
The slides can be found at
https://events.linuxfoundation.org/images/stories/pdf/lf_elc12_pihet.pdf.

I am looking at the travel arrangements and will confirm asap.

Quoted 2 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

An agreement is needed on the APIs, especially for the user space.

Quoted 32 lines

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

thanks,
--mark

Thanks for organizing!

I think it will be a good discussion and hopefully we'll make progress all around on this topic.

BTW I'm sorry for mutilating your name and email in my original posting.

--mark

#8 lore raw
In reply to mark gross

Hello Mark,

Quoted 4 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 24 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 10 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Quoted 9 lines

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

thanks,
--mark

All best,

Signature · 1 line
Eduardo Valentin
author
#9 lore raw
Quoted 42 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 4 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 24 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

Quoted 5 lines

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

This will be great! Getting the common / typical use cases well represented is the highest priority of the session IMO.

Having a solid understanding of them will drive the requirements and hopefully make defining the architecture quick, easy and without a lot of conflicting points of view.

--mark

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): CAORVsuU3YDGq713jtmPCpJT=3eXqrvx_qU=uPK86XvDdzHSGtg@mail.gmail.com

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): CAGF5oy-xduO-BjM1NcNvJG1LV1d-1h78v6mdpq5noRFMsxmjkg@mail.gmail.com

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): CAGF5oy9kKPW5BF9FPXXm8-=9O5AM+NhKxjOysJbDiwDF=RvpKw@mail.gmail.com

#14 lore raw

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Abstract:
Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management
needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
. the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why
and how to make it generic,
. the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle, . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the
various latencies,
. a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it,
. the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code
and the APIs.

This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The
goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 167 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 129 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Quoted 3 lines

--

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

#15 lore raw

Hello,

I submitted a blueprint on launchpad as well, available here:
https://blueprints.launchpad.net/linux/+spec/lpc2012-cf-thermal-pm-constraint

Quoted 209 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Abstract:
 Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
 . the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why and how to make it generic,
 . the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle, . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the various latencies,
 . a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it,
 . the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code and the APIs.

 This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 167 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 129 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Quoted 3 lines

--

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

Signature · 1 line
Eduardo Valentin
#16 lore raw
In reply to Jean Pihet
Quoted 9 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Quoted 7 lines

Abstract:
 Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
 . the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why and how to make it generic,
 . the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle,

Jean,

Do you already consider GPU drivers, backlight drivers and battery charging for setting constraints (performance and thermal) ?

Between your, Eduardo's and Antti's proposals, a lot of ground is being covered and I don't want to make a new proposal just for these three. But we're keen on helping consolidate on generic interfaces to deal with these three kinds of devices.

Quoted 194 lines

 . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the various latencies,

 . a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it, . the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code and the APIs.

 This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 167 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 129 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Quoted 3 lines

--

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

author
#17 lore raw
Quoted 20 lines · Amit Kucheria
Quoted 9 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Quoted 7 lines

Abstract:
 Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
 . the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why and how to make it generic,
 . the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle,

Jean,

Quoted 7 lines

Do you already consider GPU drivers, backlight drivers and battery charging for setting constraints (performance and thermal) ?

Between your, Eduardo's and Antti's proposals, a lot of ground is being covered and I don't want to make a new proposal just for these three. But we're keen on helping consolidate on generic interfaces to deal with these three kinds of devices.

It will be great to have you there in any case.

It feels like we have enough content to come up with portable requirements and maybe an ok design that can work for multiple SoC's.

--mark

Quoted 194 lines
Quoted 194 lines

 . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the various latencies,

 . a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it, . the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code and the APIs.

 This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 167 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 129 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Quoted 3 lines

--

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

#18 lore raw

I put in a rough draft @
https://blueprints.launchpad.net/lpc/+spec/lpc2012-power-management-constraints

Cheers!

Quoted 234 lines · mark gross
Quoted 20 lines · Amit Kucheria
Quoted 9 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Quoted 7 lines

Abstract:
 Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
 . the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why and how to make it generic,
 . the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle,

Jean,

Quoted 7 lines

Do you already consider GPU drivers, backlight drivers and battery charging for setting constraints (performance and thermal) ?

Between your, Eduardo's and Antti's proposals, a lot of ground is being covered and I don't want to make a new proposal just for these three. But we're keen on helping consolidate on generic interfaces to deal with these three kinds of devices.

It will be great to have you there in any case.

It feels like we have enough content to come up with portable requirements and maybe an ok design that can work for multiple SoC's.

--mark

Quoted 187 lines
Quoted 187 lines

 . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the various latencies,

 . a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it, . the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code and the APIs.

 This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 160 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 131 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

--

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Signature · 3 lines
---------
The views expressed in this email are personal and do not necessarily
echo my employers.
#19 lore raw

:(

I received this:

Your message (attached below) was not delivered to:

[email protected]

because:

Bad destination mailbox address

Final-recipient: rfc822;[email protected]
Action: failed
Status: 5.1.1
Diagnostic-code: X-Xagent; Bad destination mailbox address

Quoted 4 lines · Sundar

I put in a rough draft @
https://blueprints.launchpad.net/lpc/+spec/lpc2012-power-management-constraints

Cheers!

Signature · 3 lines
---------
The views expressed in this email are personal and do not necessarily
echo my employers.
author
#20 lore raw
In reply to Jean Pihet
Quoted 23 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi!

Here is my proposal for the PM constraints micro-conf RFP, as e-mailed today:

Session title: A New Model for the System and Devices Latency

Name of microconference (if applicable): PM constraints micro-conf, led by Mark Gross

Abstract:
Due to the nature of the new SoC architectures the Power Management
needs a new model for the various system latencies. The talk presents:
. the concepts of system, devices, wake-up and resume latencies, . the recent changes in the devices framework for the latency, why
and how to make it generic,
. the link with the other PM QoS frameworks: thermal, cpuidle, . the recent changes in the ARM/OMAP platform code for the system latency, . the problems encountered while modelling and measuring the
various latencies,
. a proposal on the model and on the way to implement it,
. the planned changes in the device framework, the platform code
and the APIs.

Quoted 3 lines

This talk is oriented towards Linux power management developers. The
goal is to agree on a framework implementation and the interfaces within the kernel and with the user space.

looks great to me! you should toss it up on the plumbers site.

--mark

Quoted 182 lines

Experience:
Jean Pihet, NewOldBits.com

Jean Pihet is working with embedded Linux since many years now, for companies like Texas Instruments, MontaVista, Motorola and Philips. Recently NewOldBits.com has been founded to provide high quality consulting services. The area of work is mainly OMAP Power Management, tracing and profiling tools (perf, ftrace, oprofile...) for recent ARM cores.

Kind regards,
Jean

Quoted 167 lines · Eduardo

FYI,

I will submit later today, something like this:
"
Abstract

The thermal challenge is to design an end-product with high performance while keeping the junction temperature of the IC components used on this product within their limitations and which does not present a thermal discomfort for the user. OMAP4/OMAP5 System on Chips, operating at highest Operating Performance Points (OPP), is a powerful mobile applications processor. However operating at higher voltage and higher frequency in a sustained manner may cause thermal limits to be exceeded, both for silicon and user comfort. We propose a new framework to model per device power constraints, for containment of thermal limitations across major heat sources of a end-product device, e.g. LCD, CPU, charging, etc. The framework shall facilitate the power and thermal management performed by governor and policies, depending on device context and use case knowledge.

Authors

Eduardo Valentin, System Software Engineer at Texas Instruments, working on OMAP Linux kernel, previously a working on power management in maemo for Nokia.

Quoted 129 lines · Eduardo

Benoit,

Quoted 34 lines · Benoit

Hi Jean,

Quoted 30 lines · Jean Pihet

Hi Benoit,

Quoted 24 lines · Eduardo

Hello Mark,

Quoted 5 lines · mark gross

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux plumbers event.  For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain critical mass WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

Nice! Thanks for proposing this.

Quoted 11 lines

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over extending pm-qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance of devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of developers looking for a good solution to push upstream.  The talks will be about 20 min long as I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

Is it OK to submit a talk for the next LPC? The deadline is tomorrow IIRC.

Yes, it is. Go ahead. It is related to Mark's proposal? Because it seems we have to do some homework in order to participate to the micro-conf :-(.

Yes, the homework is required in order to drive the discussion based on existing usable solutions..

Jean, I'll write down a proposal today, from thermal requirements perspective. But we can discuss also a way to converge either in a common presentation or in even with two presentations but with strong linking together.

Just trying to avoid two conflicting proposals from two peers @ti.com

Quoted 73 lines

Regards,
Benoit

Quoted 66 lines

Regards,
Jean

Quoted 62 lines
Quoted 14 lines

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

 From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include
limiting performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

Quoted 6 lines

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to participate in this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining the performance or throttling is needed.

I could bring something on the use cases where this type of constraining could be used. Essentially major focus gets partitioned in two areas: For device skin/case temperature management, and IC's junction temperature management.

I am currently checking the traveling arrangements as well. And confirming soon.

Quoted 17 lines

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested linux-plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails.  Note: must of the correspondence will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with me.  I know a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now.  I think its a good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use cases.  Perhaps we'll even come up
with a good design to implement in the process.

Quoted 3 lines

thanks,
--mark

All best,
--

Eduardo Valentin
_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm

Quoted 3 lines

--

Eduardo Valentin

--

Eduardo Valentin

#21 lore raw
In reply to mark gross
Quoted 6 lines

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:linux-pm- [email protected]] On Behalf Of mark gross
Sent: Wednesday, May 02, 2012 8:06 PM
To: mark gross; John Stultz; [email protected]; MyungJoo Ham; Amit Kucheria; Agarwal, Ramesh; Praveen Chidambaram; Antti P Miettinen;

Valentin,

Quoted 5 lines

Eduardo; Rafael J. Wysocki; Kevin Hilman
Cc: [email protected]; [email protected]
Subject: [linux-pm] Plumbers: PM constraints micro-conf RFP

This is a Request For Participation in a micro-conference at this years Linux

plumbers

Quoted 1 line

event. For this micro conference to happen we need to reach a certain

critical mass

Quoted 4 lines

WRT participants as measured by submitted talks associated to Power Management Constraints.

The To: list is populated with folks that I've had interactions with over

extending pm-

Quoted 3 lines

qos or constraint based PM over the past year.

If you are working on problems related to constraining the power / performance

of

Quoted 2 lines

devices I am inviting your participation and request you submit a proposal for presenting your problem space (preferred) and or solution to a group of

developers

Quoted 1 line

looking for a good solution to push upstream. The talks will be about 20 min

long as

Quoted 6 lines

I want to get into some design and implementation discussions after the requirements definition is mostly finished.

I am interested in gathering user mode interface needs as well as kernel mode.

From a high level pm-constraints is a generalization of pm-qos to include

limiting

Quoted 8 lines

performance as well as its current limiting of device throttling.

As performance limiting is typically used for any of the following:
1) staying within thermal operational envelopes
2) avoiding peak current
3) extending battery life in active use cases

I invite anyone working in any of these areas or pm-qos applications to

participate in

Quoted 4 lines

this micro-conference.

I will organize the micro-conference into 2 parts:
1) problem statements with specific participant examples where constraining

the

Quoted 5 lines

performance or throttling is needed.

2) high level design brain storming.

If the micro-conference happens (i.e. critical mass is reached) any interested

linux-

Quoted 4 lines

plumbers attendees is very welcome to participate.

Please send me an off list email if you want me to add you to my mutt alias of interested parties I'll use to cc people on emails. Note: must of the

correspondence

Quoted 3 lines

will cc linux-pm too.

Please submit a proposal if you are interested in participating in this with

me. I know

Quoted 1 line

a number of people are working in this space for the past few years now. I

think its a

Quoted 1 line

good time to compare notes and at least consolidate requirements and use

cases.

Quoted 1 line

Perhaps we'll even come up with a good design to implement in the process.

Mark,

Please find a draft proposal on priority based PM-QoS Parameters,
https://blueprints.launchpad.net/lpc/+spec/lpc-2012-priority-based-pmqos-paramet
ers

Thanks,

Quoted 8 lines

thanks,
--mark

_______________________________________________
linux-pm mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-pm