R: Re: [PATCH]: dontaudit sys_module wpa_supplicant
-- original message --
Subject: Re: [refpolicy] [PATCH]: dontaudit sys_module wpa_supplicant
From: "Christopher J. PeBenito" <[email protected]>
Date: 21/03/2011 14:24
Quoted 55 lines · Guido Trentalancia
Quoted 27 lines · Sven Vermeulen
Quoted 7 lines · Guido Trentalancia
Quoted 4 lines
The moment you set
kernel_load_module(NetworkManager_t)you're all set. The neverallow is on all domains that do not have thecan_load_kernmoduleattribute set, and withkernel_load_moduel()you set it for the specified domain.The "neverallow" rule in
kernel/kernel.tepreventsNetworkManager_tfrom having the "sys_module" capability.In
kernel/kernel.te:neverallow ~{
can_load_kernmodulekern_unconfined} self:capabilitysys_module;The
kernel_load_moduleinterface:interface(
kernel_load_module',gen_require(` attribute can_load_kernmodule; ') allow $1 self:capability sys_module; typeattribute $1 can_load_kernmodule; # load_module() calls stop_machine() which # calls sched_setscheduler() allow $1 self:capability sys_nice; kernel_setsched($1)Quoted 6 lines
')
When you use
kernel_load_module(NetworkManager_t), then the typeattribute will add "can_load_kernmodule" as an attribute to theNetworkManager_tdomain. The neverallow works on all but those domains havingcan_load_kernmoduleand/orkern_unconfinedset as an attribute.It seems quite difficult to explain this...
I do not want to break things for distributions that do not want
wpa_supplicantto load kernel modules and in any case I would like to hear from Christopher.So unless Dan Walsh changes his mind there needs to be at least one ifdef (for DISTRO=redhat).
I am happy to prepare a patch which does can_load_kernmodule()/dontaudit depending on the distribution, but I need to hear from people with authority for each distribution. And Christopher should decide what would be the default behaviour.
It is perfectly fine to me (and I would probably be happier) if the default behaviour is
can_load_kernmodule()as I do not particularly like "dontaudit" for stuff which just logs once (but Christopher has a different opinion on this, so once again nothing can be changed before Monday).
Quoted 4 lines
I would rather not allow
this. We don't want
network-facing services
loading kernel modules.
At least wpa_supplicant is not network-facing (would need to check for NetworkManager). It should not be dealing with sockets and connections, so it should be *isolated* from the network and the outside world (at least at L3 and above).
In any case it could be "dontaudit"ed.
Signature · 3 lines
Chris PeBenito Tresys Technology, LLC www.tresys.com | oss.tresys.com
PATCH 1/1 : dontaudit sys_module wpa_supplicant
Quoted 67 lines · Guido Trentalancia
-- original message --
Subject: Re: [refpolicy] [PATCH]: dontauditsys_modulewpa_supplicant
From: "Christopher J. PeBenito" <[email protected]>
Date: 21/03/2011 14:24Quoted 55 lines · Guido Trentalancia
Quoted 27 lines · Sven Vermeulen
Quoted 7 lines · Guido Trentalancia
Quoted 4 lines
The moment you set
kernel_load_module(NetworkManager_t)you're all set. The neverallow is on all domains that do not have thecan_load_kernmoduleattribute set, and withkernel_load_moduel()you set it for the specified domain.The "neverallow" rule in
kernel/kernel.tepreventsNetworkManager_tfrom having the "sys_module" capability.In
kernel/kernel.te:neverallow ~{
can_load_kernmodulekern_unconfined} self:capabilitysys_module;The
kernel_load_moduleinterface:interface(
kernel_load_module',gen_require(` attribute can_load_kernmodule; ') allow $1 self:capability sys_module; typeattribute $1 can_load_kernmodule; # load_module() calls stop_machine() which # calls sched_setscheduler() allow $1 self:capability sys_nice; kernel_setsched($1)Quoted 6 lines
')
When you use
kernel_load_module(NetworkManager_t), then the typeattribute will add "can_load_kernmodule" as an attribute to theNetworkManager_tdomain. The neverallow works on all but those domains havingcan_load_kernmoduleand/orkern_unconfinedset as an attribute.It seems quite difficult to explain this...
I do not want to break things for distributions that do not want
wpa_supplicantto load kernel modules and in any case I would like to hear from Christopher.So unless Dan Walsh changes his mind there needs to be at least one ifdef (for DISTRO=redhat).
I am happy to prepare a patch which does can_load_kernmodule()/dontaudit depending on the distribution, but I need to hear from people with authority for each distribution. And Christopher should decide what would be the default behaviour.
It is perfectly fine to me (and I would probably be happier) if the default behaviour is
can_load_kernmodule()as I do not particularly like "dontaudit" for stuff which just logs once (but Christopher has a different opinion on this, so once again nothing can be changed before Monday).Quoted 4 lines
I would rather not allow
this. We don't want
network-facing services
loading kernel modules.
Quoted 6 lines
At least
wpa_supplicantis not network-facing (would need to check for NetworkManager). It should not be dealing with sockets and connections, so it should be *isolated* from the network and the outside world (at least
at L3 and above).In any case it could be "dontaudit"ed.
Some more insight into this from reading some of the code. The only network that wpa_supplicant could face is 127.0.0.1 UDP (hardcoded) for the control interface (instead of Unix sockets). This is an auxiliary functionality specific to wpa_supplicant.
However, although the core functionality of wpa_supplicant shouldn't go behind Layer 2 with the Access Point, there are other auxiliary functionalities and new protocols that might bind(AF_INET): for example an http server for UPnP (not sure whether it's actually used but it is linked in). So, I agree it could be risky.
Consider the code is not very straightforward to analyze because I think it shares bits with hostap (the Access Point daemon) although not all of that code is actually used by wpa_supplicant. Also, I can't see much general interest for this, so I'll stop here.
Regards,
Guido