3D video card recommendations
I'm currently putting together (ordering parts for) another machine. It will be a AMD64 X2. Now I'm looking into a video card for this. Up till now, I've always used NVidia. But I also want to test 3D acceleration under Ingo's -rt patch. So now I need something that does not have a priority module.
I'm not much of a gamer, although I do play every so often. So I don't need the highest quality card, but I also want something that is still pretty good. For example, I currently have a NVidia GeForce 6800 GT card. So I'm hoping to get something equivalent.
I'm looking at the ATI Radeons.
Any recommendations? (links to info would also be nice ;-)
Thanks,
-- Steve
Quoted 11 lines · Steven Rostedt
I'm currently putting together (ordering parts for) another machine. It will be a AMD64 X2. Now I'm looking into a video card for this. Up till now, I've always used NVidia. But I also want to test 3D acceleration under Ingo's -rt patch. So now I need something that does not have a priority module.
I'm not much of a gamer, although I do play every so often. So I don't need the highest quality card, but I also want something that is still pretty good. For example, I currently have a NVidia GeForce 6800 GT card. So I'm hoping to get something equivalent.
Quoted 7 lines
I'm looking at the ATI Radeons.
Any recommendations? (links to info would also be nice ;-)
Thanks,
-- Steve
Not a recommendation. Just a point to be aware of. The ATI Radeons, to get the best acceleration, seem to require that you use the ATI closed source drivers. Currently I haven't found an ATI closed source driver that supports 2.6.14. so I'm forced to use the Xorg radeon driver. I have no idea if this is very good. I don't think so as my glxgear numbers are pretty low. Much lower than the ATI driver running on 2.6.13-X.
NOTE: I'm horrible at setting up all the 3D stuff as I don't understand what to chose and what to avoid. This could be far better than the results I get!
- Mark
Quoted 3 lines · Mark Knecht
(...)
Currently I haven't found an ATI closed source driver that supports 2.6.14. so I'm forced to use the Xorg radeon driver.
This patch works fine on my amd64+radeon.
http://ati.cchtml.com/show_bug.cgi?id=211
Signature · 3 lines
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil
is for good men to do nothing.
- Edmund BurkeQuoted 10 lines · Mark Knecht
Quoted 7 lines · Steven Rostedt
I'm looking at the ATI Radeons.
Any recommendations? (links to info would also be nice ;-)
Thanks,
-- Steve
Quoted 7 lines
Not a recommendation. Just a point to be aware of. The ATI Radeons, to get the best acceleration, seem to require that you use the ATI closed source drivers. Currently I haven't found an ATI closed source driver that supports 2.6.14. so I'm forced to use the Xorg radeon driver. I have no idea if this is very good. I don't think so as my glxgear numbers are pretty low. Much lower than the ATI driver running on 2.6.13-X.
I'm sure ATI will come out with a proprietary driver for 2.6.14. I just want some 3D accel for working with -rt. If I want to play a game, I'll just back out to 2.6.13 and use the ATI binary driver. But right now with NVidia, it is either -rt with no accel, or accel with no -rt.
Thanks,
-- Steve
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Anshuman Gholap <[email protected]>
Date: Nov 4, 2005 9:00 PM
Subject: Re: 3D video card recommendations
To: Steven Rostedt <[email protected]>
Cc: LKML <[email protected]>
Quoted 6 lines
I'm sure ATI will come out with a proprietary driver for 2.6.14. I just want some 3D accel for working with -rt. If I want to play a game, I'll just back out to 2.6.13 and use the ATI binary driver. But right now with NVidia, it is either -rt with no accel, or accel with no -rt.
:) do i need those drivers badly or what.
The americas army 2..5 for linux ~750 mb file is waiting for these
drivers in my /games folder.
Regards,
Anshuman Gholap
Host Server Admin specialist
using Centos 4.2 / Kernel 2.6.14/ E-17 cvs.
On 4 Nov 2005, Mark Knecht announced authoritatively:
Quoted 16 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 6 lines
I'm currently putting together (ordering parts for) another machine. It will be a AMD64 X2. Now I'm looking into a video card for this. Up till now, I've always used NVidia. But I also want to test 3D acceleration under Ingo's -rt patch. So now I need something that does not have a priority module.
Quoted 8 lines
I'm not much of a gamer, although I do play every so often. So I don't need the highest quality card, but I also want something that is still pretty good. For example, I currently have a NVidia GeForce 6800 GT card. So I'm hoping to get something equivalent.
I'm looking at the ATI Radeons.
Any recommendations? (links to info would also be nice ;-)
Quoted 7 lines
Not a recommendation. Just a point to be aware of. The ATI Radeons, to get the best acceleration, seem to require that you use the ATI closed source drivers. Currently I haven't found an ATI closed source driver that supports 2.6.14. so I'm forced to use the Xorg radeon driver. I have no idea if this is very good. I don't think so as my glxgear numbers are pretty low. Much lower than the ATI driver running on 2.6.13-X.
Surely it depends on the Radeon. I get perfectly respectable numbers on my Radeon 9250 (purchased because Dave Airlie said it was well-supported by X.org :) ). It's not exactly Doom-playing quality, but it's good enough for everything I'm doing with it, and it only cost thirty quid:
for that price you can afford to try it and see :)
(Later Radeons' 3D aren't fully supported yet in free drivers, as far as I know.)
Signature · 2 lines
`Heinlein is quite competent at putting together sentences, but usually he also puts together a plot to go with them.' --- Russ Allbery
Quoted 10 lines · Steven Rostedt
I'm currently putting together (ordering parts for) another machine. It will be a AMD64 X2. Now I'm looking into a video card for this. Up till now, I've always used NVidia. But I also want to test 3D acceleration under Ingo's -rt patch. So now I need something that does not have a priority module.
I'm not much of a gamer, although I do play every so often. So I don't need the highest quality card, but I also want something that is still pretty good. For example, I currently have a NVidia GeForce 6800 GT card. So I'm hoping to get something equivalent.
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
By buying a piece of hardware that requires a closed module you take the risk that one of the following can happen at any time
1) The vendor in the future stops considering linux important and you're stuck with old kernels; for example as a side-effect of getting a good deal to supply graphics chips to a certain game console maker
2) The vendor in the future stops considering the hardware you bought important enough to spend time on; after all they got their cash and the product cycles for consumer hardware are often in the 3 to 6 month timeframe. Result: you're stuck with old kernels.
3) The vendor gets sued and convicted for GPL violations and stops doing linux as a result. (not saying it will happen, but it sure is a risk you are taking)
4) The linux kernel developers change the kernel in a way that the module in question no longer is possible and the vendor stops updating the driver
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
6) The vendor doesn't release an x86-64 binary (or other architecture) and your next PC can't use the module anymore
7) The vendor starts charging money for the driver or updates thereof.
Open source is not just something for developers, but also for users. It means that you or anyone else can keep the open driver going even when the manufacturer stops doing so. By using a closed driver you get all the disadvantages of the open source model (yes there are some just that normally the benefits outweigh them by far) without getting the gains. Be very sure you want to do this before spending your hard earned money on hardware that doesn't work without closed drivers.
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Quoted 3 lines
By buying a piece of hardware that requires a closed module you take the risk that one of the following can happen at any time
Yep, I know all these, since I've been a NVidia user for some time. But NVidia was good enough for my needs since the only times I needed 3D was when I wasn't playing with experimental kernels.
Quoted 4 lines
1) The vendor in the future stops considering linux important and you're stuck with old kernels; for example as a side-effect of getting a good deal to supply graphics chips to a certain game console maker
I was able to get some hacks out for NVidia on some new kernels before they were official released. But they were not great, just worked.
Quoted 4 lines
2) The vendor in the future stops considering the hardware you bought important enough to spend time on; after all they got their cash and the product cycles for consumer hardware are often in the 3 to 6 month timeframe. Result: you're stuck with old kernels.
So far NVidia is good at having one driver to do most of their boards. It would take a major design change of a model to stop this, and by then, I would probably have a new video card anyway.
Quoted 3 lines
3) The vendor gets sued and convicted for GPL violations and stops doing linux as a result. (not saying it will happen, but it sure is a risk you are taking)
Could happen, but I doubt it. This might happen if one of the above do first :)
Quoted 3 lines
4) The linux kernel developers change the kernel in a way that the module in question no longer is possible and the vendor stops updating the driver
I've also hacked my kernel to get NVidia working. (Changing EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL back to EXPORT_SYMBOL) It's ok as long as I'm using this just for myself. Which currently I am.
Quoted 1 line
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
MS folks would have the same problem.
Quoted 2 lines
6) The vendor doesn't release an x86-64 binary (or other architecture) and your next PC can't use the module anymore
Hmm, x86-64 _is_ what I'll be using this on :-/
Quoted 1 line
7) The vendor starts charging money for the driver or updates thereof.
Good way to lose customers.
Quoted 9 lines
Open source is not just something for developers, but also for users. It means that you or anyone else can keep the open driver going even when the manufacturer stops doing so. By using a closed driver you get all the disadvantages of the open source model (yes there are some just that normally the benefits outweigh them by far) without getting the gains. Be very sure you want to do this before spending your hard earned money on hardware that doesn't work without closed drivers.
I totally agree with you on this, that's why my question was about a good "Open Source" 3D card in the first place. I want to try out 3D on Ingo's RT patch set and NVidia (because of the above that you mentioned) doesn't cut it anymore. I've heard that the Radeon open source drive isn't too bad so I went with them. I don't need the best 3D, but I do need something.
So you are right. I've been a loyal NVidia customer for several years now, but since there is no alternative of a reliable 3D driver for them, I had to leave them to do what I needed. Now they risk me never going back if I find out that I like ATI better.
-- Steve
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers. Don't know if they work with AMD64, though.
There's also the OpenGraphics development work. See the summary at
http://kerneltrap.org/node/5743
Hugo.
Signature · 4 lines
=== Hugo Mills: hugo@... carfax.org.uk | darksatanic.net | lug.org.uk ===
PGP key: 1C335860 from wwwkeys.eu.pgp.net or http://www.carfax.org.uk
--- Anyone using a computer to generate random numbers is, of ---
course, in a state of sin. Quoted 5 lines · Hugo Mills
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers. Don't know if they work with AMD64, though.
[ http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2005/05/03/club3d_volari_v3xt/2.html ]
System Setup:
AMD Athlon 64 FX-55 (operating at 1600MHz - 8x200); (...)
Volari V3XT seems to work on amd64.
Signature · 3 lines
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil
is for good men to do nothing.
- Edmund BurkeQuoted 7 lines · Paweł Sikora
Quoted 5 lines · Hugo Mills
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers. Don't know if they work with AMD64, though.
Quoted 6 lines
[ http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2005/05/03/club3d_volari_v3xt/2.html ]
System Setup:
AMD Athlon 64 FX-55 (operating at 1600MHz - 8x200); (...)Volari V3XT seems to work on amd64.
ps).
"XGI had released its source-code to the Linux community, but what they
failed to mention in their press release was that the 3D acceleration portion of their drivers would remain closed-source."
(...)
Although it will be very unlikely for XGI to open up the 3D portion of their drivers anytime in the near future, due to fierce competition from NVIDIA and ATI drivers."
Signature · 3 lines
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil
is for good men to do nothing.
- Edmund BurkeQuoted 7 lines · Hugo Mills
Quoted 6 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers.
That's not entirely true. The DRI driver is closed source.
Signature · 3 lines
Ville Syrjälä [email protected] http://www.sci.fi/~syrjala/
Quoted 13 lines · Ville Syrjälä
Quoted 11 lines · Hugo Mills
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers.That's not entirely true. The DRI driver is closed source.
DRI closed source ? You mean the fglrx driver from ati ?
Anyway my advice would be to look at dri project an see the supported card list. http://dri.freedesktop.org
if you want a card with open source 3d driver.
ATI & Intel graphics chipset seems to have the best open source support i am aware of. For ATI the r300/r400 (radeon 9500-9800/ X300-X800) support is still experimental (IIRC there are PCI-E issues).
best,
Jerome Glisse
Quoted 28 lines · Jerome Glisse
Quoted 13 lines · Ville Syrjälä
Quoted 11 lines · Hugo Mills
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers.That's not entirely true. The DRI driver is closed source.
DRI closed source ? You mean the fglrx driver from ati ?
Anyway my advice would be to look at dri project an see the supported card list. http://dri.freedesktop.org
if you want a card with open source 3d driver.
Quoted 7 lines
ATI & Intel graphics chipset seems to have the best open source support i am aware of. For ATI the r300/r400 (radeon 9500-9800/ X300-X800) support is still experimental (IIRC there are PCI-E issues).
best,
Jerome Glisse
FGLRX won't function at all with 2.6.14 and requires patching to work with 2.6.13.
And your right there are PCI-E issues.. the cards work but no direct rendering is supported although I did see some patches head to Linus that fix that. (waiting for the next pre release so mine will work.. I should really sit down and learn GIT)
Gerhard
--
Gerhard Mack
<>< As a computer I find your faith in technology amusing.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Quoted 11 lines · Jerome Glisse
Quoted 8 lines · Ville Syrjälä
Quoted 4 lines · Hugo Mills
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers.That's not entirely true. The DRI driver is closed source.
DRI closed source ? You mean the fglrx driver from ati ?
No. He means the 3D driver for the Xgi cards. However, Xgi is apparently working with some folks in the community to remedy this. I haven't heard any updates in a *long* time, so it's possible that things may have stalled.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.6 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFDb4JJX1gOwKyEAw8RAs82AJsGOC+O0An18TmxXV7XbjJ+EreTdQCfZf8e aNljl61xsZ5RGlFu8uSgC68=
=YkIR
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Quoted 16 lines · Jerome Glisse
Quoted 15 lines · Ville Syrjälä
Quoted 13 lines · Hugo Mills
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
http://www.xgitech.com/
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Not the fastest pieces of hardware out there by some way, but they
_do_ have open-source drivers.That's not entirely true. The DRI driver is closed source.
DRI closed source ? You mean the fglrx driver from ati ?
No, I mean the XGI drivers.
Signature · 3 lines
Ville Syrjälä [email protected] http://www.sci.fi/~syrjala/
Quoted 3 lines · Steven Rostedt
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Some of the radeons - R3xx is pretty close to usable R2xx works well. Support for running 32bit hardware accelerated apps on 64bit kernel recently went in.
Quoted 8 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 3 lines · Steven Rostedt
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Some of the radeons - R3xx is pretty close to usable R2xx works well. Support for running 32bit hardware accelerated apps on 64bit kernel recently went in.
I'm using a Radeon 9600 (R350) with debian packages (32bits userspace, 64bits kernel) since a few weeks, and it works very well, apart from a few visual glitches here and there (the only GL apps I use are some free games, blender and some screensavers). The only thing I had to recompile was the drm moduleset.
xav
Quoted 9 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 3 lines · Steven Rostedt
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
Some of the radeons - R3xx is pretty close to usable R2xx works well. Support for running 32bit hardware accelerated apps on 64bit kernel recently went in.
I would also suggest avoiding PCI-E cards for the time being as there is no DRI support for them. (although if I'm not mistaken that will improve in 2.6.15).
Gerhard
--
Gerhard Mack
<>< As a computer I find your faith in technology amusing.
Quoted 5 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
MS folks would have the same problem.
...which proves the point Arjan is making.
For one, I have an ISDN-adapter which doesn't work with any version of MS-Windows from this millennium (no drivers available), while it's still working great on current Linux kernels.
Regards,
Toon.
Quoted 5 lines · Toon van der Pas
Quoted 4 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
MS folks would have the same problem.
...which proves the point Arjan is making.
For one, I have an ISDN-adapter which doesn't work with any version of MS-Windows from this millennium (no drivers available), while it's still working great on current Linux kernels.
well despite your post; the Windows people are a lot better at keeping old drivers working (win 9x to a NT based kernel was obviously a huge change though). In linux you can use an old driver maybe for 6 months if you're lucky.. in windows 6 years is no exception. So the problem is a lot bigger in linux for the owner of such a card than it is in windows.
Quoted 15 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Quoted 5 lines · Toon van der Pas
Quoted 4 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
MS folks would have the same problem.
...which proves the point Arjan is making.
For one, I have an ISDN-adapter which doesn't work with any version of MS-Windows from this millennium (no drivers available), while it's still working great on current Linux kernels.
Quoted 6 lines
well despite your post; the Windows people are a lot better at keeping old drivers working (win 9x to a NT based kernel was obviously a huge change though). In linux you can use an old driver maybe for 6 months if you're lucky.. in windows 6 years is no exception. So the problem is a lot bigger in linux for the owner of such a card than it is in windows.
Only if the Linux driver is closed source. Otherwise, the driver should be upgraded with the kernel. Most all open source hardware drivers are already included in the kernel, and maintained as long as there's someone that has the device that can maintain it.
-- Steve
Quoted 8 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 5 lines · Arjan van de Ven
well despite your post; the Windows people are a lot better at keeping old drivers working (win 9x to a NT based kernel was obviously a huge change though). In linux you can use an old driver maybe for 6 months if you're lucky.. in windows 6 years is no exception. So the problem is a lot bigger in linux for the owner of such a card than it is in windows.
Quoted 4 lines
Only if the Linux driver is closed source. Otherwise, the driver should be upgraded with the kernel. Most all open source hardware drivers are already included in the kernel, and maintained as long as there's someone that has the device that can maintain it.
I'd rather not count the drivers that have dropped out of open source operating systems due to bit rot. If there is no maintainer, the hardware will become useless sooner or later. With Linux's rapidly changing "moving target" 2.6.X I'd call it sooner rather than later.
OSS drivers are good iff there is a maintainer - IOW: to the user, the maintainer makes the difference, not the driver being open source.
Signature · 1 line
Matthias Andree
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Matthias" == Matthias Andree <[email protected]> writes:
Matthias> I'd rather not count the drivers that have dropped out of Matthias> open source operating systems due to bit rot. If there is no Matthias> maintainer, the hardware will become useless sooner or Matthias> later. With Linux's rapidly changing "moving target" 2.6.X Matthias> I'd call it sooner rather than later.
Matthias> OSS drivers are good iff there is a maintainer - IOW: to the Matthias> user, the maintainer makes the difference, not the driver Matthias> being open source.
No, a publically available spec for the hardware is what makes the difference. Those drivers which are reverse engineered, or which have only partially open specs are the ones which bit-rot the fastest.
For example, I've got a webcam which I've never been able to make work properly due to the PWC driver and the lack of documentation from Philips on the chipset. Even with heroic efforts by others, it's just hard to do.
But if we have docs, we could support this camera until the end of time, as long as people were interested in supporting it.
John
Quoted 7 lines · Matthias Andree
I'd rather not count the drivers that have dropped out of open source operating systems due to bit rot. If there is no maintainer, the hardware will become useless sooner or later. With Linux's rapidly changing "moving target" 2.6.X I'd call it sooner rather than later.
OSS drivers are good iff there is a maintainer - IOW: to the user, the maintainer makes the difference, not the driver being open source.
You're right - but the existence of a unmaintained open source driver makes possible and easier to write a maintained driver. Which is important, too
Quoted 4 lines · Matthias Andree
I'd rather not count the drivers that have dropped out of open source operating systems due to bit rot. If there is no maintainer, the hardware will become useless sooner or later. With Linux's rapidly changing "moving target" 2.6.X I'd call it sooner rather than later
If there is no maintainer and there is demand for the driver then I guess the end users need to remember its a development model and not a charity. The problem should then be self correcting if the docs/driver are open
Quoted 2 lines
OSS drivers are good iff there is a maintainer - IOW: to the user, the maintainer makes the difference, not the driver being open source.
No. If the code is open source the user can get it fixed, if it is closed source then they are screwed because support is by vendor dictat. If Nvidia drop TNT2 you can't pay a local consultant to fix it.
Alan
Quoted 7 lines · Toon van der Pas
Quoted 1 line
MS folks would have the same problem.
...which proves the point Arjan is making.
For one, I have an ISDN-adapter which doesn't work with any version of MS-Windows from this millennium (no drivers available), while it's still working great on current Linux kernels.
agreed, I have the same problems with a creative (a well know vendor) webcam. Stopped working on SP2.
The problem in windows (and linux closed-sourced drivers) is _much_ bigger than it seems. Soon all CPUs will be 64-bit capable and dual core, and that brings two problems: 64-bit-compatible drivers and SMP-safe drivers. I used to have a cheap winmodem which would deadlock my smp machine. There're lots of crappy windows drivers which haven't been even tested in a smp machine it seems. If you buy a dual-core machine and your vendor has gone out of bussines or the "support period" is expired you migh need to buy new hardware :(
The 64-bit driver issue is bigger: Even HP has already a (somewhat long) list of printers which HP is definitively _never_ going to support in 64 bit platforms (and that's HP, you can imagine what small vendors are doing). It seems that most of desktop hardware makers are supporting the 64 bit windows platform just for new devices - unless you had 64 bit in mind when you created it (which is not possible, because nobody knew what was going to happen in the 64 bit desktop land until intel supported x86-64) supporting 64 bit may be very well impossible, since they need to port the drivers of all the thousands of devices they've made through years, and the windows platform doesn't make it easier (pointers are obviously 64-bit long in the windows 64 bit platform but longs are still 32 bit for compatibility and driver programmers don't find it helpful I've heard)
I wish there was opensource drivers for windows. Maybe the fact that some companies are opening them in linux will make that easier in the future :/
Hi,
I'd like to thank all those that responded. Unfortunately, I was not very patient and already bought something before most of you responded. That's my fault.
So, this is what I'm getting:
ATI (Connect3D) Radeon X800 GTO 256MB GDDR3/PCI-E/VIVO/DVI (Retail Box) For $179 at Monarch computer.
Gerhard Mack recommended avoiding the PCI-E since there is no support yet for DRI. Right now I don't care about that (thinking it will be supported in the future) and all that I read was to go with the PCI-E instead of the AGP. I could be wrong.
I'll keep the list posted of problems/solutions that I come across with this card.
Thanks,
-- Steve
Quoted 26 lines · Steven Rostedt
Date: Mon, 07 Nov 2005 12:30:24 -0500
From: Steven Rostedt <[email protected]>
To: LKML <[email protected]>
Cc: Gerhard Mack <[email protected]>, Xavier Bestel <[email protected]>,
Alan Cox <[email protected]>, Hugo Mills <[email protected]>, Nix <[email protected]>, Anshuman Gholap <[email protected]>, Mark Knecht <[email protected]>, Diego Calleja <[email protected]>, Toon van der Pas <[email protected]>, [email protected]
Subject: Re: 3D video card recommendationsHi,
I'd like to thank all those that responded. Unfortunately, I was not very patient and already bought something before most of you responded. That's my fault.
So, this is what I'm getting:
ATI (Connect3D) Radeon X800 GTO 256MB GDDR3/PCI-E/VIVO/DVI (Retail Box) For $179 at Monarch computer.
Gerhard Mack recommended avoiding the PCI-E since there is no support yet for DRI. Right now I don't care about that (thinking it will be supported in the future) and all that I read was to go with the PCI-E instead of the AGP. I could be wrong.
Quoted 6 lines
I'll keep the list posted of problems/solutions that I come across with this card.
Thanks,
-- Steve
Way ahead of you .. I have such a list since I own the PCI-E X300 ;)
Your better off than I am since I bought mine two months ago.
Gerhard
--
Gerhard Mack
<>< As a computer I find your faith in technology amusing.
Quoted 6 lines · Gerhard Mack
Way ahead of you .. I have such a list since I own the PCI-E X300 ;)
Your better off than I am since I bought mine two months ago.
Gerhard
Are you running this on a x86_64 machine?
-- Steve
Quoted 10 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 6 lines · Gerhard Mack
Way ahead of you .. I have such a list since I own the PCI-E X300 ;)
Your better off than I am since I bought mine two months ago.
Gerhard
Are you running this on a
x86_64machine?
Yes.. it works I just don't get direct rendering.
Gerhard
--
Gerhard Mack
<>< As a computer I find your faith in technology amusing.
Quoted 5 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Gerhard Mack
Way ahead of you .. I have such a list since I own the PCI-E X300 ;)
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Your better off than I am since I bought mine two months ago.
Gerhard
Are you running this on a
x86_64machine?-- Steve
Steven,
Hi . I run my ATI PCI_Express card on a 64-bit kernel. (2.6.14-rt6)
It works fine for my needs, although as I said earlier my glxgears numbers are nothing to shout about:
0000:01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)]
0000:01:00.1 Display controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 [Radeon X300SE]
mark@lightning ~ $ glxgears
Xlib: extension "XFree86-DRI" missing on display ":0.0". 3170 frames in 5.0 seconds = 634.000 FPS
3416 frames in 5.0 seconds = 683.200 FPS
3294 frames in 5.0 seconds = 658.800 FPS
mark@lightning ~ $
I'm using the radeon driver from the Xorg-X11 package. The only
problem I've run into which remains unsolved is that when I run either Quicken or IE6 under Crossover Office 5.0 all of the icons in those windows programs show up in black and white, not color, so they are somewhat unreadable. Other than that no real problems.
- Mark
On Mon, 2005-11-07 at 10:01 -0800, Mark Knecht wrote:
Mark thanks for the update.
Quoted 10 lines
Steven,
Hi . I run my ATIPCI_Expresscard on a 64-bit kernel. (2.6.14-rt6)
It works fine for my needs, although as I said earlier my glxgears numbers are nothing to shout about:0000:01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)]
0000:01:00.1 Display controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 [Radeon X300SE]
Quoted 5 lines
mark@lightning ~ $ glxgears
Xlib: extension "XFree86-DRI" missing on display ":0.0". 3170 frames in 5.0 seconds = 634.000 FPS
3416 frames in 5.0 seconds = 683.200 FPS
3294 frames in 5.0 seconds = 658.800 FPS
These aren't too shabby, but then again compared to my NVidia (non-rt obviously) with their binary driver):
0000:01:05.0 VGA compatible controller: nVidia Corporation NV40 [GeForce 6800 GT] (rev a1)
$ glxgears 49961 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9992.200 FPS 48599 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9719.800 FPS 55592 frames in 5.0 seconds = 11118.400 FPS 47395 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9479.000 FPS
What do you get with the ATI binary driver?
Quoted 9 lines
mark@lightning ~ $
I'm using the radeon driver from the Xorg-X11 package. The only
problem I've run into which remains unsolved is that when I run either Quicken or IE6 under Crossover Office 5.0 all of the icons in those windows programs show up in black and white, not color, so they are somewhat unreadable. Other than that no real problems.
Sorry, I can't help you there. I don't have access to IE or Quicken (well, it's on my wife's computer, but she won't let me put Linux on it! :-(
-- Steve
Quoted 26 lines · Steven Rostedt
On Mon, 2005-11-07 at 10:01 -0800, Mark Knecht wrote:
Mark thanks for the update.
Quoted 10 lines
Steven,
Hi . I run my ATIPCI_Expresscard on a 64-bit kernel. (2.6.14-rt6)
It works fine for my needs, although as I said earlier my glxgears numbers are nothing to shout about:0000:01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)]
0000:01:00.1 Display controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 [Radeon X300SE]Quoted 5 lines
mark@lightning ~ $ glxgears
Xlib: extension "XFree86-DRI" missing on display ":0.0". 3170 frames in 5.0 seconds = 634.000 FPS
3416 frames in 5.0 seconds = 683.200 FPS
3294 frames in 5.0 seconds = 658.800 FPSThese aren't too shabby, but then again compared to my NVidia (non-rt obviously) with their binary driver):
0000:01:05.0 VGA compatible controller: nVidia Corporation NV40 [GeForce 6800 GT] (rev a1)
Quoted 7 lines
$ glxgears 49961 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9992.200 FPS 48599 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9719.800 FPS 55592 frames in 5.0 seconds = 11118.400 FPS 47395 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9479.000 FPSWhat do you get with the ATI binary driver?
Last time I tried (circa 2.6.14-rc3-rtX) it didn't load correctly. Note that this was the ati-drivers package from portage and not an ATI driver package from ATI so possibly that was part of the problem.
I should probably try again one of these days but high speed graphics are not an issue for me on this machine. It's used for audio work mostly.
Cheers,
Mark
Quoted 50 lines · Mark Knecht
Date: Mon, 7 Nov 2005 10:31:35 -0800
From: Mark Knecht <[email protected]>
To: Steven Rostedt <[email protected]>
Cc: Gerhard Mack <[email protected]>, LKML <[email protected]>,
Xavier Bestel <[email protected]>,
Alan Cox <[email protected]>, Hugo Mills <[email protected]>, Nix <[email protected]>, Anshuman Gholap <[email protected]>, Diego Calleja <[email protected]>,
Toon van der Pas <[email protected]>, [email protected]
Subject: Re: 3D video card recommendationsQuoted 26 lines · Steven Rostedt
On Mon, 2005-11-07 at 10:01 -0800, Mark Knecht wrote:
Mark thanks for the update.
Quoted 10 lines
Steven,
Hi . I run my ATIPCI_Expresscard on a 64-bit kernel. (2.6.14-rt6)
It works fine for my needs, although as I said earlier my glxgears numbers are nothing to shout about:0000:01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)]
0000:01:00.1 Display controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 [Radeon X300SE]Quoted 5 lines
mark@lightning ~ $ glxgears
Xlib: extension "XFree86-DRI" missing on display ":0.0". 3170 frames in 5.0 seconds = 634.000 FPS
3416 frames in 5.0 seconds = 683.200 FPS
3294 frames in 5.0 seconds = 658.800 FPSThese aren't too shabby, but then again compared to my NVidia (non-rt obviously) with their binary driver):
0000:01:05.0 VGA compatible controller: nVidia Corporation NV40 [GeForce 6800 GT] (rev a1)
Quoted 7 lines
$ glxgears 49961 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9992.200 FPS 48599 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9719.800 FPS 55592 frames in 5.0 seconds = 11118.400 FPS 47395 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9479.000 FPSWhat do you get with the ATI binary driver?
Last time I tried (circa 2.6.14-rc3-rtX) it didn't load correctly. Note that this was the ati-drivers package from portage and not an ATI driver package from ATI so possibly that was part of the problem.
Quoted 6 lines
I should probably try again one of these days but high speed graphics are not an issue for me on this machine. It's used for audio work mostly.
Cheers,
Mark
Not worth trying. I spent a couple weeks with ATI tech support trying to get it working with no luck. It can work with a 32 bit kernel with some patching but won't work at all with a 64 bit kernel.
Gerhard
--
Gerhard Mack
<>< As a computer I find your faith in technology amusing.
Quoted 56 lines · Gerhard Mack
Quoted 54 lines · Mark Knecht
Date: Mon, 7 Nov 2005 10:31:35 -0800
From: Mark Knecht <[email protected]>
To: Steven Rostedt <[email protected]>
Cc: Gerhard Mack <[email protected]>, LKML <[email protected]>,
Xavier Bestel <[email protected]>,
Alan Cox <[email protected]>, Hugo Mills <[email protected]>, Nix <[email protected]>, Anshuman Gholap <[email protected]>, Diego Calleja <[email protected]>,
Toon van der Pas <[email protected]>, [email protected]
Subject: Re: 3D video card recommendationsQuoted 26 lines · Steven Rostedt
On Mon, 2005-11-07 at 10:01 -0800, Mark Knecht wrote:
Mark thanks for the update.
Quoted 10 lines
Steven,
Hi . I run my ATIPCI_Expresscard on a 64-bit kernel. (2.6.14-rt6)
It works fine for my needs, although as I said earlier my glxgears numbers are nothing to shout about:0000:01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)]
0000:01:00.1 Display controller: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 [Radeon X300SE]Quoted 5 lines
mark@lightning ~ $ glxgears
Xlib: extension "XFree86-DRI" missing on display ":0.0". 3170 frames in 5.0 seconds = 634.000 FPS
3416 frames in 5.0 seconds = 683.200 FPS
3294 frames in 5.0 seconds = 658.800 FPSThese aren't too shabby, but then again compared to my NVidia (non-rt obviously) with their binary driver):
0000:01:05.0 VGA compatible controller: nVidia Corporation NV40 [GeForce 6800 GT] (rev a1)
Quoted 7 lines
$ glxgears 49961 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9992.200 FPS 48599 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9719.800 FPS 55592 frames in 5.0 seconds = 11118.400 FPS 47395 frames in 5.0 seconds = 9479.000 FPSWhat do you get with the ATI binary driver?
Last time I tried (circa 2.6.14-rc3-rtX) it didn't load correctly. Note that this was the ati-drivers package from portage and not an ATI driver package from ATI so possibly that was part of the problem.
I should probably try again one of these days but high speed graphics are not an issue for me on this machine. It's used for audio work mostly.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Cheers,
MarkNot worth trying. I spent a couple weeks with ATI tech support trying to get it working with no luck. It can work with a 32 bit kernel with some patching but won't work at all with a 64 bit kernel.
Gerhard
Thanks. I was just looking at emerge output and wondering if I wanted to mess with this. I didn't, but now I have a good reason!
Thanks,
Mark
Quoted 6 lines · Mark Knecht
I'm using the radeon driver from the Xorg-X11 package. The only
problem I've run into which remains unsolved is that when I run either Quicken or IE6 under Crossover Office 5.0 all of the icons in those windows programs show up in black and white, not color, so they are somewhat unreadable. Other than that no real problems.
Um, didn't you say you were still getting audio underruns correlated with display activity? I still think it's a bug in the Xorg radeon driver.
Lee
Quoted 8 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 6 lines · Mark Knecht
I'm using the radeon driver from the Xorg-X11 package. The only
problem I've run into which remains unsolved is that when I run either Quicken or IE6 under Crossover Office 5.0 all of the icons in those windows programs show up in black and white, not color, so they are somewhat unreadable. Other than that no real problems.
Quoted 5 lines
Um, didn't you say you were still getting audio underruns correlated with display activity? I still think it's a bug in the Xorg radeon driver.
Lee
Hi Lee,
It very well could be a video issue causing my xruns. That's been
the biggest, but not olny, factor, but I don't know any more. I've gone down so many paths that haven't yielded results.
I've tried the NoAccel and RenderAccel experiments you suggested.
You also mentioned not loading DRI which I guess isn't possible anyway with a PCI-Express card. Anyway, I don't have it loaded.
While I do get xruns, they are happening lately only a couple of
times a day, and usually very late in the day after the machine has been running for 12+ hours. If I pull Jack back to 256/2 then I don't think I get them at all so I'm living with it for now and hoping for a solution one of these days. Low latency really only matters to me when recording which is <5% of the time.
I'm most interested in a kernel developer finding the time to fix
the IRQoff latency testing on 64-bit machines so I can look at that.
In case the question comes to mind for others, this HDSP 9652 sound
card runs for months at a time at 64/2 in my older Via 32-bit machine. The problem only surfaced when I moved it to my new AMD64 machine.
Anyway, that's status. It's a frustration, not a killer issue.
Cheers,
Mark
Quoted 3 lines · Mark Knecht
I'm most interested in a kernel developer finding the time to fix
the IRQoff latency testing on 64-bit machines so I can look at that.
Well, when I get all my pieces and then the box up and running, I might just be that developer ;-)
-- Steve
Quoted 17 lines · Mark Knecht
Quoted 6 lines · Lee Revell
Um, didn't you say you were still getting audio underruns correlated with display activity? I still think it's a bug in the Xorg radeon driver.
Lee
Hi Lee,
It very well could be a video issue causing my xruns. That's been
the biggest, but not olny, factor, but I don't know any more. I've gone down so many paths that haven't yielded results.I've tried the NoAccel and RenderAccel experiments you suggested.
You also mentioned not loading DRI which I guess isn't possible anyway with a PCI-Express card. Anyway, I don't have it loaded.
Quoted 6 lines
While I do get xruns, they are happening lately only a couple of
times a day, and usually very late in the day after the machine has been running for 12+ hours. If I pull Jack back to 256/2 then I don't think I get them at all so I'm living with it for now and hoping for a solution one of these days. Low latency really only matters to me when recording which is <5% of the time.
After looking at the Radeon driver I'm increasingly convinced that it's causing your problems.
Please try disabling Xscreensaver and see if the xruns go away - looking at radeonfb it seems like the xruns could be triggered by video mode switching, there are lots of places where it loops waiting for the hardware to be ready. If that eliminates them I have a patch you can try.
Lee
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 3 lines · Arjan van de Ven
people who buy a 3D card for linux that depends on a closed source module take a few risks, and they should be aware of them (I suspect they are) so let me make some of them explicit:
Are there good 3D cards that don't depend on a proprietary module, that can run on a AMD64 board? That was pretty much my questing to begin with :)
radeon 9200/9250 is decent though not exceptional (quality is fine, opengl performance is about 2 years behind state of the art). and uses the opensource x.org radeon opengl module.
Quoted 84 lines
Quoted 3 lines
By buying a piece of hardware that requires a closed module you take the risk that one of the following can happen at any time
Yep, I know all these, since I've been a NVidia user for some time. But NVidia was good enough for my needs since the only times I needed 3D was when I wasn't playing with experimental kernels.
Quoted 4 lines
1) The vendor in the future stops considering linux important and you're stuck with old kernels; for example as a side-effect of getting a good deal to supply graphics chips to a certain game console maker
I was able to get some hacks out for NVidia on some new kernels before they were official released. But they were not great, just worked.
Quoted 4 lines
2) The vendor in the future stops considering the hardware you bought important enough to spend time on; after all they got their cash and the product cycles for consumer hardware are often in the 3 to 6 month timeframe. Result: you're stuck with old kernels.
So far NVidia is good at having one driver to do most of their boards. It would take a major design change of a model to stop this, and by then, I would probably have a new video card anyway.
Quoted 3 lines
3) The vendor gets sued and convicted for GPL violations and stops doing linux as a result. (not saying it will happen, but it sure is a risk you are taking)
Could happen, but I doubt it. This might happen if one of the above do first :)
Quoted 3 lines
4) The linux kernel developers change the kernel in a way that the module in question no longer is possible and the vendor stops updating the driver
I've also hacked my kernel to get NVidia working. (Changing
EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPLback toEXPORT_SYMBOL) It's ok as long as I'm using this just for myself. Which currently I am.Quoted 1 line
5) The vendor goes out of business and thus stops updating the driver
MS folks would have the same problem.
Quoted 2 lines
6) The vendor doesn't release an x86-64 binary (or other architecture) and your next PC can't use the module anymore
Hmm, x86-64 _is_ what I'll be using this on :-/
Quoted 1 line
7) The vendor starts charging money for the driver or updates thereof.
Good way to lose customers.
Quoted 9 lines
Open source is not just something for developers, but also for users. It means that you or anyone else can keep the open driver going even when the manufacturer stops doing so. By using a closed driver you get all the disadvantages of the open source model (yes there are some just that normally the benefits outweigh them by far) without getting the gains. Be very sure you want to do this before spending your hard earned money on hardware that doesn't work without closed drivers.
I totally agree with you on this, that's why my question was about a good "Open Source" 3D card in the first place. I want to try out 3D on Ingo's RT patch set and NVidia (because of the above that you mentioned) doesn't cut it anymore. I've heard that the Radeon open source drive isn't too bad so I went with them. I don't need the best 3D, but I do need something.
So you are right. I've been a loyal NVidia customer for several years now, but since there is no alternative of a reliable 3D driver for them, I had to leave them to do what I needed. Now they risk me never going back if I find out that I like ATI better.
-- Steve
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
Signature · 3 lines
-------------------------------------------------------------------------- Joel Jaeggli Unix Consulting [email protected] GPG Key Fingerprint: 5C6E 0104 BAF0 40B0 5BD3 C38B F000 35AB B67F 56B2
Quoted 9 lines · Steven Rostedt
Quoted 4 lines · Arjan van de Ven
2) The vendor in the future stops considering the hardware you bought important enough to spend time on; after all they got their cash and the product cycles for consumer hardware are often in the 3 to 6 month timeframe. Result: you're stuck with old kernels.
So far NVidia is good at having one driver to do most of their boards. It would take a major design change of a model to stop this, and by then, I would probably have a new video card anyway.
they just dropped support for the TNT2 (and old Geforce IIRC) boards some months ago, so my son needed a new video card although the old one was perfectly good.
Signature · 2 lines
seife
Never trust a computer you can't lift.Quoted 3 lines · Stefan Seyfried
they just dropped support for the TNT2 (and old Geforce IIRC) boards some months ago, so my son needed a new video card although the old one was perfectly good.
Not that the 71.x drivers don't still work for old cards. My TNT2 is doing just fine at the moment.
They are also planing (they claim) to offer packages for the older cards (at least I read someone was planning to continue offering packages for the older driver series.)
Of course I might have problems when I try using 2.6.14, although 2.6.12 has no problems.
Len Sorensen