Configure.help editorial policy
Quoted 3 lines
Most disk sizes are an unholy mixture of the two
that deserves a stake through the heart,
where 1 GB = 1,024,000,000 bytes.
"Are"??
I see several good people spout this particular type of nonsense here. If I interpret "are" to mean that that is the unit disk manufacturers use, then it is false - as far as I know no manufacturer uses this.
Let us look at Maxtor. They are so friendly to give disk size as part of the type.
Maxtor 91728D8 - 17280442368 bytes, 17280 MB, 17.2 GB Maxtor 93652U8 - 36529274880 bytes, 36529 MB, 36.5 GB Maxtor 96147H6 - 61473226752 bytes, 61473 MB, 61.4 GB
You see that the number of GB claimed by the manufacturer is just (number of megabytes)/1000.
There is no 2.4% difference that could justify your strange claim.
All disk manufacturers always use decimal.
And this has been true for many years.
Andries
Quoted 9 lines · On Thu, 27 Dec 2001 [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 3 lines
Most disk sizes are an unholy mixture of the two
that deserves a stake through the heart,
where 1 GB = 1,024,000,000 bytes."Are"??
I see several good people spout this particular type of nonsense here. If I interpret "are" to mean that that is the unit disk manufacturers use, then it is false - as far as I know no manufacturer uses this.
How about IBM. According to the datasheet at
http://www.storage.ibm.com/hdd/desk/ds120gxp.htm
Deskstar 120GXP with 120GB capacity has 24125472 sectors (123522416640 bytes).
That is 123.5GB if G=10^9 but 120.6GB if G=10^6*2^10 (and merely 115.0GB if G=2^30).
Horrible? Yes.
(The same is true for 40GB and 80GB versions of 120GXP, and my (older model) 30GB and 40GB IBM drives.)
Quoted 9 lines
Let us look at Maxtor. They are so friendly to give disk size as part of the type.
Maxtor 91728D8 - 17280442368 bytes, 17280 MB, 17.2 GB Maxtor 93652U8 - 36529274880 bytes, 36529 MB, 36.5 GB Maxtor 96147H6 - 61473226752 bytes, 61473 MB, 61.4 GBYou see that the number of GB claimed by the manufacturer is just (number of megabytes)/1000.
There is no 2.4% difference that could justify your strange claim.
So Maxtor lies 7.37% while IBM lies only 4.86%?
BTW does anybody else remember when this insanity started? I seem to remember that in the begining of the 90's some manufacturers re-defined (binary) MB as 1000kB and others had to follow (most likely because stupid buyers usually bought the drive with 2.4% bigger figure without realizing it was the same size as the other.)
Quoted 1 line
Andries
// /