Skip to contentSkip to conversation

bpf development stats for 6.6

ANN Stanislav Fomichev 3 participants 3 messages Aug 30, 2023 – Aug 31, 2023

Subsystems (3)
lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

See the netdev posting for more info and context:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm posting a link to the previous cycle below so people can do the comparison if needed. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc.

Previous cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

Current cycle:
28 Jun to 29 Aug: 5240 mailing list messages, 62 days, 85 messages per day 384 repo commits (6 commits/day)

6.5 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 ( +1) [11] Alexei Starovoitov      1 ( +1) [23] Alexei Starovoitov  
   2 ( -1) [ 7] Yonghong Song           2 ( +1) [15] Yonghong Song       
   3 ( +5) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau        3 ( +4) [ 9] Stanislav Fomichev  
   4 ( +3) [ 4] Stanislav Fomichev      4 ( -3) [ 7] Andrii Nakryiko     
   5 ( -1) [ 4] Daniel Borkmann         5 ( +5) [ 7] Martin KaFai Lau    
   6 ( +3) [ 3] Jakub Kicinski          6 (+15) [ 5] Hou Tao             
   7 ( -2) [ 3] Jiri Olsa               7 ( +7) [ 5] Jakub Kicinski      
   8 ( -5) [ 2] Andrii Nakryiko         8 ( -2) [ 4] Daniel Borkmann     
   9 (***) [ 2] Hou Tao                 9 (+13) [ 4] Jesper Dangaard Brouer

10 (+16) [ 2] Jesper Dangaard Brouer 10 (+17) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman
11 ( +7) [ 2] John Fastabend 11 ( -2) [ 4] Steven Rostedt
12 ( +3) [ 2] Eduard Zingerman 12 (***) [ 4] Alan Maguire

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 ( +9) [3] Yonghong Song            1 ( +5) [20] Jiri Olsa           
   2 (   ) [2] Yafang Shao              2 (+30) [17] Yonghong Song       
   3 (***) [2] Geliang Tang             3 ( +8) [10] Larysa Zaremba      
   4 ( +5) [1] Daniel Borkmann          4 (   ) [10] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 ( +2) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)    5 (***) [ 8] Geliang Tang        
   6 ( -2) [1] Jiri Olsa                6 ( -3) [ 8] Maciej Fijalkowski  
   7 (+19) [1] Kui-Feng Lee             7 ( -5) [ 6] Yafang Shao         
   8 (+40) [1] Dave Marchevsky          8 (+12) [ 6] Dave Marchevsky     
   9 (***) [1] Rong Tao                 9 (+15) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann     

10 (***) [1] Daniel Xu 10 (***) [ 5] Hao Xu

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [20] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta                
   2 (   ) [ 8] Isovalent               2 (   ) [16] RedHat              
   3 (   ) [ 7] Google                  3 ( +1) [15] Google              
   4 (   ) [ 6] RedHat                  4 ( -1) [12] Isovalent           
   5 (   ) [ 3] Intel                   5 (   ) [ 7] Intel               
   6 ( +3) [ 3] Huawei                  6 ( +2) [ 7] Huawei              
   7 (+24) [ 2] Oracle                  7 (+41) [ 4] Oracle              
   8 ( -2) [ 2] Corigine                8 (+49) [ 3] Rivos               
   9 ( -1) [ 1] nVidia                  9 ( -3) [ 3] Corigine            

10 (+34) [ 1] Rivos 10 ( -3) [ 2] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [9] Meta                     1 (   ) [40] Meta                
   2 ( +3) [6] Huawei                   2 ( +1) [31] Isovalent           
   3 ( -1) [4] Isovalent                3 ( +1) [24] Intel               
   4 ( -1) [3] Google                   4 ( +2) [19] Huawei              
   5 ( +1) [3] Intel                    5 ( -3) [17] Google              
   6 ( -2) [2] RedHat                   6 ( +2) [ 9] RedHat              
   7 (***) [2] Juniper Networks         7 (***) [ 8] SUSE                
   8 (***) [2] SUSE                     8 ( +5) [ 7] Bytedance           
   9 ( +8) [1] Oracle                   9 (***) [ 6] Juniper Networks    

10 (+42) [1] Linaro 10 (***) [ 5] Hao Xu

Development vs reviewing scores
-------------------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 ( +1) [144] Alexei Starovoitov     1 (***) [46] Jiri Olsa           
   2 ( +4) [ 50] Martin KaFai Lau       2 ( +4) [39] Larysa Zaremba      
   3 (+15) [ 40] Stanislav Fomichev     3 (   ) [37] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   4 ( -3) [ 38] Yonghong Song          4 (***) [34] Geliang Tang        
   5 ( +4) [ 37] Jakub Kicinski         5 ( +7) [22] Dave Marchevsky     
   6 ( -1) [ 34] Andrii Nakryiko        6 ( -4) [22] Maciej Fijalkowski  

7 (***) [ 30] Jesper Dangaard Brouer 7 (***) [19] Hao Xu
8 (***) [ 25] John Fastabend 8 (+26) [18] Roberto Sassu
9 (***) [ 24] Hou Tao 9 (***) [16] Valentin Schneider
10 ( -7) [ 23] Daniel Borkmann 10 (***) [16] Tejun Heo

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [142] Meta                   1 ( +1) [49] Intel               
   2 (   ) [ 52] RedHat                 2 (+11) [38] Huawei              
   3 (***) [ 28] Google                 3 ( +5) [28] Bytedance           
   4 ( -1) [ 22] Corigine               4 (***) [22] SUSE                
   5 (***) [ 18] Oracle                 5 (***) [19] Isovalent           
   6 (+37) [  8] Rivos                  6 (***) [19] Hao Xu              
   7 ( -2) [  8] Microsoft              7 ( -3) [13] Alibaba             
   8 (***) [  7] Markus Elfring         8 (***) [12] Aviatrix            
   9 (   ) [  6] Amazon                 9 (***) [12] Juniper Networks    
  10 (***) [  5] Huacai Chen           10 (***) [11] Leon Hwang          
  11 (+28) [  5] Dave Thaler           11 (***) [10] IBM                 

More raw stats
--------------

Prev: start: Thu, 27 Apr 2023 08:55:55 +0200

	end: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 17:27:38 +0200

Prev: messages: 4234 days: 62 (68 msg/day)
Prev: direct commits: 664 (11 commits/day)
Prev: people/aliases: 241 {'author': 89, 'commenter': 103, 'both': 49}
Prev: review pct: 12.95% x-corp pct: 12.05%

Curr: start: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 22:18:25 -0700

	end: Tue, 29 Aug 2023 15:24:18 -0700

Curr: messages: 5240 days: 62 (85 msg/day)
Curr: direct commits: 384 (6 commits/day)
Curr: people/aliases: 279 {'author': 112, 'commenter': 120, 'both': 47}
Curr: review pct: 24.22% x-corp pct: 23.44%

Diff: +23.8% msg/day
Diff: -42.2% commits/day
Diff: +15.8% people/day
Diff: review pct: +11.3%

      x-corp pct: +11.4%
#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Stanislav Fomichev

See the netdev posting for more info and context:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm posting a link to the previous cycle below so people can do the comparison if needed. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc.

Quoted 7 lines

Previous cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

Current cycle:
28 Jun to 29 Aug: 5240 mailing list messages, 62 days, 85 messages per day 384 repo commits (6 commits/day)

That is a big jump in activity.
Every bpf developer needs to internalize what "85 messages per day" really means.
Put yourself in maintainer's shoes.
Patches will be applied only after they're reviewed.
When developers only send patches they slow down themselves and all other developers. Every active developer needs to code review as well.

We all want patches to move swiftly, so please help maintainers and
yourself: review as many patches as you can.
This will speed up the patch queue and every developer will benefit. win/win for both developers and maintainers.

Quoted 16 lines

6.5 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 ( +1) [11] Alexei Starovoitov      1 ( +1) [23] Alexei Starovoitov
   2 ( -1) [ 7] Yonghong Song           2 ( +1) [15] Yonghong Song
   3 ( +5) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau        3 ( +4) [ 9] Stanislav Fomichev
   4 ( +3) [ 4] Stanislav Fomichev      4 ( -3) [ 7] Andrii Nakryiko
   5 ( -1) [ 4] Daniel Borkmann         5 ( +5) [ 7] Martin KaFai Lau
   6 ( +3) [ 3] Jakub Kicinski          6 (+15) [ 5] Hou Tao
   7 ( -2) [ 3] Jiri Olsa               7 ( +7) [ 5] Jakub Kicinski
   8 ( -5) [ 2] Andrii Nakryiko         8 ( -2) [ 4] Daniel Borkmann
   9 (***) [ 2] Hou Tao                 9 (+13) [ 4] Jesper Dangaard Brouer
Quoted 3 lines

10 (+16) [ 2] Jesper Dangaard Brouer 10 (+17) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman
11 ( +7) [ 2] John Fastabend 11 ( -2) [ 4] Steven Rostedt
12 ( +3) [ 2] Eduard Zingerman 12 (***) [ 4] Alan Maguire

BIG thank you to all reviewers.
You're doing an excellent job.

Quoted 50 lines

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 ( +9) [3] Yonghong Song            1 ( +5) [20] Jiri Olsa
   2 (   ) [2] Yafang Shao              2 (+30) [17] Yonghong Song
   3 (***) [2] Geliang Tang             3 ( +8) [10] Larysa Zaremba
   4 ( +5) [1] Daniel Borkmann          4 (   ) [10] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 ( +2) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)    5 (***) [ 8] Geliang Tang
   6 ( -2) [1] Jiri Olsa                6 ( -3) [ 8] Maciej Fijalkowski
   7 (+19) [1] Kui-Feng Lee             7 ( -5) [ 6] Yafang Shao
   8 (+40) [1] Dave Marchevsky          8 (+12) [ 6] Dave Marchevsky
   9 (***) [1] Rong Tao                 9 (+15) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann

10 (***) [1] Daniel Xu 10 (***) [ 5] Hao Xu

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [20] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta
   2 (   ) [ 8] Isovalent               2 (   ) [16] RedHat
   3 (   ) [ 7] Google                  3 ( +1) [15] Google
   4 (   ) [ 6] RedHat                  4 ( -1) [12] Isovalent
   5 (   ) [ 3] Intel                   5 (   ) [ 7] Intel
   6 ( +3) [ 3] Huawei                  6 ( +2) [ 7] Huawei
   7 (+24) [ 2] Oracle                  7 (+41) [ 4] Oracle
   8 ( -2) [ 2] Corigine                8 (+49) [ 3] Rivos
   9 ( -1) [ 1] nVidia                  9 ( -3) [ 3] Corigine

10 (+34) [ 1] Rivos 10 ( -3) [ 2] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [9] Meta                     1 (   ) [40] Meta
   2 ( +3) [6] Huawei                   2 ( +1) [31] Isovalent
   3 ( -1) [4] Isovalent                3 ( +1) [24] Intel
   4 ( -1) [3] Google                   4 ( +2) [19] Huawei
   5 ( +1) [3] Intel                    5 ( -3) [17] Google
   6 ( -2) [2] RedHat                   6 ( +2) [ 9] RedHat
   7 (***) [2] Juniper Networks         7 (***) [ 8] SUSE
   8 (***) [2] SUSE                     8 ( +5) [ 7] Bytedance
   9 ( +8) [1] Oracle                   9 (***) [ 6] Juniper Networks

10 (+42) [1] Linaro 10 (***) [ 5] Hao Xu

Development vs reviewing scores
-------------------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 ( +1) [144] Alexei Starovoitov     1 (***) [46] Jiri Olsa
   2 ( +4) [ 50] Martin KaFai Lau       2 ( +4) [39] Larysa Zaremba
   3 (+15) [ 40] Stanislav Fomichev     3 (   ) [37] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   4 ( -3) [ 38] Yonghong Song          4 (***) [34] Geliang Tang
   5 ( +4) [ 37] Jakub Kicinski         5 ( +7) [22] Dave Marchevsky
   6 ( -1) [ 34] Andrii Nakryiko        6 ( -4) [22] Maciej Fijalkowski
Quoted 4 lines

7 (***) [ 30] Jesper Dangaard Brouer 7 (***) [19] Hao Xu
8 (***) [ 25] John Fastabend 8 (+26) [18] Roberto Sassu
9 (***) [ 24] Hou Tao 9 (***) [16] Valentin Schneider
10 ( -7) [ 23] Daniel Borkmann 10 (***) [16] Tejun Heo

Jiri,
you've managed to be in the top reviewers and top negative :) I guess that means that we need to tweak the positive/negative formula to more accurately represent the value each person brings to the community.

Quoted 37 lines

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [142] Meta                   1 ( +1) [49] Intel
   2 (   ) [ 52] RedHat                 2 (+11) [38] Huawei
   3 (***) [ 28] Google                 3 ( +5) [28] Bytedance
   4 ( -1) [ 22] Corigine               4 (***) [22] SUSE
   5 (***) [ 18] Oracle                 5 (***) [19] Isovalent
   6 (+37) [  8] Rivos                  6 (***) [19] Hao Xu
   7 ( -2) [  8] Microsoft              7 ( -3) [13] Alibaba
   8 (***) [  7] Markus Elfring         8 (***) [12] Aviatrix
   9 (   ) [  6] Amazon                 9 (***) [12] Juniper Networks
  10 (***) [  5] Huacai Chen           10 (***) [11] Leon Hwang
  11 (+28) [  5] Dave Thaler           11 (***) [10] IBM

More raw stats
--------------

Prev: start: Thu, 27 Apr 2023 08:55:55 +0200

        end: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 17:27:38 +0200

Prev: messages: 4234 days: 62 (68 msg/day)
Prev: direct commits: 664 (11 commits/day)
Prev: people/aliases: 241 {'author': 89, 'commenter': 103, 'both': 49}
Prev: review pct: 12.95% x-corp pct: 12.05%

Curr: start: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 22:18:25 -0700

        end: Tue, 29 Aug 2023 15:24:18 -0700

Curr: messages: 5240 days: 62 (85 msg/day)
Curr: direct commits: 384 (6 commits/day)
Curr: people/aliases: 279 {'author': 112, 'commenter': 120, 'both': 47}
Curr: review pct: 24.22% x-corp pct: 23.44%

Diff: +23.8% msg/day
Diff: -42.2% commits/day
Diff: +15.8% people/day
Diff: review pct: +11.3%

      x-corp pct: +11.4%
#2 lore raw

On Wed, Aug 30, 2023 at 02:24:19PM -0700, Alexei Starovoitov wrote:

SNIP

Quoted 42 lines
Quoted 37 lines

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [20] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta
   2 (   ) [ 8] Isovalent               2 (   ) [16] RedHat
   3 (   ) [ 7] Google                  3 ( +1) [15] Google
   4 (   ) [ 6] RedHat                  4 ( -1) [12] Isovalent
   5 (   ) [ 3] Intel                   5 (   ) [ 7] Intel
   6 ( +3) [ 3] Huawei                  6 ( +2) [ 7] Huawei
   7 (+24) [ 2] Oracle                  7 (+41) [ 4] Oracle
   8 ( -2) [ 2] Corigine                8 (+49) [ 3] Rivos
   9 ( -1) [ 1] nVidia                  9 ( -3) [ 3] Corigine

10 (+34) [ 1] Rivos 10 ( -3) [ 2] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [9] Meta                     1 (   ) [40] Meta
   2 ( +3) [6] Huawei                   2 ( +1) [31] Isovalent
   3 ( -1) [4] Isovalent                3 ( +1) [24] Intel
   4 ( -1) [3] Google                   4 ( +2) [19] Huawei
   5 ( +1) [3] Intel                    5 ( -3) [17] Google
   6 ( -2) [2] RedHat                   6 ( +2) [ 9] RedHat
   7 (***) [2] Juniper Networks         7 (***) [ 8] SUSE
   8 (***) [2] SUSE                     8 ( +5) [ 7] Bytedance
   9 ( +8) [1] Oracle                   9 (***) [ 6] Juniper Networks

10 (+42) [1] Linaro 10 (***) [ 5] Hao Xu

Development vs reviewing scores
-------------------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 ( +1) [144] Alexei Starovoitov     1 (***) [46] Jiri Olsa
   2 ( +4) [ 50] Martin KaFai Lau       2 ( +4) [39] Larysa Zaremba
   3 (+15) [ 40] Stanislav Fomichev     3 (   ) [37] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   4 ( -3) [ 38] Yonghong Song          4 (***) [34] Geliang Tang
   5 ( +4) [ 37] Jakub Kicinski         5 ( +7) [22] Dave Marchevsky
   6 ( -1) [ 34] Andrii Nakryiko        6 ( -4) [22] Maciej Fijalkowski
Quoted 4 lines

7 (***) [ 30] Jesper Dangaard Brouer 7 (***) [19] Hao Xu
8 (***) [ 25] John Fastabend 8 (+26) [18] Roberto Sassu
9 (***) [ 24] Hou Tao 9 (***) [16] Valentin Schneider
10 ( -7) [ 23] Daniel Borkmann 10 (***) [16] Tejun Heo

Quoted 5 lines

Jiri,
you've managed to be in the top reviewers and top negative :) I guess that means that we need to tweak the positive/negative formula to more accurately represent the value each person brings to the community.

heh nice, win-win ;-)

jirka

Quoted 39 lines
Quoted 38 lines

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [142] Meta                   1 ( +1) [49] Intel
   2 (   ) [ 52] RedHat                 2 (+11) [38] Huawei
   3 (***) [ 28] Google                 3 ( +5) [28] Bytedance
   4 ( -1) [ 22] Corigine               4 (***) [22] SUSE
   5 (***) [ 18] Oracle                 5 (***) [19] Isovalent
   6 (+37) [  8] Rivos                  6 (***) [19] Hao Xu
   7 ( -2) [  8] Microsoft              7 ( -3) [13] Alibaba
   8 (***) [  7] Markus Elfring         8 (***) [12] Aviatrix
   9 (   ) [  6] Amazon                 9 (***) [12] Juniper Networks
  10 (***) [  5] Huacai Chen           10 (***) [11] Leon Hwang
  11 (+28) [  5] Dave Thaler           11 (***) [10] IBM

More raw stats
--------------

Prev: start: Thu, 27 Apr 2023 08:55:55 +0200

        end: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 17:27:38 +0200

Prev: messages: 4234 days: 62 (68 msg/day)
Prev: direct commits: 664 (11 commits/day)
Prev: people/aliases: 241 {'author': 89, 'commenter': 103, 'both': 49}
Prev: review pct: 12.95% x-corp pct: 12.05%

Curr: start: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 22:18:25 -0700

        end: Tue, 29 Aug 2023 15:24:18 -0700

Curr: messages: 5240 days: 62 (85 msg/day)
Curr: direct commits: 384 (6 commits/day)
Curr: people/aliases: 279 {'author': 112, 'commenter': 120, 'both': 47}
Curr: review pct: 24.22% x-corp pct: 23.44%

Diff: +23.8% msg/day
Diff: -42.2% commits/day
Diff: +15.8% people/day
Diff: review pct: +11.3%

      x-corp pct: +11.4%