Centrino: undervolting and further reducing heat
Hi,
I have a dothan 1.6 GHz processor, and i've been investigating how to reduce heat to minimize fan usage. One very promising avenue is undervolting. According to several online articles, there is a large potential for undervolting. I ended up modifying speedstep-centrino.c to test it out. Results are very positive: it can run under heavy load at 1.6Ghz with only 972mV (down from 1340mV). This decreased temperature by 10°C! At 600MHz, the minimum 700mV was sufficient.
I understand that the driver needs to be conservative by default, but given the huge benefits, it would make a lot of sense to offer a way to specify lower voltages to those who want to. Has anybody investigated this possibility, or already started working on it? What would be a good interface to specify the voltages?
Independently of this feature, I wonder how it's possible to further reduce consumption when the system is mostly ideal, and even 600MHz is more than needed. The idea being to let the system cool down even more in that case. Is there any existing way to achive this on linux? One possibility I found in the intel docs is the IA32_THERM_CONTROL MSR, which can reduce clock speed by 12.5% to 87.5%. Am I right in thinking that it could be combined with speedstep to achieve even lower power consumption states? Are there other possibilities?
Cheers,
Daniel
I use undervolted AMD64 on two gentoo boxes for months:
1. socket 754 nforce3-250gb, athlon64 3000+ (Newcastle core) overclocked to 2.4GHz and undervolted to run @1.45V
2. socket 939 nforce4 ultra, athlon64 3000+ (Winchester core) undervolted to run @1V at 1GHz and @1.275V at 1.8GHz (stable voltages suficient to run prime95 for hours were 0.9V at 1GHz and 1.175V at 1.8GHz but I like to be 110% safe so I've left extra 0.1V just in case)
Ofcorse, I had to manualy modify powernow-k8.c
;)
Quoted 37 lines · Daniel Bonniot
Hi,
I have a dothan 1.6 GHz processor, and i've been investigating how to reduce heat to minimize fan usage. One very promising avenue is undervolting. According to several online articles, there is a large potential for undervolting. I ended up modifying
speedstep-centrino.cto test it out. Results are very positive: it can run under heavy load at 1.6Ghz with only 972mV (down from 1340mV). This decreased temperature by 10���C! At 600MHz, the minimum 700mV was sufficient.I understand that the driver needs to be conservative by default, but given the huge benefits, it would make a lot of sense to offer a way to specify lower voltages to those who want to. Has anybody investigated this possibility, or already started working on it? What would be a good interface to specify the voltages?
Independently of this feature, I wonder how it's possible to further reduce consumption when the system is mostly ideal, and even 600MHz is more than needed. The idea being to let the system cool down even more in that case. Is there any existing way to achive this on linux? One possibility I found in the intel docs is the
IA32_THERM_CONTROLMSR, which can reduce clock speed by 12.5% to 87.5%. Am I right in thinking that it could be combined with speedstep to achieve even lower power consumption states? Are there other possibilities?Cheers,
Daniel
_______________________________________________
Cpufreq mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.linux.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/cpufreq
Hi
I've got a banias 1.6 GHz processor and like Daniel I've reduced the voltages. My multiplicators and voltages:
6x @ 0.780V (default: 0.988V)
10x @ 0.956V
12x @ 1.004V
14x @ 1.116V
16x @ 1.244V (default: 1.484V)
So far I've found nobody who needs higher settings on a banias cpu (I'm admin on a german notebook forum and have seen many values).
Dothan cpus need less power, in my experience (very) safe values are:
6x @ 0.732V
10x @ 0.860V
12x @ 0.988V
14x @ 1.052V
16x @ 1.212V
17x (?)
18x (?)
As you can see with Daniels cpu (6x @ 0.700V, 16x @ 0.972) these voltages should be no problem for anyone, so I suppose it would be safe to set the default values to these.
I think my banias values should be increased by one step (0.016V) to be sure.
Idea:
Is it possible to set a kernel option like "reduce cpu voltage", maybe even an "aggressive" option? We could leave the original tables for default and activate the lower voltages only if this option is set. A kernel boot parameter could override this option for one session, so people could test it easily.
Regards
Aaron
Quoted 67 lines · Nebojsa Trpkovic
I use undervolted AMD64 on two gentoo boxes for months:
1. socket 754 nforce3-250gb, athlon64 3000+ (Newcastle core) overclocked to 2.4GHz and undervolted to run @1.45V
2. socket 939 nforce4 ultra, athlon64 3000+ (Winchester core) undervolted to run @1V at 1GHz and @1.275V at 1.8GHz (stable voltages suficient to run prime95 for hours were 0.9V at 1GHz and 1.175V at 1.8GHz but I like to be 110% safe so I've left extra 0.1V just in case)
Ofcorse, I had to manualy modify
powernow-k8.c;)
Quoted 28 lines · Daniel Bonniot
Hi,
I have a dothan 1.6 GHz processor, and i've been investigating how to reduce heat to minimize fan usage. One very promising avenue is undervolting. According to several online articles, there is a large potential for undervolting. I ended up modifying
speedstep-centrino.cto test it out. Results are very positive: it can run under heavy load at 1.6Ghz with only 972mV (down from 1340mV). This decreased temperature by 10�C! At 600MHz, the minimum 700mV was sufficient.I understand that the driver needs to be conservative by default, but given the huge benefits, it would make a lot of sense to offer a way to specify lower voltages to those who want to. Has anybody investigated this possibility, or already started working on it? What would be a good interface to specify the voltages?
Independently of this feature, I wonder how it's possible to further reduce consumption when the system is mostly ideal, and even 600MHz is more than needed. The idea being to let the system cool down even more in that case. Is there any existing way to achive this on linux? One possibility I found in the intel docs is the
IA32_THERM_CONTROLMSR, which can reduce clock speed by 12.5% to 87.5%. Am I right in thinking that it could be combined with speedstep to achieve even lower power consumption states? Are there other possibilities?Cheers,
Quoted 10 lines
Daniel
_______________________________________________
Cpufreq mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.linux.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/cpufreq_______________________________________________
Cpufreq mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.linux.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/cpufreq
Quoted 1 line · Daniel Bonniot
Independently of this feature, I wonder how it's possible to further reduce consumption when the system is mostly ideal, and even 600MHz is more than needed. The idea being to let the system cool down even more in that case. Is there any existing way to achive this on linux? One possibility I found in the intel docs is the
IA32_THERM_CONTROLMSR, which can reduce clock speed by 12.5% to 87.5%. Am I right in thinking that it could be combined with speedstep to achieve even lower power consumption states? Are there other possibilities?
Throttling isn't going to help if the system is already mostly halted. You're already doing as much as can be done. (Unless there is an undocumented setting even lower than 600MHz...)
Wes Felter - [email protected]
Quoted 2 lines
Throttling isn't going to help if the system is already mostly halted.
Yes, I tried and it makes very little difference indeed, if any.
Quoted 1 line
You're already doing as much as can be done. (Unless there is an undocumented setting even lower than 600MHz...)
I wonder if there is a way to reduce the speed of other components of the system (the memory is quite hot, for instance). I'm pretty sure the graphic card (ATI) can be underclocked too.
Daniel
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Bonniot
I wonder if there is a way to reduce the speed of other components of the system (the memory is quite hot, for instance). I'm pretty sure the graphic card (ATI) can be underclocked too.
IIRC recent xorg do have some power saving options for radeon. I don't remember if its in CVS or if patches have been committed though, or if this work only for mobile versions.
Signature · 4 lines
Bruno Ducrot -- Which is worse: ignorance or apathy? -- Don't know. Don't care.
Quoted 4 lines
IIRC recent xorg do have some power saving options for radeon. I don't remember if its in CVS or if patches have been committed though, or if this work only for mobile versions.
Yes, I'm using Xorg 6.8.2 (-10 from Ubuntu), and the xorg driver does have power saving options, although they are not on by default (it's the DynamicClocks option). The proprietary drivers enable it by default. My preliminary experiments seem to show that you can save further by underclocking the radeon card (a Mobility in my case).
Daniel