Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Reworking the default SAE group

DISCUSSION James Prestwood 1 participant 1 message Sep 5, 2023

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

All,

The current WPA3/SAE logic (really inside ELL) returns a descending list of SAE groups which IWD tries. Currently just groups 20 and 19. This ordering was initially chosen because higher order groups have larger keys are are more secure. I can't come close to speaking to all AP manufacturers but I haven't come across a single one that supports group 20. Even the default openWRT build only supported group 19. In addition some APs are even out of spec and don't handle the group negotiation correctly, requiring IWD to special case those OUIs.

So at this point it feels (to me) like using group 20 first just a performance hit, and should maybe be on an opt-in basis or we should explore other options. We could add an option to use a certain group which could even be set automatically per-network if the AP rejected with status 77 and a subsequent authentication using group 19 succeeded. From that point on the known working group would be used and avoid repeated retries.

I'd like to get anyone else's thoughts/experiences on this. Maybe I'm wrong about group 20 being widely unsupported? If you use WPA3 check your dmesg logs for status 77 errors :)

Thanks,
James