Skip to contentSkip to conversation

newbie question about git push

DISCUSSION Eric Bowman 3 participants 3 messages Jun 15, 2016

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

Apologies in advance if this has been covered before ... I've been wading through the archives a bit and couldn't find anything that seemed to address this basic question.

I have a bunch of machines I use for development, but only one of them is allowed to connect via vpn to where the subversion repository lives, so I'm using git-svn to make things a little easier.

I've got one machine, itchy, where I've done a git svn clone operation. I do a fair amount of development work there, and typically I just work on the master branch, and periodically commit back to svn using git svn dcommit.

I've cloned the repository on itchy on a few other machines I occasionally use, and I'm able to push new revisions from itchy with no surprises, and I can pull revisions back to itchy ok with no surprises.

Where things get a weird is when I push a revision back to itchy from one of my other clones. I feel like I must be missing some fundamental concept, and I'm wondering if someone can help.

Suppose I make a change on another machine commit that change, then push it back to itchy:

git commit -as
git push origin master

This works ok, and I can then git svn dcommit that change back to the svn. But I have a hard time getting that change to show up in the sandbox I have on itchy.

When I go back to itchy after pushing from a satellite, git thinks that the old revision of the file I modified on another machine, has been modified locally; it doesn't see that the local copy is out of data and this new revision needs to be merged. But I can't figure out how to get git to do that; the only things that seem to work are fairly drastic measures, like "git reset --hard" or by stashing and then deleting the stash. Either seems terribly error prone.

I'm starting to think that I should clone the repo I cloned from svn for doing development work on itchy, but this seems kind of wasteful. Am I missing some fundamental concept?

Many thanks for any thoughts.

cheers,
Eric

#1 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Eric Bowman

Where things get a weird is when I push a revision back to itchy from one of my other clones. I feel like I must be missing some fundamental concept, and I'm wondering if someone can help.

This is a FAQ.
http://git.or.cz/gitwiki/GitFaq#head-b96f48bc9c925074be9f95c0fce69bcece5f6e73

Quoted 3 lines

I'm starting to think that I should clone the repo I cloned from svn for doing development work on itchy, but this seems kind of wasteful. Am I missing some fundamental concept?

I always clone my svn mirrors for doing development work.

It's not particularly wasteful, especially if you set up the svn mirror as an alternate for your working repo. ("git clone -s", but make sure you read "git help clone" so that you know why you can't delete anything from the svn mirror)

Peter Harris

#2 lore raw
In reply to Eric Bowman

Eric Bowman venit, vidit, dixit 27.08.2008 17:37:

Quoted 41 lines

Hi,

Apologies in advance if this has been covered before ... I've been wading through the archives a bit and couldn't find anything that seemed to address this basic question.

I have a bunch of machines I use for development, but only one of them is allowed to connect via vpn to where the subversion repository lives, so I'm using git-svn to make things a little easier.

I've got one machine, itchy, where I've done a git svn clone operation. I do a fair amount of development work there, and typically I just work on the master branch, and periodically commit back to svn using git svn dcommit.

I've cloned the repository on itchy on a few other machines I occasionally use, and I'm able to push new revisions from itchy with no surprises, and I can pull revisions back to itchy ok with no surprises.

Where things get a weird is when I push a revision back to itchy from one of my other clones. I feel like I must be missing some fundamental concept, and I'm wondering if someone can help.

Suppose I make a change on another machine commit that change, then push it back to itchy:

git commit -as
git push origin master

This works ok, and I can then git svn dcommit that change back to the svn. But I have a hard time getting that change to show up in the sandbox I have on itchy.

When I go back to itchy after pushing from a satellite, git thinks that the old revision of the file I modified on another machine, has been modified locally; it doesn't see that the local copy is out of data and this new revision needs to be merged. But I can't figure out how to get git to do that; the only things that seem to work are fairly drastic measures, like "git reset --hard" or by stashing and then deleting the stash. Either seems terribly error prone.

Quoted 8 lines

I'm starting to think that I should clone the repo I cloned from svn for doing development work on itchy, but this seems kind of wasteful. Am I missing some fundamental concept?

Many thanks for any thoughts.

cheers,
Eric

I don't think I understand your situation completely. But could it be that when you push from satellite to itchy you push into a branch which is checked out? Most probably, because you seem to push master to master. You can't merge on push because there may be conflicts.

That setup is generally not a good idea, for the reasons you've experienced. You may want to pull from itchy instead.

Michael