try_module_get code understanding
Dear List,
I agree that this issue certainly doesn't require to be in this list (rightful place being kernewbies) but I tried that and got no response - so trying my luck here.
I was going through try_module_get function in include/linux/module.h file (2.6.22 stock kernel) - which is like:
-----
static inline int try_module_get(struct module *module){
int ret = 1; <--- error case when !module
if (module) {
unsigned int cpu = get_cpu();
if (likely(module_is_live(module)))
local_inc(&module->ref[cpu].count);
else
ret = 0; <--- error case
put_cpu(); }
return ret; <----
}
----
What I understand about the code flow is:
-- module live would return the flag stating that this module can be reference and is NOT being removed currently.
1. In case the module pointer passed is invalid (NULL) this function would return 1 (error case)
2. In case the module pointer is OK, and module is currently not being removed, reference count would be incremented and 1 returned (non error case)
3. In case the module pointer is OK, and module reference count can NOT be increased, 0 would be returned (error case).
As you can observe from above points, 0 and 1 are returned for error cases. I am a little confused and wondering if there is something which I am missing in this code??.
Can anyone help me out with this? Any help would be highly appreciated.
Regards
Shreyansh
Quoted 29 lines
I was going through
try_module_getfunction ininclude/linux/module.hfile (2.6.22 stock kernel) - which is like:-----
static inline inttry_module_get(struct module *module){
int ret = 1; <--- error case when !moduleif (module) { unsigned int cpu = get_cpu(); if (likely(module_is_live(module))) local_inc(&module->ref[cpu].count); else ret = 0; <--- error case put_cpu();}
return ret; <----
}
----What I understand about the code flow is:
-- module live would return the flag stating that this module can be reference and is NOT being removed currently.1. In case the module pointer passed is invalid (NULL) this function would return 1 (error case)
2. In case the module pointer is OK, and module is currently not being removed, reference count would be incremented and 1 returned (non error case)
3. In case the module pointer is OK, and module reference count can NOT be increased, 0 would be returned (error case).
Quoted 5 lines
As you can observe from above points, 0 and 1 are returned for error cases. I am a little confused and wondering if there is something which I am missing in this code??.
Can anyone help me out with this? Any help would be highly appreciated.
Somewhere in module.h you have:
#ifdef MODULE
#define THIS_MODULE (&__this_module)
#else /* !MODULE */
#define THIS_MODULE ((struct module *)0)
#endif
So this just means, that THIS_MODULE is NULL for compiled in modules and therefore try_module_get(NULL) succeeds. It's not an error case.
Thanks for you reply, please see inline.
Quoted 1 line · Heiko Carstens <heiko.carstens <at> de.ibm.com> writes:
[snip]
Quoted 13 lines
Quoted 13 lines
static inline int
try_module_get(struct module *module){
int ret = 1; <--- error case when !moduleif (module) { unsigned int cpu = get_cpu(); if (likely(module_is_live(module))) local_inc(&module->ref[cpu].count); else ret = 0; <--- error case put_cpu();}
return ret; <----
}
----
[snip]
Quoted 10 lines
Somewhere in
module.hyou have:#ifdef MODULE
#defineTHIS_MODULE(&__this_module)
#else /* !MODULE */
#defineTHIS_MODULE((struct module *)0)
#endifSo this just means, that
THIS_MODULEis NULL for compiled in modules and thereforetry_module_get(NULL)succeeds. It's not an error case.
Agreed.
Then what is return value if my module tries to 'get' a module which does not exist (and is a module, not in-built)? . Is it '1' ?
Or am I imagining a hypothetical scenario which would not exist?
Thanks again for your fast response.
Shreyansh
Quoted 3 lines
Then what is return value if my module tries to 'get' a module which does not exist (and is a module, not in-built)? . Is it '1' ?
Or am I imagining a hypothetical scenario which would not exist?
That is not supposed to happen. After a module got unloaded there shouldn't be any objects around anymore that have an .owner member with an address that points to the now non-existent module.
Quoted 21 lines · Shreyansh Jain
-----
static inline inttry_module_get(struct module *module){
int ret = 1; <--- error case when !moduleif (module) { unsigned int cpu = get_cpu(); if (likely(module_is_live(module))) local_inc(&module->ref[cpu].count); else ret = 0; <--- error case put_cpu();}
return ret; <----
}1. In case the module pointer passed is invalid (NULL) this function would return 1 (error case)
2. In case the module pointer is OK, and module is currently not being removed, reference count would be incremented and 1 returned (non error case)
3. In case the module pointer is OK, and module reference count can NOT be increased, 0 would be returned (error case).
Quoted 3 lines
As you can observe from above points, 0 and 1 are returned for error cases. I am a little confused and wondering if there is something which I am missing in this code??.
Go look at the call sites for this function - I bet that most of them, if they check the return code at all, only check for zero or nonzero, because they only *care* about the case that returns zero. Since they already know they're not passing a NULL pointer, they don't worry about that case returning a 1. So there's only two realistic returns - either the module is live or it isn't.