Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Q: Pushing code to 2.4.x

DISCUSSION Eric W. Biederman 2 participants 4 messages Jan 29, 2003 – Jan 31, 2003 Memory technology devices (MTD)

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

What is the plan for keeping the kernel and the CVS tree more or less in sync?

There are currently some large divergences, to the point there are some chips that I can use the cfi_cmdset_0002.c from the stable 2.4.x kernel mtd tree but not from the recent CVS tree.

In addition on the boards I support LinuxBIOS on I ensure there are kernel mtd drivers that allow people to flash their BIOS rom. And my customers would like to see those drivers in the stock kernel.

For the short term I can release and maintain patch where everything works, the question is what should my long term strategy be.

A) Push to the MTD cvs repository and let David Woodhouse push to Marcelo.
B) Push to the MTD cvs repository and push directly to Marcelo.
C) Some more involved coordination of the MTD drivers.

With LinuxBIOS becoming a fully supported product I expect to continually have more board and more little rom chips that I am making certain work.

Eric

#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Eric W. Biederman

What is the plan for keeping the kernel and the CVS tree more or less in sync?

It goes in cycles...
1. I sync to Marcelo/Linus
2. People commit changes.
3. Those changes stabilise and I become happy with them.
4. I plan to find time to sync to Marcelo/Linus again.
5. People bitch at me because it's out of sync.
6. I say "I'll find some time soon, honest".
7. Red Hat finds me more 'real work' to do just when I thought I'd got some slack some in the Engineering Schedule.
8. People bitch at me some more.
9. I eventually get round to it.

Quoted 3 lines

There are currently some large divergences, to the point there are some chips that I can use the cfi_cmdset_0002.c from the stable 2.4.x kernel mtd tree but not from the recent CVS tree.

That's a bit of a bugger -- because I sent the CVS code to Marcelo this week :) Care to enlighten us on the problems you've seen?

Quoted 4 lines

For the short term I can release and maintain patch where everything works, the question is what should my long term strategy be.

A) Push to the MTD cvs repository and let David Woodhouse push to Marcelo.

As you've observed, there's a lag involved with this. If you're willing to help reduce that I'm happy.

Quoted 1 line

B) Push to the MTD cvs repository and push directly to Marcelo.

This is fine by me assuming the following:

1. You commit to CVS first and then send to Marcelo, including the appropriate $Id$ changes so I know which version Marcelo was last sync'd with.
2. You Cc me.
3. Your changes are correct for both 2.4 and 2.5. I don't care if they're tested, as long as they're correct :)
4. You merge changes from Marcelo's tree into CVS too, before sending it back to him.

Quoted 2 lines

With LinuxBIOS becoming a fully supported product I expect to continually have more board and more little rom chips that I am making certain work.

For new map drivers, and new IDs for the chip drivers, please do commit to CVS and send to Marcelo simultaneously. I'm perfectly happy with that.

Signature · 1 line
dwmw2
#2 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · David Woodhouse
Quoted 2 lines · Eric W. Biederman

What is the plan for keeping the kernel and the CVS tree more or less in sync?

Quoted 11 lines

It goes in cycles...
1. I sync to Marcelo/Linus
2. People commit changes.
3. Those changes stabilise and I become happy with them.
4. I plan to find time to sync to Marcelo/Linus again.
5. People bitch at me because it's out of sync.
6. I say "I'll find some time soon, honest".
7. Red Hat finds me more 'real work' to do just when I thought I'd got some slack some in the Engineering Schedule.
8. People bitch at me some more.
9. I eventually get round to it.

That sounds about right. Things similar things tend to happen here but as the mtd stuff becomes more real work, and the volume goes up it is easier to find the time...

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

There are currently some large divergences, to the point there are some chips that I can use the cfi_cmdset_0002.c from the stable 2.4.x kernel mtd tree but not from the recent CVS tree.

That's a bit of a bugger -- because I sent the CVS code to Marcelo this week :) Care to enlighten us on the problems you've seen?

Primarily these are the chips from SST. In particular the Roms used on the old tyan s2466 motherboards. Currently we are working on a port to PMC flash chips, which is what that board is using now. I didn't look closely at the time, but we should be able to retest and figure out what is going on.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

For the short term I can release and maintain patch where everything works, the question is what should my long term strategy be.

A) Push to the MTD cvs repository and let David Woodhouse push to Marcelo.

As you've observed, there's a lag involved with this. If you're willing to help reduce that I'm happy.

I am certainly willing to look at that.

Quoted 13 lines
Quoted 1 line

B) Push to the MTD cvs repository and push directly to Marcelo.

This is fine by me assuming the following:

1. You commit to CVS first and then send to Marcelo, including the appropriate $Id$ changes so I know which version Marcelo was last sync'd with.
2. You Cc me.
3. Your changes are correct for both 2.4 and 2.5. I don't care if they're tested, as long as they're correct :)
4. You merge changes from Marcelo's tree into CVS too, before sending it back to him.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

With LinuxBIOS becoming a fully supported product I expect to continually have more board and more little rom chips that I am making certain work.

For new map drivers, and new IDs for the chip drivers, please do commit to CVS and send to Marcelo simultaneously. I'm perfectly happy with that.

O.k. Then I will do that. It sounds like a reasonable procedure. It might be someone else doing the legwork but it that will definitely be the plan.

Eric

#3 lore raw
In reply to Eric W. Biederman
Quoted 2 lines · Eric W. Biederman

What is the plan for keeping the kernel and the CVS tree more or less in sync?

It goes in cycles...
1. I sync to Marcelo/Linus
2. People commit changes.
3. Those changes stabilise and I become happy with them.
4. I plan to find time to sync to Marcelo/Linus again.
5. People bitch at me because it's out of sync.
6. I say "I'll find some time soon, honest".
7. Red Hat finds me more 'real work' to do just when I thought I'd got some slack some in the Engineering Schedule.
8. People bitch at me some more.
9. I eventually get round to it.

Quoted 3 lines

There are currently some large divergences, to the point there are some chips that I can use the cfi_cmdset_0002.c from the stable 2.4.x kernel mtd tree but not from the recent CVS tree.

That's a bit of a bugger -- because I sent the CVS code to Marcelo this week :) Care to enlighten us on the problems you've seen?

Quoted 4 lines

For the short term I can release and maintain patch where everything works, the question is what should my long term strategy be.

A) Push to the MTD cvs repository and let David Woodhouse push to Marcelo.

As you've observed, there's a lag involved with this. If you're willing to help reduce that I'm happy.

Quoted 1 line

B) Push to the MTD cvs repository and push directly to Marcelo.

This is fine by me assuming the following:

1. You commit to CVS first and then send to Marcelo, including the appropriate $Id$ changes so I know which version Marcelo was last sync'd with.
2. You Cc me.
3. Your changes are correct for both 2.4 and 2.5. I don't care if they're tested, as long as they're correct :)
4. You merge changes from Marcelo's tree into CVS too, before sending it back to him.

Quoted 2 lines

With LinuxBIOS becoming a fully supported product I expect to continually have more board and more little rom chips that I am making certain work.

For new map drivers, and new IDs for the chip drivers, please do commit to CVS and send to Marcelo simultaneously. I'm perfectly happy with that.

Signature · 7 lines
dwmw2



______________________________________________________
Linux MTD discussion mailing list
http://lists.infradead.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-mtd/