Skip to contentSkip to conversation

avoiding dsmark; help with nested classifiers

LARTC Martin A. Brown 1 participant 1 message Mar 11, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello all,

Pardon the long mail, I'll accept flames if I have irritated anybody. Here are three snippets of different ways to approach a tcng configuration. Unfortunately, I must not quite understand tcng syntax....

I could work around it, build a new kernel and so forth, but I'm curious about this behaviour of tcng. It almost strikes me as "by-design" or a feature of the language--I'd just like to understand why this is happening, and if there is a way I can solve my conundrum!

Intended goal:

- support nested HTB classes; top level class to limit total bandwidth,
- add internal classes to limit (and isolate) certain types of traffic.
- use tcng; much more readable (Thank goodness!)

Working example (simpler than reality...lab/test sort of thing) has all filters attached to 1:0, and traffic is divided up roughly like this (see example):

- class 1:1 HTB ( rate = ceil = 1544k )
- class 1:2 ( rate = 128k, ceil = 512k ), interactive traffic
- class 1:3 ( rate = 512k, ceil = 1544k ), bulk (mail/web/scp)
- class 1:4 ( rate = 128k, ceil = 768k ), default

If I use the tcng class selection path construct (see Example #1), I'll need support for dsmark in my kernel, and being a lazy admin, I'd rather work around this requirement.... This was not unexpected, since Werner clearly outlined the requirement of dsmark support on this very list (if not elsewhere):

http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2002q3/004504.html

If I put my classifiers in the internal classes (1:2, 1:3, 1:4) (see Example #2), then the filters are attached to parent 1:1, which means that they never get called. This is intuitive given the syntax and structure of the tcng language.

My clever workaround failed miserably, however, when I tried to select all IP packets with TCP segments in class 1:1 the class closest to the root (see Example #3). I'm not sure what to make of this.

My questions:

- How can I nest classes with filters without using dsmark?
- Am I overlooking a very simple solution?
- What section of the manual should I re-read?
- Anybody have an example of nested HTB classes or CBQ classes without dsmark or class selection path?

Thanks in advance,

-Martin

# -- Example #1 class selection path; requires dsmark kernel support #
#include "fields.tc"
#include "ports.tc"
#

dev eth0 {
    egress {
        class ( <$ssh> )  if tcp_sport = 22 || ip_tos_delay = 1 ;
        class ( <$bulk> ) if tcp_sport = 22 || tcp_dport = 80 ;
        class ( <$other> ) if 1 ;
        htb () {
            class ( rate 1544kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) {
                $ssh   = class ( rate 128kbps, ceil  512kbps ) ;
                $bulk  = class ( rate 512kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) ;
                $other = class ( rate 128kbps, ceil  768kbps ) ;
            }
        }
    }
}

#
# -- most output suppressed...; word wrapped/shell escaped for
# readability
#

$ tcc lartc-example-1.tcc  | grep filter | head -4
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 2:0 protocol all \
  prio 1 tcindex mask 0x3 shift 0
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 2:0 protocol all \
  prio 1 handle 3 tcindex classid 2:4
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 2:0 protocol all \
  prio 1 handle 2 tcindex classid 2:3
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 2:0 protocol all \
  prio 1 handle 1 tcindex classid 2:2
# <-- more lines of "tc filter" would have been here -->

# -- Example #2; all tc filter commands attach to parent 1:1 #
#include "fields.tc"
#include "ports.tc"
#
dev eth0 {

  htb {
    class ( rate 1544kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) {
      class ( rate 128kbps, ceil 512kbps ) \
        if tcp_dport = 22 && ip_tos_delay = 1 { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
      class ( rate 512kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) \
        if tcp_dport = 25 || tcp_dport = 80 { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
      class ( rate 128kbps, ceil 768kbps ) { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
    }

}
}
#
# -- word wrapped/shell escaped for readability
#

$ tcc lartc-example-2.tcc | grep filter  | head -4
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:1 protocol all prio 1   \
  handle 1:0:0 u32 divisor 1
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:1 protocol all prio 1   \
  u32 match u8 0x6 0xff at 9 offset at 0 mask 0f00      \
  shift 6 eat link 1:0:0
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:1 protocol all prio 1   \
  handle 1:0:1 u32 ht 1:0:0 match u16 0x16 0xffff at 2  \
  match u8 0x10 0x10 at 1 classid 1:2
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:1 protocol all prio 1   \
  handle 2:0:0 u32 divisor 1

# -- Example #3; differs from #2 in line 3, "if ip_proto = IPPROTO_TCP"
# only one tc filter command appears in output--filter command for
# selecting IP packets with TCP segments
#
#include "fields.tc"
#include "ports.tc"
#
dev eth0 {

  htb {
    class ( rate 1544kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) if ip_proto = IPPROTO_TCP {
      class ( rate 128kbps, ceil 512kbps ) \
        if tcp_dport = 22 && ip_tos_delay = 1 { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
      class ( rate 512kbps, ceil 1544kbps ) \
        if tcp_dport = 25 || tcp_dport = 80 { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
      class ( rate 128kbps, ceil 768kbps ) { sfq ( perturb 10s ); }
    }

}
}
#
# -- word wrapped/shell escaped for readability
#

$ tcc lartc-example-3.tcc | grep filter
tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:0 protocol all prio 1 \
  u32 match u8 0x6 0xff at 9 classid 1:1
Signature · 5 lines
Martin A. Brown --- SecurePipe, Inc. --- [email protected]

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/