Skip to contentSkip to conversation

About HTB , bandwidth limiting for ftp port...

LARTC Dhirendra Pal Singh 4 participants 7 messages Mar 13, 2003 – Mar 15, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi All,
I have a quesiton on bandwidth limiting done by HTB to be specific.

Okay now I put on a rule for FTP port 21 for 100Kbps. Now when I am retriving data from ftp server I think the port is different when doing passive ftp transfer. If I am not wrong then a new dynamic port is sent by the ftp server to the client.. and then client initiates a new connection on that port and then the real ftp data transfer happens.

My Question is : Now when limiting the bandwidht will htb limit that data transfer(i.e. the real file transfer) also under 100Kbps or will that data transfer be not at all affected by the rule..?

Just a novice question.. but please guide me...

Thanks in Advance..
Dp

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/

#1 lore raw

Hi there Dhirendra,

: Okay now I put on a rule for FTP port 21 for 100Kbps. Now when I am : retriving data from ftp server I think the port is different when doing : passive ftp transfer. If I am not wrong then a new dynamic port is sent : by the ftp server to the client.. and then client initiates a new : connection on that port and then the real ftp data transfer happens.

Yes. I think FTP should be summarily executed. It has been plaguing us since the beginnings of firewalls and NAT. Sadly, another spiritually impoverished but well-known operating system has two basic options for file transfer: HTTP ("the Internet", of course!), and FTP (for experts!). Of course, on the other side of the divide, people (ab)use ssh for all sorts of nefarious purposes....... (anybody remember a recent article in some print periodical detailing NFS over ssh?)

There has been discussion on the question of FTP (port/passive) and shaping on this list in the past. Here are some links.

See the following threads:

http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2001q3/001473.html
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2002q1/002388.html
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2003q1/007498.html

See also Eric Leblond's description of usage:

http://home.regit.org/connmark.html

: My Question is : Now when limiting the bandwidht will htb limit that : data transfer(i.e. the real file transfer) also under 100Kbps or will : that data transfer be not at all affected by the rule..?

That depends entirely on how you use the tools above. Take a look at Eric Lelond's description, and let us know if you are successful.

: Just a novice question.. but please guide me...

This question is in exactly the right forum, and I'm quite sure I wouldn't call it a novice question....though it might well belong in that rumoured FAQ.

Good luck,

-Martin

Signature · 5 lines
Martin A. Brown --- SecurePipe, Inc. --- [email protected]

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/
#2 lore raw
In reply to Dhirendra Pal Singh

** Reply to message from "Martin A. Brown" <[email protected]> on Thu, 13 Mar 2003 20:37:33 -0600 (CST)

Quoted 8 lines

Hi there Dhirendra,

: Okay now I put on a rule for FTP port 21 for 100Kbps. Now when I am : retriving data from ftp server I think the port is different when doing : passive ftp transfer. If I am not wrong then a new dynamic port is sent : by the ftp server to the client.. and then client initiates a new : connection on that port and then the real ftp data transfer happens.

Quoted 7 lines

Yes. I think FTP should be summarily executed. It has been plaguing us since the beginnings of firewalls and NAT. Sadly, another spiritually impoverished but well-known operating system has two basic options for file transfer: HTTP ("the Internet", of course!), and FTP (for experts!). Of course, on the other side of the divide, people (ab)use ssh for all sorts of nefarious purposes....... (anybody remember a recent article in some print periodical detailing NFS over ssh?)

<snip>

Not trying to be argumentative or start a useless tangential thread here, but none other than Frank da Cruz provides his reason why he thinks ftp is better than ssh/scp at the following link:

http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ftpclient.html

Note he is coming at this as the developer of the most capable comm program ever.

jb

--
Jack Bowling mailto:[email protected]
Prince George, BC
_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/

#3 lore raw
In reply to Dhirendra Pal Singh

Hi Martin,

First of all thanks for the info.
Now among all the links you have sent I think, the one which says about using the helper and mark the packets will be the one which will best do the job.

So I think what you are pointing to, is that mark all the ftp packets (control and data) with a specific mark and then do bandwidth policies on the basis of that mark.. is that right Martin?

Also I ran ethereal for further analysis. To my surprise ethereal showed FTP-DATA in front of the data which is captured by it duing ftp transactions.? Any idea how did ethereal found that out ??

Thanks for helping and anticipation
Dp

PS.. In one of my previous querries you had asked about the idea of FAQ. I am totally for it...

Quoted 38 lines · Martin A. Brown

Hi there Dhirendra,

: Okay now I put on a rule for FTP port 21 for 100Kbps. Now when I am : retriving data from ftp server I think the port is different when doing : passive ftp transfer. If I am not wrong then a new dynamic port is sent : by the ftp server to the client.. and then client initiates a new : connection on that port and then the real ftp data transfer happens.

Yes. I think FTP should be summarily executed. It has been plaguing us since the beginnings of firewalls and NAT. Sadly, another spiritually impoverished but well-known operating system has two basic options for file transfer: HTTP ("the Internet", of course!), and FTP (for experts!). Of course, on the other side of the divide, people (ab)use ssh for all sorts of nefarious purposes....... (anybody remember a recent article in some print periodical detailing NFS over ssh?)

There has been discussion on the question of FTP (port/passive) and shaping on this list in the past. Here are some links.

See the following threads:

http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2001q3/001473.html
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2002q1/002388.html
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/pipermail/lartc/2003q1/007498.html

See also Eric Leblond's description of usage:

http://home.regit.org/connmark.html

: My Question is : Now when limiting the bandwidht will htb limit that : data transfer(i.e. the real file transfer) also under 100Kbps or will : that data transfer be not at all affected by the rule..?

That depends entirely on how you use the tools above. Take a look at Eric Lelond's description, and let us know if you are successful.

: Just a novice question.. but please guide me...

Quoted 10 lines

This question is in exactly the right forum, and I'm quite sure I wouldn't call it a novice question....though it might well belong in that rumoured FAQ.

Good luck,

-Martin

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/

#4 lore raw
In reply to Dhirendra Pal Singh
Quoted 15 lines · Dhirendra Pal Singh

Hi Martin,

First of all thanks for the info.
Now among all the links you have sent I think, the one which says about using the helper and mark the packets will be the one which will best do the job.

So I think what you are pointing to, is that mark all the ftp packets (control and data) with a specific mark and then do bandwidth policies on the basis of that mark.. is that right Martin?

Also I ran ethereal for further analysis. To my surprise ethereal showed FTP-DATA in front of the data which is captured by it duing ftp transactions.? Any idea how did ethereal found that out ??

Quoted 5 lines

Thanks for helping and anticipation
Dp

PS.. In one of my previous querries you had asked about the idea of FAQ. I am totally for it...

I covered the subject on www.docum.org on the faq page :)

Stef

Signature · 8 lines
[email protected]
 "Using Linux as bandwidth manager"
     http://www.docum.org/
     #lartc @ irc.oftc.net

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/
#5 lore raw
In reply to Dhirendra Pal Singh

Hi Stef,
I did check on docum or org specially the FAQ but couldnt find anything.
http://www.docum.org/stef.coene/qos/docs/ was the link I searched.

If you could please send me the link, it would be great.

Thanks in advance
Dp

Quoted 21 lines · Stef Coene
Quoted 18 lines · Dhirendra Pal Singh

Hi Martin,

First of all thanks for the info.
Now among all the links you have sent I think, the one which says about using the helper and mark the packets will be the one which will best do the job.

So I think what you are pointing to, is that mark all the ftp packets (control and data) with a specific mark and then do bandwidth policies on the basis of that mark.. is that right Martin?

Also I ran ethereal for further analysis. To my surprise ethereal showed FTP-DATA in front of the data which is captured by it duing ftp transactions.? Any idea how did ethereal found that out ??

Thanks for helping and anticipation
Dp

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 4 lines

PS.. In one of my previous querries you had asked about the idea of FAQ. I am totally for it...

I covered the subject on www.docum.org on the faq page :)

Stef

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/

#6 lore raw
In reply to Dhirendra Pal Singh
Quoted 5 lines · Dhirendra Pal Singh

Hi Stef,
I did check on docum or org specially the FAQ but couldnt find anything.
http://www.docum.org/stef.coene/qos/docs/ was the link I searched.

If you could please send me the link, it would be great.

Go to www.docum.org and click on faq in the left frame. It's the last entry in the list. But I only added a link to an external page for more information.

Stef

Signature · 8 lines
[email protected]
 "Using Linux as bandwidth manager"
     http://www.docum.org/
     #lartc @ irc.oftc.net

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/