Skip to contentSkip to conversation

u32 filter limits?? ....?2000

LARTC Trevor Warren 2 participants 3 messages Jun 22, 2003 – Jun 23, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hey Nickola,

Yep, this surely is a feature/bug of tc which deems clarification. Hope
someone can come around with a fix for the same.

As for your setup, can i humbly request you to send across the script
such that i can test the same on my setup.....that is if you don't mind. Also, i was under the presumtion that flowid was used only when iptables is used to mark these outgoing packets.

Since i don't use iptables i have stuck to plain u32 filters. Lemme
know Nickola and i will try changing the classid to flowid and give this one a shot.

Any points at optimising the same folks???.

Trevor

Quoted 67 lines · Nickola Kolev

Hey again, Trevor,

[ cut ]
: Thanks for the prompt reply. Am indeed glad that htb scales to my : enterprise requirements. I have performed tests on my Athlon 1.7Ghz but : still use my dell latitude for r and d.

I also changed a bit my testbed, just to overclock the CPU to 863MHz (though it is the same Duron@750) and to add some 256MB of RAM, which totals 512.

[ cut ]
: I have tested the same time and again and am convinced this issue needs : to be clarified on.

Obviously, and you'll see I'm backing you later on.

: * Uptill 2000 U32 Filters and htb classes everything is fine : * Above 2000....i am very clear that probably htb classes formation : happens seamlessly but U32 filters stat throwing some stupid errors.

In my test, tc started throwing errors at u32 filter, attached to classid 2048

tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:0 protocol ip u32 match ip dst \
192.168.20.48/32 classid 1:2048
RTNETLINK answers: File exists

I'm not sure if htb classids (or better u32 classids) are limited to 2048 (dec), which equals 800(hex). I'm sorry, but I can't read sources, otherwise I could peek into Martin Devera's work to search for an answer.

: * "RTNETLINK answers: No such file or directory" thrown up for filters : greater than 2000. Not exactly sure on which number...but very surely : above 2000.

In my case, tc answered "RTNETLINK answers: File exists" after adding u32 classifier to classid 2048. This is probably not the case, because in my production setup, I have classids much higher than 2048, e.g.:

tc class add dev eth0 parent $HOME64_CLASS classid 1:14116 htb \
rate $HOME64_CHILD ceil $HOME64_SPEED burst 12k quantum 1514
tc filter add dev eth0 protocol ip parent 1:0 prio $HOME64_PRIO u32 \
match ip dst 10.10.8.79 flowid 1:14116
tc qdisc add dev eth0 parent 1:14116 handle 14116: sfq quantum 1514b perturb 10

here HOME64_CHILD, HOME64_SPEED and HOME64_PRIO are variables, taking part in the script.

: Any idea on whats wrong with my setup. Does this necessitate change in : use of U32 filters. Can this be avoided???. Or am i on the wrong : track???.

Keeping in mind I wrote the above, I notice that I'm using a bit different sintax, i.e. attaching u32 classifiers to "flowid", not to "classid", as in your setup. But nevertheless, the resulst is a

RTNETLINK answers: File exists

: Any pointers towards resolving the same will be appreciated. Am : attaching the 4000 approx user script along.

Personally I can't help, obviously. Am I missing something? I tend to be erroneous, but this is beyound the scope of my knowledge. ;)

Martin Devera? Stef Coene? Martin Brown? Leonardo Baliache?

Well, If I missed someone more deep-in-this-stuff, please, excuse me, but I would also be very interested in clarifying this.

Signature · 9 lines
( >-    GNU/LINUX, It's all about CHOICE      -< )
/~\    __  [email protected]  __   /~\
|  \) /  Pre Sales Consultant - Red Hat     \ (/ |
|_|_  \    9820349221(M) | 22881326(O)      / _|_|
       \___________________________________/

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/
#1 lore raw

Hey again, Trevor,

[ cut ]
: Thanks for the prompt reply. Am indeed glad that htb scales to my : enterprise requirements. I have performed tests on my Athlon 1.7Ghz but : still use my dell latitude for r and d.

I also changed a bit my testbed, just to overclock the CPU to 863MHz (though it is the same Duron@750) and to add some 256MB of RAM, which totals 512.

[ cut ]
: I have tested the same time and again and am convinced this issue needs : to be clarified on.

Obviously, and you'll see I'm backing you later on.

: * Uptill 2000 U32 Filters and htb classes everything is fine : * Above 2000....i am very clear that probably htb classes formation : happens seamlessly but U32 filters stat throwing some stupid errors.

In my test, tc started throwing errors at u32 filter, attached to classid 2048

tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:0 protocol ip u32 match ip dst \
192.168.20.48/32 classid 1:2048
RTNETLINK answers: File exists

I'm not sure if htb classids (or better u32 classids) are limited to 2048 (dec), which equals 800(hex). I'm sorry, but I can't read sources, otherwise I could peek into Martin Devera's work to search for an answer.

: * "RTNETLINK answers: No such file or directory" thrown up for filters : greater than 2000. Not exactly sure on which number...but very surely : above 2000.

In my case, tc answered "RTNETLINK answers: File exists" after adding u32 classifier to classid 2048. This is probably not the case, because in my production setup, I have classids much higher than 2048, e.g.:

tc class add dev eth0 parent $HOME64_CLASS classid 1:14116 htb \
rate $HOME64_CHILD ceil $HOME64_SPEED burst 12k quantum 1514
tc filter add dev eth0 protocol ip parent 1:0 prio $HOME64_PRIO u32 \
match ip dst 10.10.8.79 flowid 1:14116
tc qdisc add dev eth0 parent 1:14116 handle 14116: sfq quantum 1514b perturb 10

here HOME64_CHILD, HOME64_SPEED and HOME64_PRIO are variables, taking part in the script.

: Any idea on whats wrong with my setup. Does this necessitate change in : use of U32 filters. Can this be avoided???. Or am i on the wrong : track???.

Keeping in mind I wrote the above, I notice that I'm using a bit different sintax, i.e. attaching u32 classifiers to "flowid", not to "classid", as in your setup. But nevertheless, the resulst is a

RTNETLINK answers: File exists

: Any pointers towards resolving the same will be appreciated. Am : attaching the 4000 approx user script along.

Personally I can't help, obviously. Am I missing something? I tend to be erroneous, but this is beyound the scope of my knowledge. ;)

Martin Devera? Stef Coene? Martin Brown? Leonardo Baliache?

Well, If I missed someone more deep-in-this-stuff, please, excuse me, but I would also be very interested in clarifying this.

Signature · 5 lines
_____________________________________________________________

So long, and thanks for all the fish.

Nickola
#2 lore raw
In reply to Trevor Warren
Quoted 87 lines · Trevor Warren

Hey Nickola,

Yep, this surely is a feature/bug of tc which deems clarification. Hope
someone can come around with a fix for the same.

As for your setup, can i humbly request you to send across the script
such that i can test the same on my setup.....that is if you don't mind. Also, i was under the presumtion that flowid was used only when iptables is used to mark these outgoing packets.

Since i don't use iptables i have stuck to plain u32 filters. Lemme
know Nickola and i will try changing the classid to flowid and give this one a shot.

Any points at optimising the same folks???.

Trevor

Quoted 67 lines · Nickola Kolev

Hey again, Trevor,

[ cut ]
: Thanks for the prompt reply. Am indeed glad that htb scales to my : enterprise requirements. I have performed tests on my Athlon 1.7Ghz but : still use my dell latitude for r and d.

I also changed a bit my testbed, just to overclock the CPU to 863MHz (though it is the same Duron@750) and to add some 256MB of RAM, which totals 512.

[ cut ]
: I have tested the same time and again and am convinced this issue needs : to be clarified on.

Obviously, and you'll see I'm backing you later on.

: * Uptill 2000 U32 Filters and htb classes everything is fine : * Above 2000....i am very clear that probably htb classes formation : happens seamlessly but U32 filters stat throwing some stupid errors.

In my test, tc started throwing errors at u32 filter, attached to classid 2048

tc filter add dev eth0 parent 1:0 protocol ip u32 match ip dst \
192.168.20.48/32 classid 1:2048
RTNETLINK answers: File exists

I'm not sure if htb classids (or better u32 classids) are limited to 2048 (dec), which equals 800(hex). I'm sorry, but I can't read sources, otherwise I could peek into Martin Devera's work to search for an answer.

: * "RTNETLINK answers: No such file or directory" thrown up for filters : greater than 2000. Not exactly sure on which number...but very surely : above 2000.

In my case, tc answered "RTNETLINK answers: File exists" after adding u32 classifier to classid 2048. This is probably not the case, because in my production setup, I have classids much higher than 2048, e.g.:

tc class add dev eth0 parent $HOME64_CLASS classid 1:14116 htb \
rate $HOME64_CHILD ceil $HOME64_SPEED burst 12k quantum 1514
tc filter add dev eth0 protocol ip parent 1:0 prio $HOME64_PRIO u32 \
match ip dst 10.10.8.79 flowid 1:14116
tc qdisc add dev eth0 parent 1:14116 handle 14116: sfq quantum 1514b perturb 10

here HOME64_CHILD, HOME64_SPEED and HOME64_PRIO are variables, taking part in the script.

: Any idea on whats wrong with my setup. Does this necessitate change in : use of U32 filters. Can this be avoided???. Or am i on the wrong : track???.

Keeping in mind I wrote the above, I notice that I'm using a bit different sintax, i.e. attaching u32 classifiers to "flowid", not to "classid", as in your setup. But nevertheless, the resulst is a

RTNETLINK answers: File exists

: Any pointers towards resolving the same will be appreciated. Am : attaching the 4000 approx user script along.

Personally I can't help, obviously. Am I missing something? I tend to be erroneous, but this is beyound the scope of my knowledge. ;)

Martin Devera? Stef Coene? Martin Brown? Leonardo Baliache?

Well, If I missed someone more deep-in-this-stuff, please, excuse me, but I would also be very interested in clarifying this.

Signature · 9 lines
( >-    GNU/LINUX, It's all about CHOICE      -< )
/~\    __        [email protected]       __   /~\
|  \) /  Pre Sales Consultant - Red Hat     \ (/ |
|_|_  \    9820349221(M) | 22881326(O)      / _|_|
       \___________________________________/

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/