Add stacked registers to SAL records
SAL error records contain most registers in sal_processor_static_info, but not the stacked registers. What is the process for adding another GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?
Layout:
number of stacked registers in this record cfm for frame at the time of failure stacked registers, ending with the cfm.sof registers
This GUID would be optional, if a particular SAL implementation did not produce it then that platform would not have stacked registers printed via salinfo.
[RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)
Originally sent November 13 with no response, try again.
SAL error records contain most registers in sal_processor_static_info, but not the stacked registers. What is the process for adding another GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?
Layout:
number of stacked registers in this record cfm for frame at the time of failure stacked registers, ending with the cfm.sof registers
This GUID would be optional, if a particular SAL implementation did not produce it then that platform would not have stacked registers printed via salinfo.
Re: [RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)
In reply to Keith OwensQuoted 3 lines · Keith Owens
SAL error records contain most registers in
sal_processor_static_info, but not the stacked registers. What is the process for adding another GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?
I've always been puzzled about why the stacked registers aren't available after an INIT, so this proposal sounds incredibly useful to me. Much of the useful information, i.e., function arguments, is in the stacked registers and hence currently unavailable.
As for getting it added to the spec, I don't really know the process. But I'll forward this to our people who deal with the spec. I think it would help to have an actual draft of a proposal.
Tony Luck might have a good Intel contact, too.
Bjorn
RE: [RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)
In reply to Keith OwensQuoted 22 lines
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]On Behalf Of Bjorn Helgaas
Sent: Friday, December 05, 2003 8:29 AM
To: Keith Owens; [email protected]
Subject: Re: [RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)Quoted 1 line · Keith Owens
SAL error records contain most registers in
sal_processor_static_info,Quoted 1 line
but not the stacked registers. What is the process for
adding another
Quoted 1 line
GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?
I've always been puzzled about why the stacked registers aren't available after an INIT, so this proposal sounds incredibly useful to me. Much of the useful information, i.e., function arguments, is in the stacked registers and hence currently unavailable.
Quoted 5 lines
As for getting it added to the spec, I don't really know the process. But I'll forward this to our people who deal with the spec. I think it would help to have an actual draft of a proposal.
Tony Luck might have a good Intel contact, too.
I'm looking around for the right person to pass this to.
-Tony
Re: [RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)
In reply to Keith OwensQuoted 3 lines · Keith Owens
SAL error records contain most registers in
sal_processor_static_info, but not the stacked registers. What is the process for adding another GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?
One of our architecture guys pointed out that the stacked registers should still be intact at the OS_MCA and OS_INIT handoffs. They are unchanged in the PALE_CHECK and PALE_INIT exit state (I finally found this buried in the RSE description), and the OS_MCA and OS_INIT handoff state is defined to be the same for stacked registers.
So I assume your proposal is to address the fact that we don't actually save the error records until after a reboot, and the stacked register contents are gone by then. Right?
Bjorn
Re: [RFE] Add stacked registers to SAL records (resend)
In reply to Keith OwensQuoted 11 lines · Bjorn Helgaas
Quoted 3 lines · Keith Owens
SAL error records contain most registers in
sal_processor_static_info, but not the stacked registers. What is the process for adding another GUID to the SAL specification to contain the stacked registers?One of our architecture guys pointed out that the stacked registers should still be intact at the
OS_MCAandOS_INIThandoffs. They are unchanged in thePALE_CHECKandPALE_INITexit state (I finally found this buried in the RSE description), and theOS_MCAandOS_INIThandoff state is defined to be the same for stacked registers.
Quoted 3 lines
So I assume your proposal is to address the fact that we don't actually save the error records until after a reboot, and the stacked register contents are gone by then. Right?
Partly. Bu mainly because we need a new SAL error record section with its own GUID and an agreed format.
You mentioned in another mail "Someone also raised the technical question of whether the new format included enough information to relate it to a particular processor, i.e., maybe it should include the LID". We already have the lid, in sal_log_processor_info.