Sound card with S/PDIF input (and output) wanted
Hi,
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
1) Turlte Beach Fiji - but that card seems to have been withdrawn from the market
2) Hoontechs Multisound cards - but theese seems to resample all incomming data to their own 44.1Khz clock.
Christian
Quoted 7 lines · Christian Worm Mortensen
Hi,
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
Quoted 7 lines
1) Turlte Beach Fiji - but that card seems to have been withdrawn from the market
2) Hoontechs Multisound cards - but theese seems to resample all incomming data to their own 44.1Khz clock.Christian
I'm new to Linux so I don't know all the options we have yet. I have the
Sound Blaster Live. The drivers for this card under Linux are not available
yet. I went ahead and purchased the card knowing I couldn't run it fully under
Linux at this time. I believe the card will be supported under Linux because
it is a great card and in my opinion Creative will sell many . You get all the analog, synth, and midi feature plus digital I/O for around $200US. I do use
the card on the other OS until they get the drivers worked out. Open Sound
System (OSS) and Creative both are working on drivers for this card.
Thanks
Karl
Hi,
Quoted 6 lines · Oliver Helmling
Quoted 4 lines
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
what do you mean with S/PDIF?
I mean Sony/Philips Digital Interface Format (as far as I remember :-) ).
Quoted 1 line
normally OSS supports quite a lot of soundcards.
Yes - I asked if anyone know any supported soundcard except for the mentioned that can read data from an S/PDIF port without modifing it.
Quoted 1 line
i´ve got a soundblaster awe 64 and it works great.
As far as I know it has no digital input and if it has I am sure that it spoils what it reads on it.
Christian
Quoted 8 lines · Christian Worm Mortensen
Hi,
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
Quoted 6 lines
1) Turlte Beach Fiji - but that card seems to have been withdrawn from the market
2) Hoontechs Multisound cards - but theese seems to resample all incomming data to their own 44.1Khz clock.Christian
hi christian,
what do you mean with S/PDIF? normally OSS supports quite a lot of soundcards. i´ve got a soundblaster awe 64 and it works great. which distribution do you have? S.u.S.E. ships with a free commercial version of OSS (ver 3.8).
Signature · 2 lines
Grüße Oliver
Quoted 4 lines · Oliver Helmling
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
I have been looking around for such a card myself for quite some time. The only one with a reasonable price/performance point that's also readily available is the SB Live. The only problem is that the Linux drivers are still in early beta. http://developer.soundblaster.com/linux/
It puzzles me that no more people are interested in using Linux for MP3 encoding and recording purposes. Maybe the market just haven't caught up with the demand yet. I'm going to use that card to replace CD's, LP's etc. with MP3's at home so that I can mix and match the music I want to listen to without having to stop whatever I'm doing to switch records all the time.
--------------------------------------------------------------
The Linux Resource Exchange http://www.linuxrx.com
Kristian Elof Soerensen [email protected] (+45) 45 93 92 02
Quoted 12 lines · Kristian Soerensen
Quoted 4 lines · Oliver Helmling
Can it really be true that there exists no useable sound card (except for the in Europe very expensive Turtle Beach Pinnacle card) with S/PDIF input that is supported by Linux? Either by OSS/free or ALSA. The only thing I have found is:
I have been looking around for such a card myself for quite some time. The only one with a reasonable price/performance point that's also readily available is the SB Live. The only problem is that the Linux drivers are still in early beta. http://developer.soundblaster.com/linux/
Quoted 6 lines
It puzzles me that no more people are interested in using Linux for MP3 encoding and recording purposes. Maybe the market just haven't caught up with the demand yet. I'm going to use that card to replace CD's, LP's etc. with MP3's at home so that I can mix and match the music I want to listen to without having to stop whatever I'm doing to switch records all the time.
I think the availability of good free software makes it easy without special hardware. I use grip, and encoder for ripping and encoding and xmms with mpg123 for playing. Works great. grip even does automated enquiries from cddb for cd titles and tracks. Slower than dedicated hardware, but works great.
Rick
Quoted 5 lines
--------------------------------------------------------------
The Linux Resource Exchange http://www.linuxrx.com
Kristian Elof Soerensen [email protected] (+45) 45 93 92 02
--
mailto:[email protected] <=> RICK MARSHALL <=> http://www.herzfeld.com.au/isl
International Software Laboratories Pty Limited - Australia, New Zealand
Footwear: Retail Management, Point of Sale, Wholesale, Manufacturing
(-: All in Linux :-) (-: On the Web :-) (-: All in UNIBASE 5GL :-)
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 8 lines
It puzzles me that no more people are interested in using Linux for MP3 encoding and recording purposes. Maybe the market just haven't caught up with the demand yet. I'm going to use that card to replace CD's, LP's etc. with MP3's at home so that I can mix and match the music I want to listen to without having to stop whatever I'm doing to switch records all the time.
Quoted 4 lines
I think the availability of good free software makes it easy without special hardware. I use grip, and encoder for ripping and encoding and xmms with mpg123 for playing. Works great. grip even does automated enquiries from cddb for cd titles and tracks. Slower than dedicated hardware, but works great.
It won't work with LP's, cassette tapes, radio broadcasts etc. unless the sound equipment is sitting right next to the computer. For longer distances such as is found in most homes etc. you will need the A->D conversion to happen as close as possible to the analog equipment and transport the sound in digital form from there to the computer where it's to be mp3 encoded and stored.
Neither will your proposal work for the many digital audio sources such as DAT, minidisc, digital musical instruments etc.
Not all people lives in tiny dorm rooms or have both their computers and their HiFi mounted in the same 19" rack. I surely don't want my home to look like an average server room/sound studio just to get decent quality A->D conversion and mp3 encoding of various sound sources.
Actually I want to get all the benefits of modern technology including getting rid of the tons of boxes and kilometers of wires that was neccesary with pre. mp3 audio.
------------------- http://www.image.dk/~elof ----------------------
Kristian Elof Soerensen [email protected] (+45) 45 93 92 02
Hi,
Quoted 4 lines
I have been looking around for such a card myself for quite some time. The only one with a reasonable price/performance point that's also readily available is the SB Live. The only problem is that the Linux drivers are still in early beta. http://developer.soundblaster.com/linux/
I am affraid SB Live is not an option for me. First, it resampels input to it's own 48Khz clock and maybe even do worse things. Second, the drivers are made by Creative and the source is not released.
Christian
Quoted 3 lines · Kristian Soerensen
It puzzles me that no more people are interested in using Linux for MP3 encoding and recording purposes. Maybe the market just haven't caught up with the demand yet. I'm going to use that card to replace CD's, LP's etc.
Well, I think most people just rip the tracks straight from CDs. It's by far the easiest way to go. Also, you can use a CD-burner for digital output (slow, but works). When it comes to recording, 16bits at 44,1kHz just isn't enough. I'd really like to see a reasonably priced, 20bit/48kHz(or more) card with Linux support and digital io-jacks. But I guess I'm going to have to wait for long...
It's funny how slow the soundcard development has been when compared to other computer components. I'm now using a GUS MAX and a AWE64Gold for my recording work. Although GUS is at least two or three years older than the AWE, it can handle 16bit full-duplex while AWE64Gold can't (!). Of course there are the overly-priced pro-cards, but they can't be used as an excuse forever.
Signature · 4 lines
Kai Vehmanen ----------------------------- CS, University of Turku, Finland : email mailto:[email protected] : projects, home page, etc http://www.wakkanet.fi/~kaiv/ : ambient-idm-rock-... mp3/ra http://www.wakkanet.fi/~kaiv/sculpscape.html
Quoted 9 lines
It's funny how slow the soundcard development has been when compared to other computer components. I'm now using a GUS MAX and a AWE64Gold for my recording work. Although GUS is at least two or three years older than the AWE, it can handle 16bit full-duplex while AWE64Gold can't (!). Of course there are the overly-priced pro-cards, but they can't be used as an excuse forever.
Huh?! I thought that the AWE64 is a 16 bit full-duplex card. That's the main reason I purchased mine. Did I really screw up here or what?
Jim Hines
400mhz AMDk6-2 98mb
RedHat 5.2 (2.0.36)
Quoted 3 lines
It's funny how slow the soundcard development has been when compared to other computer components.
Part of this is slow develpoment is due to human hearing limitations. I may be slightly off on the numbers, but I believe the human ear will 'max out' at 50KHz sample rate. Anything above and beyond this rate creates absolutely *no* improvement in sound quality to the human ear. We can't tell a difference. This is why many of the cards have frequency ceilings of 44.1KHz or 48KHz.
The other part of this slow development is a 'supply/demand' issue. Most people don't really even *need* a full-dpulex card at all. They use their sound cards for games/MP3s/etc (ie, only *playing* sound files). A _small_ percentage of them ever do any recording, and an even _smaller_ percentage of *these* people do recording that requires full-duplex operation.
We here on this mailing list are a small small small sub-culture (especially since we use linux in the first place), and while *we* may all like to have a nice 50KHz 20-bit full-duplex soundcard with 8 digital i/o ports, the other 99% of computer users couldn't care less. This creates a small demand for such a card. So small, in fact, that the price of such a product *must* be astronomically large, just to cover the research and development costs that went into the design of the card.
Quoted 4 lines
I'm now using
a GUS MAX and a AWE64Gold for my recording work. Although GUS is at least two or three years older than the AWE, it can handle 16bit full-duplex while AWE64Gold can't (!).
This was done to make the AWE64's more affordable. The second audio device in the AWE64 is an 8-bit device. (The AWE64Gold cost more than the AWE64 only because they have gold-plated the bus contacts. It's the exact same components other than that. I use the regular AWE64 because I'm a cheap-skate.)
Granted, the output of this second audio device leaves much to be desired, but the only person who ever hears the sound out of this second device (in my case, at least) is me. I do multi-track recording, so I have to listen to a scratchy bass guitar through the 8-bit device as I lay down the rhythm guitar through the 16-bit device, but I see this as only a minor annoyance since the final mix-down of all the tracks that I record sounds just fine when it's all said and done.
The AWE64 packs alot of bang for the buck, IMHO. I can do all of my recording with this one sound card. I have my complaints about the card, too, so don't get me wrong, but you can't expect professional quality recording from a card that only costs $35 brand new. You get what you pay for.
Chad Walker
Digital Systems Design Engineer
HAL Computer Systems
Quoted 6 lines · Paco
Quoted 2 lines
It's funny how slow the soundcard development has been when compared to other computer components.
Part of this is slow develpoment is due to human hearing limitations. I may be slightly off on the numbers, but I believe the human ear will 'max out' at 50KHz sample rate. Anything above and beyond this rate creates absolutely *no* improvement in sound quality to the human ear. We
Well, the upper limit for human hearing is around 20kHz (although there are exceptions, even over 22kHz!). And as Nyquist's sampling theorem says, 40kHz is enough to represent a 20kHz signal. But in reality, it isn't so simple. In sound synthesis, the lack of frequency head-room when using 44.1/48kHz sampling freqs causes problems. Same goes for sample resolution. 16bit is fine for normal playback, but when you are recording, using 20bit samples helps enormously as it gives more head-room. You can record safely without clipping and still have a decent dynamic range.
Quoted 4 lines
The other part of this slow development is a 'supply/demand' issue. Most people don't really even *need* a full-dpulex card at all. They use their sound cards for games/MP3s/etc (ie, only *playing* sound files). A _small_ percentage of them ever do any recording, and an even _smaller_
Well, situation is changing. Internet phone-systems, voice control (Os/2 v3.0 aka Merlin brought this to the masses), multitrack recording, using you computer for listening music (mp3s), format conversions (vinyl -> cd transfers), ... Well, not all need full-duplex, but still, normal people might want to do these things.
Quoted 7 lines
Granted, the output of this second audio device leaves much to be desired, but the only person who ever hears the sound out of this second device (in my case, at least) is me. I do multi-track recording, so I have to listen to a scratchy bass guitar through the 8-bit device as I lay down the rhythm guitar through the 16-bit device, but I see this as only a minor annoyance since the final mix-down of all the tracks that I record sounds just fine when it's all said and done.
Okay, you can do multi-track recording, but what if you wanted to use your computer as a FX-processor? 8bit just isn't enough for this. And the otherway around, you might want to recycle the tracks you recorded through some external fx-gear. This too, definately needs 16bit full-duplex.
Quoted 5 lines
The AWE64 packs alot of bang for the buck, IMHO. I can do all of my recording with this one sound card. I have my complaints about the card, too, so don't get me wrong, but you can't expect professional quality recording from a card that only costs $35 brand new. You get what you pay for.
I can say all that about my GUSMAX, but it cost less and I bought it two or three years ago. It just sounds unbelievable. At the time I bought my GUS, I had a 486 with 8MB of memory...
Ok, I admit that AWE64 has better MIDI-features and the DAC isn't bad either, but still... hopefully this will change soon.
Signature · 4 lines
Kai Vehmanen ----------------------------- CS, University of Turku, Finland : email mailto:[email protected] : home page, projects, etc http://www.wakkanet.fi/~kaiv/ : my music (ambient-idm-rock-...mp3/ra) http://www.wakkanet.fi/sculpscape/