Skip to content

RFC gdth combined patchset & call for testers

Boaz Harrosh linux-scsi 1 version In review

Get series with b4
b4 am [email protected]

Versions newest first

  1. v1 RFC Latest16 patches 29 repliesIn review

Patches in v1 No applies recorded yet

#Subject and filesSizeRepliesApplied
1/16gdth: split out isa probingdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+154 -1272 replies
2/16gdth: split out eisa probingdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+150 -1207 replies
3/16gdth: split out pci probingdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+155 -1320 replies
4/16gdth: Remove 2.4.x support, in-kernel changelogdrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h drivers/scsi/gdth_kcompat.h +1 more+2 -4530 replies
5/16gdth: kill gdth_{read,write}[bwl] wrappersdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+153 -1600 replies
6/16Reorder scsi_host_template intitializersdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+3 -30 replies
7/16gdth: make some virt ctrlr code commondrivers/scsi/gdth.c+41 -391 reply
8/16gdth: Remove virt hostsdrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth_proc.c drivers/scsi/gdth_proc.h+25 -970 replies
9/16gdth: clean up host private datadrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h drivers/scsi/gdth_proc.c +1 more+291 -3841 reply
10/16gdth: gdth_get_status() return pointer to host not its indexdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+11 -153 replies
11/16gdth: switch to modern scsi host registrationdrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h+153 -1620 replies
12/16gdth: Remove gdth_ctr_tab[]drivers/scsi/gdth.c+51 -580 replies
13/16gdth: Make one abuse of scsi_cmnd less obviousdrivers/scsi/gdth.c+18 -154 replies
14/16gdth: Setup proper per-command private datadrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h drivers/scsi/gdth_proc.c+91 -330 replies
15/16gdth: Move members from SCp to gdth_cmndinfo, stage 2drivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h drivers/scsi/gdth_proc.c+104 -912 replies
16/16gdth: !use_sg cleanup and use of scsi accessorsdrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h+108 -1261 reply
16/16gdth: !use_sg cleanup and use of scsi accessorsdrivers/scsi/gdth.c drivers/scsi/gdth.h+109 -1260 replies

Reviews trailers per patch

No Reviewed-by, Acked-by or Tested-by trailers for v1 yet.

Read the v1 thread

Cover letter [RFC 0/16] gdth combined patchset & call for testers

Hi!

following is an attempted at unified patchset for the gdth driver.

They try to incorporate floating patches to gdth from:
Christoph Hellwig
Jeff Garzik
Matthew Wilcox
and Me Boaz Harrosh

They are done in the mindset of "likelihood of inducing breakage", hence the need for testers. Christoph & Jeff please review for any obvious easy-to-catch bugs.

Some short explanations:
[1/16] gdth: split out isa probing - Christoph Hellwig [2/16] gdth: split out eisa probing - Christoph Hellwig [3/16] gdth: split out pci probing - Christoph Hellwig
These three are from Christoph and where ACKed by Jeff at the time.

[4/16] gdth: Remove 2.4.x support, in-kernel changelog - Jeff Garzik
Same but partial work was done both by Christoph and Matthew.

[5/16] gdth: kill gdth_{read,write}[bwl] wrappers - Jeff Garzik [6/16] Reorder scsi_host_template intitializers [7/16] gdth: make some virt ctrlr code common
These 3 are from Jeff's patchset 6 & 7 where the same patch

[8/16] gdth: Remove virt hosts - Christoph && Boaz
Here we need an executive decision! The issue is as stated by Christoph:

"The virt_ctr option allows to register a new scsi_host for each bus on the raid controller. This non-default option makes no sense with the current scsi code and prevents cleaning up the host registration, so remove it."

I agree. This is just exactly the same as done buy scsi-ml scans but only more resource consuming. Unless I'm totally missing something, perhaps it is just a leftover from old kernels.

But if it is decided that this "virt_ctr" fixture is absolutely needed than I have a patch for re-enabling it at: "after the patchset", done in a different way. Because for now it prevents the cleanups I need.

Also this patch can Just be merged with [7/16] but I wanted it separate in the case we decide for "virt_ctr" fixture return.

[9/16] gdth: clean up host private data - Christoph && Boaz
This is based on the same patch from Christoph, but taken one step farther, by just passing the ha pointer everywhere instead of hanum. Christoph please acknowledge your signed-of-by on this patch.

[10/16] gdth: gdth_get_status() return pointer to host not its index - Boaz
This logically belongs to [9/16] but is separated for reviewing and bisect-ability As it is a sensitive matter.

[11/16] gdth: switch to modern scsi host registration - Christoph
Christoph what is missing from here is the remove of the deprecated pci_find_device() call. Can I Just use pci_get_device() of the same signature or do I need to call some other pci_ members after that?

[12/16] gdth: Remove gdth_ctr_tab[] - Boaz
I took Christoph's cleanup one step farther and got read of the statically allocated gdth_ctr_tab[]. In it's place I use the new link-list introduced by the [11/16] patch.

[13/16] gdth: Make one abuse of scsi_cmnd less obvious - Matthew Wilcox
This is the first patch sent by Matthew Wilcox, rebased to all above patches. Matthew, thanks, it saved me from a much uglier hack I had with regard to per-command-private-data.

[14/16] gdth: Setup proper per-command private data - Boaz [15/16] gdth: Move members from SCp to gdth_cmndinfo, stage 2 - Boaz
These two move me much closer to the agenda I had in all this, which is: "gdth diss-abuse of of scsi_cmnd IO members". With these patches I also conform to Matthew's second patch:
"gdth: Stop abusing ->done for internal commands"

[16/16] gdth: !use_sg cleanup and use of scsi accessors
And finally this one.

Boaz