Skip to content

RFC Buildroot cleanup

Thomas Petazzoni buildroot 1 version New

Get series with b4
b4 am [email protected]

Versions newest first

  1. v1 RFC Latest5 patches 0 repliesNew

Patches in v1 No applies recorded yet

#Subject and filesSizeRepliesApplied
1/5Remove the "project" featureMakefile package/Makefile.autotools.in package/at/at.mk +29 more+252 -3658 replies
1/5Remove the "project" feature+0 -00 replies
1/5Remove the "project" feature+0 -01 reply
1/5Remove the "project" feature+0 -00 replies
2/5Remove the BOARD/LOCAL featureMakefile+0 -150 replies
3/5By default, put the output in an output/ directoryMakefile+2 -31 reply
3/5By default, put the output in an output/ directory+0 -00 replies
4/5Remove BR2_TOPDIR_PREFIX and BR2_TOPDIR_SUFFIXConfig.in Makefile package/Makefile.in+4 -311 reply
4/5Remove BR2_TOPDIR_PREFIX and BR2_TOPDIR_SUFFIX+0 -01 reply
5/5Rename the output directoriesConfig.in Makefile package/Makefile.in+9 -101 reply
5/5Rename the output directories+0 -01 reply

Reviews trailers per patch

No Reviewed-by, Acked-by or Tested-by trailers for v1 yet.

Read the v1 thread

Cover letter [Buildroot] [RFC] [PATCH 0/5] Buildroot cleanup

Hello,

I would like to propose a few patches to start a cleanup of Buildroot. My goal is not only to cleanup Buildroot internally, but also to clean it up so that it is easier to understand for our users.

This thread is meant to be a preliminary discussion only and is not yet a request for inclusion, because :

* Some of the proposed changes remove features that I think confuse our users and are not central in Buildroot operation, but others might have different opinion on the matter ;

* The changes are relatively invasive and I did only limited testing on them.

* The documentation is not updated with the changes. I'm waiting for the community opinion on the changes before spending time to update the documentation

While the commit logs gives all the details, I would like to give an quick overview of the proposed changes :

1. Remove the "project" feature.

This feature is meant to allow an user to build a Linux system for several similar platforms where the differences are only in Busybox, kernel and U-Boot configuration. While this feature might be useful in some very specific cases, my opinion is that it adds far too much complexity in Buildroot compared to the added-value it gives.

Removing this feature allows to instantly make the directory layout a lot simpler to understand for a newcomer (no strane project_build_ARCH directory anymore !)

2. Remove the BOARD/LOCAL feature.

This mechanism is a duplication of something that could already be done in a different way: by adding a new target in target/device/.

3. By default, put the output directories in a single directory, named output/.

Nothing complex, it just clarifies the tree for a new user.

4. Remove BR2_TOPDIR_PREFIX and BR2_TOPDIR_SUFFIX

The same thing can be done with O=

5. Rename the output directories with more sensible names.

In the output directory, we now have

- build/ where all the packages are built
- images/ where the final kernel and rootfs images are stored
- staging/ the staging directory (containing the development files and libraries compiled for the target)
- target/ which contains the target root filesystem
- host/ which contains all the host programs
- stamps/ which contains the stamps files

Thanks for your input,

Thomas