How drivers notice a HW error?
Hi all,
This is a request for comments, especially comments from driver developers.
On some platform, for example IA64, the chipset detects an error caused by driver's operation such as I/O read, and reports it to kernel. Linux kernel analyzes the error and decides to kill the driver or reboot at worst. I want to convey the error information to the offending driver, and want to enable the driver to recover the failed operation.
So, just a plan, I think about a readb_check function that has checking ability enable it to return error value if error is occurred on read. Drivers could use readb_check instead of usual readb, and could diagnosis whether a retry be required or not, by the return value of readb_check.
To realize this, I consider following two images:
+ readb_check on driver (with Notifier)
[Outline]:
- Hardware error handler (for example in IA64, MCA handler) has a Notifier as hook point.
- Driver may register a hook function to the Notifier.
- Notifier calls over registered functions when error is occurred.
- Called hook function checks address of error, and if the error seems to be concerned with the parent driver, ups internal error flag and stops Notifier by returning OK.
- Hardware error handler regards state of Notifier, and decides the system to resume or not.
- Restarted driver may refer the error flag after read, and may retry the read if flag is up.
[Issue]:
- Some interfaces such as register hooks would be required.
- Coding a hook function would be a bother of developers.
+ readb_check on kernel
[Outline]:
- Kernel has readb_check function.
- Drivers may use readb_check instead of usual readb.
- Hardware error handler checks address of error, and if it occurs in readb_check, changes return value of readb_check and resumes interrupted context.
- Driver may refer the return value to notice an error in last read procedure.
[Issue]:
- Overhead would be involved. (Possibly, it could say negligible since I/O reads are already horribly slow.)
IMO, this is a general-purpose function that should be available on many platforms. I also hear that Solaris has some similar implementations like this.
If you have any comment about this feature or any idea different from this, please tell me.
Best regards,
------
H.Seto <[email protected]>