Skip to contentSkip to conversation

UML kernel & rootfs bundle with every kernel release ?

RFC roland 2 participants 2 messages Apr 3, 2007

lore
Share & tools
lore

roland

author
#0 lore raw

what is the real advantage to package uml-kernel and rootfs into a single file ?

If this needs to be distributed with additional script, that's two files, anyway.

the classical way would be 3 files: uml-kernel, rootfs, script - put into some tar.gz or tar.bz2

this could look as elegant like:

linux-2.6.21-UML-TryMe-and-RunMe-Kit.tar.bz2

linux-2.6.21-start.sh (containing ./linux-2.6.21-kernel-um ubd0=linux-2.6.21-rootfs.....) linux-2.6.21-kernel-um
linux-2.6.21-rootfs

regards
roland

ps:

Quoted 3 lines

I've done the converse: package the uml kernel within the rootfs image, and use a script that plays the part of bootloader. With ext2 at least, it's fairly easy to use the debugfs 'cat' command for this.

wicked, though! :)

Quoted 8 lines · Jeff Dike

There are sites (http://uml.nagafix.co.uk/ being the best one I know of) where, with two downloads, two uncompressions, and one command line later, you have a booted UML.

The only way I know of to improve on this, aside from inprovements in the booted distro, is to package the filesystem as a rootfs within the UML kernel binary. I've considered this, but haven't done anything with it.

I've done the converse: package the uml kernel within the rootfs image, and use a script that plays the part of bootloader. With ext2 at least, it's fairly easy to use the debugfs 'cat' command for this.

That way, you simply distribute the fs image with a companion script that can boot any number of such images.

Jason

#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · roland

what is the real advantage to package uml-kernel and rootfs into a single file ?

If this needs to be distributed with additional script, that's two files, anyway.

If a common means of doing this were widespread, the script would be distributed separately (probably with the uml utilities). Analagous to the way bootloaders are separate from linux on real hardware.

That way, the distributor of a virtual machine would only distribute that single system image. The user would boot it using the script according to his own host environment.

Jason