alsa and gtk
folks,
thought I'd bounce this off the list in case anyone has seen it before. I'm trying to write something like TotalMix for the RME HDSP, but more suited for mixing in-ear-monitors. So I wrote this mini library that uses the snd_ctl_* api of alsa. Wrote all the functionality, tested the functionality in a CLI and everything worked. Yesterday, I started writing the GUI in GTK and some weird things started happening. Whenever I tried using the library outside of gtk_main, everything worked fine. It wasn't until after I started using snd_ctl_* functions from within gtk callbacks that I was having issues. If I move the library calls outside of something within or before gtk_main, it works just fine. After calling gtk_main, any functions are also toast. When trying to write to a control element, I get:
Control hw:1 element write error: No such file or directory
and similarly, when I try to read an element, I get:
Control hw:1 element read error: No such file or directory
Once gtk_main hits, the game is over. Is there something gtk_main does to the environment that affects alsa? I'm willing to post code for anyone who's interested. Normally, I'd start pouring through GTK+ and Alsa source at this point, but time is of the essence in my case.
thanks,
d!
Quoted 17 lines · David E. Storey
folks,
thought I'd bounce this off the list in case anyone has seen it before. I'm trying to write something like TotalMix for the RME HDSP, but more suited for mixing in-ear-monitors. So I wrote this mini library that uses the snd_ctl_* api of alsa. Wrote all the functionality, tested the functionality in a CLI and everything worked. Yesterday, I started writing the GUI in GTK and some weird things started happening. Whenever I tried using the library outside of
gtk_main, everything worked fine. It wasn't until after I started using snd_ctl_* functions from within gtk callbacks that I was having issues. If I move the library calls outside of something within or beforegtk_main, it works just fine. After callinggtk_main, any functions are also toast. When trying to write to a control element, I get:Control hw:1 element write error: No such file or directory
Quoted 8 lines
and similarly, when I try to read an element, I get:
Control hw:1 element read error: No such file or directory
Once
gtk_mainhits, the game is over. Is there somethinggtk_maindoes to the environment that affects alsa? I'm willing to post code for anyone who's interested. Normally, I'd start pouring through GTK+ and Alsa source at this point, but time is of the essence in my case.
I had a problem like this once, not with gtk. The controls get corrupted. I had an extrmemely short deadline so I just allocated and freed a new control every time I wanted to use it, rather inefficient. I think it *must* be an alsa bug, but it is very strange. Hope you can find it.
Justin
-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Etnus, makers of TotalView, The best thread debugger on the planet. Designed with thread debugging features you've never dreamed of, try TotalView 6 free at www.etnus.com.
curious... that did the trick. True about the inefficiency... but then again, we are talking about GUI's. ;-) Thanks!
d!
Quoted 5 lines · Justin Cormack
I had a problem like this once, not with gtk. The controls get corrupted. I had an extrmemely short deadline so I just allocated and freed a new control every time I wanted to use it, rather inefficient. I think it *must* be an alsa bug, but it is very strange. Hope you can find it.
If you still have the non working version it might be worth running it under valgrind to see if you can find where the bug is, as it would be nice to fix it. Or send me a copy and I will have a go. I dont have the old version of my code, though I could reconstruct it.
Quoted 12 lines · David E. Storey
curious... that did the trick. True about the inefficiency... but then again, we are talking about GUI's. ;-) Thanks!
d!
Quoted 5 lines · Justin Cormack
I had a problem like this once, not with gtk. The controls get corrupted. I had an extrmemely short deadline so I just allocated and freed a new control every time I wanted to use it, rather inefficient. I think it *must* be an alsa bug, but it is very strange. Hope you can find it.
-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Etnus, makers of TotalView, The best thread debugger on the planet. Designed with thread debugging features you've never dreamed of, try TotalView 6 free at www.etnus.com.