Qualcomm "All Rights Reserved" in Linux staging
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Hi Greg,
Reading this story about Qualcomm lawyers shooting DMCA takedown requests lightly against github projects:
http://linux.slashdot.org/story/14/07/04/1455200/qualcomm-takes-down-100-github-repositories-with-dmca-notice
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTczNDU
https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2014-07-02-Qualcomm.md
It appears to me that the mere presence of those lines in Linux staging:
grep -r "Qualcomm" . |grep -i "rights"./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_usb.c: * CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_download.c:* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_hw.c:/* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved.
might be contradicting the Dual MPL/GPL license expressed by MODULE_LICENSE() for those files. Perhaps we should ask some clarification on licensing of those files to Qualcomm ?
Thanks,
Mathieu
Signature · 3 lines
Mathieu Desnoyers EfficiOS Inc. http://www.efficios.com
Quoted 4 lines · Mathieu Desnoyers
grep -r "Qualcomm" . |grep -i "rights"
./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_usb.c: * CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_download.c:* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_hw.c:/* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved.
That's actually a common pattern:
$ git grep -i "Copyright.*All Rights Reserved" v3.16-rc3 | wc -l
5203Paul Bolle
Quoted 9 lines · Paul Bolle
Quoted 4 lines · Mathieu Desnoyers
grep -r "Qualcomm" . |grep -i "rights"
./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_usb.c: * CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_download.c:* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_hw.c:/* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved.That's actually a common pattern:
$ git grep -i "Copyright.*All Rights Reserved" v3.16-rc3 | wc -l 5203
Yeah, I used to be "worried" about that as well, turns out it means nothing :)
It's the license of the code that is the issue, not the copyright line, which all lawyers tell me now shouldn't even be in a file, as it, again, means nothing.
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 17 lines · On Fri, 4 Jul 2014 21:20:28 +0000 (UTC) Mathieu Desnoyers…
Hi Greg,
Reading this story about Qualcomm lawyers shooting DMCA takedown requests lightly against github projects:
http://linux.slashdot.org/story/14/07/04/1455200/qualcomm-takes-down-100-github-repositories-with-dmca-notice
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTczNDU
https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2014-07-02-Qualcomm.mdIt appears to me that the mere presence of those lines in Linux staging:
grep -r "Qualcomm" . |grep -i "rights"
./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_usb.c: * CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_download.c:* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved. ./drivers/staging/ft1000/ft1000-usb/ft1000_hw.c:/* CopyRight (C) 2007 Qualcomm Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Quoted 4 lines
might be contradicting the Dual MPL/GPL license expressed by
MODULE_LICENSE()for those files. Perhaps we should ask some clarification on licensing of those files to Qualcomm ?
Trying to stop idiot DMCA takedowns is pointless. If some random robot issues a takedown the kernel.org folks will get another pointless DMCA notice and the Linux Foundation will have to go and kick backsides.
Qualcomm screwed up massively - the problem is that fake DMCA takedowns are never punished. Qualcomm shouldn't just be apologising, they should facing an automatic financial penalty for each bogus filing and whoever signed the notices should be facing their professional body.
Alan