Invisible threads in 2.6.9
We do indeed have a kernel problem. I re-did the
example code using the raw clone() system call,
to avoid any pthreads troubles. I took out the
busy loop; add it back in if you care to verify
that it would indeed chew up CPU time.
(I started the threads stopped, so they wouldn't
need to have distinct stacks.)
-------------------------- begin example ---------------------------
$ ./zombie-leader $ ps -mfL UID PID PPID LWP C NLWP STIME TTY TIME CMD albert 3224 3223 - 0 1 Sep29 pts/19 00:00:00 bash albert - - 3224 0 1 Sep29 - 00:00:00 - albert 7442 1 - 0 9 20:05 pts/19 00:00:00 [zombie-leader] <defunct> albert 7457 3224 - 0 1 20:06 pts/19 00:00:00 xterm albert - - 7457 0 1 20:06 - 00:00:00 - albert 7475 3224 - 0 1 20:10 pts/19 00:00:00 ps -mfL albert - - 7475 0 1 20:10 - 00:00:00 - $ ls /proc/7442/task/ ls: /proc/7442/task/: No such file or directory $ ls /proc/7442/ ls: cannot read symbolic link /proc/7442/cwd: Permission denied ls: cannot read symbolic link /proc/7442/root: Permission denied ls: cannot read symbolic link /proc/7442/exe: Permission denied auxv cmdline cwd environ exe fd maps mem mounts root stat statm status task wchan $ ps -mo stat,ppid,pid,tid,nlwp,args STAT PPID PID TID NLWP COMMAND - 3223 3224 - 1 bash Ss - - 3224 1 - - 1 7442 - 9 [zombie-leader] <defunct> - 3224 7457 - 1 xterm S - - 7457 1 - - 3224 7477 - 1 ps -mo stat,ppid,pid,tid,nlwp,args R+ - - 7477 1 - ---------------------------- end example -------------------------------
////////////////////// begin code /////////////////////////// #include <sys/types.h>
#include <unistd.h>
#include <signal.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <sched.h>
#ifndef CLONE_THREAD
#define CLONE_THREAD 0x00010000
#endif
#ifndef CLONE_DETACHED
#define CLONE_DETACHED 0x00400000
#endif
#ifndef CLONE_STOPPED
#define CLONE_STOPPED 0x02000000
#endif
// similar to NPTL pthreads, AFAIK
#define FLAGS (CLONE_FS|CLONE_FILES|CLONE_SIGHAND|CLONE_VM|CLONE_THREAD|CLONE_DETACHED)
static pid_t one;
static void die(int signo){
(void)signo;
_exit(0);
}
static void hang(void){
for(;;) pause();
}
static int clone_fn(void *vp){
(void)vp;
hang();
return 0; // keep gcc happy
}
static long clone_stack_data[2048];
#ifdef __hppa__
static long *clone_stack = &clone_stack_data[0]; #else
static long *clone_stack = &clone_stack_data[2048]; #endif
int main(int argc, char *argv[]){
pid_t minime;
int i = 8;
(void)argc;
(void)argv;
one = getpid();
signal(SIGHUP,die);
if(fork()) hang(); // parent later killed as readyness signal
while(i--){
// better be stopped... they share a stack
minime = clone(clone_fn, clone_stack, FLAGS | CLONE_STOPPED, NULL);
if(minime==-1){
perror("no clone");
kill(one,SIGKILL);
_exit(8);
}
} kill(one,SIGHUP); // let the shell know we're ready
_exit(0); // make task group leader a zombie
return 0; // keep gcc happy
}
/////////////////////// end code /////////////////////////////