[Fwd: Re: Linuxant/Conexant HSF/HCF Modem Drivers]
I'm not going to post much more about this topic.
The contents of this describe the lack of any notice of the actual licensing scheme of conexant/linuxant modems and their Linux drivers
-------- Forwarded Message --------
From: Chad Christopher Giffin <[email protected]>
Reply-To: [email protected]
To: Alan Cox <[email protected]>, [email protected] <[email protected]>, Paulo Marques <[email protected]>, Marc Boucher <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: Linuxant/Conexant HSF/HCF Modem Drivers Unlocked
Date: Fri, 29 Oct 2004 10:42:42 -0600
Quoted 7 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 3 lines · Chad Christopher Giffin
I still find myself deeply troubled and questioning the legalities of using "GPL\0[...]" in the license string of a non-GPL module. As it is a blatant lie.
Oh its almost certainly a criminal offence in the USA - the DMCA for example. The \0 stupidity checker needs to go into the kernel.
Well, as I expected, after learning my mistake, I am being told I was in the legal wrong.
Examine this:
I have a gentoo system. I bought a used pci modem card. Someone told me to use the hcfpcimodem package for the drivers, cause it's of course a piece of sh*t winmodem. I ran:
emerge hcfpcimodem
I get something installed in non-standard places. I can't find any documentation. It doesn't tell me ANYTHING upon install EXCEPT something similar to: "run hcfpciconfig to install your modem"
I'm left thinking this is just another free package.
When I run hcfpciconfig, I'm told to enter my kernel module build directory name, my email address, and a license number or "FREE". It tells me that I need a license from linuxant to do fax, voice or anything higher then 14.4k.
I do a search on the web for "linuxant license" and get keygen.pl.
I run keygen.pl and enter the key it gives me.
Upon questioning why I need a key, I strings the modules and see:
"license=GPL". I continue on my merry way thinking everything is OK.
Now where have I gone wrong here? And plus... when I go into the standard directories for documentation:
"/usr/man:/usr/share/man:/usr/info:/usr/share/info:/usr/share/doc" I find nothing about hcfpcimodem or hcfpciconfig(1). And I certainly find no license file in any of those directories OR the '/lib/modules/<kernel version>/misc' directory it places these magically appearing binaries.
/usr/sbin/hcfpciconfig says:
# Copyright (c) 2003 Linuxant inc.
but there is no mention of where the license is or what kind of license there is. and its a sh script that, normally, is too arcane for one to decipher.
Following all of this, does anyone have a clue what the licensing scheme is of linuxant drivers? there is no mention of anything except the string "license=GPL" in the binaries.
It upsets me that I have to pay TWICE for this modem. Once for the hardware and again for the driver. sheeesh!
Signature · 6 lines
- Chad Christopher Giffin mailto:[email protected] There are 10 kinds of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who do not. -- anonymous