64 bit kernel
Hi everyone,
I was wondering if anyone can tell me if the following is a 64 bit kernel problem or if it's a BIOS problem.
I have a Gigabyte K8NSC-939 with an AMD64 3200+ (Venice) CPU version F7 BIOS. When I first got this board, I put a single 512 Mb PC2700 DIMM in it from an older Celeron board I had. 32 bit Suse 10.0 and 32 bit FC4 loaded fine. When I tried the 64 bit version of either, I kept getting DMA errors on boot like the HD or controller was bad. After some searching I found others with similar problems and they had to use "noapic nolapic" kernel boot options to install and boot the OS. That worked for me too and I was able to install the OS.
After I upgraded the memory and put 2 512Mb PC3200 DIMMS in the board. I tried a 64 bit install again. This time I no longer had to use the "noapic nolapic" options. With a single DIMM, BIOS (during boot) reported "single channel" memory. With 2 DIMMS, BIOS (during boot) reports "dual channel" memory. My question though is does the 64 bit kernel require "dual channel" memory or is this a BIOS problem?
Stan
I saw a similar issue many years ago that turned out to be a chipset bug. This was a PII system that used 16 bit wide modules. When using only one module, the chipset "fooled" the OS into thinking that it was doing 32 bit wide operations. However, it failed at full speed. Reducing the memory bus speed or installing modules in pairs "fixed" the problem. I suspect a bus or memory controller issue rather than the kernel.
The failure mode was exactly as you describe. It manifested itself as disk errors or DMA failures. Unfortunately the chipset vendor determined that it was a silicon bug and said that they would NOT fix it!
Mike
----- Original Message ----- From: "Stan Gammons" <[email protected]>
To: "Linux Kernel Mailing List" <[email protected]>
Sent: Sunday, January 08, 2006 11:27 PM
Subject: 64 bit kernel
Quoted 32 lines
Hi everyone,
I was wondering if anyone can tell me if the following is a 64 bit kernel problem or if it's a BIOS problem.
I have a Gigabyte K8NSC-939 with an AMD64 3200+ (Venice) CPU version F7 BIOS. When I first got this board, I put a single 512 Mb PC2700 DIMM in it from an older Celeron board I had. 32 bit Suse 10.0 and 32 bit FC4 loaded fine. When I tried the 64 bit version of either, I kept getting DMA errors on boot like the HD or controller was bad. After some searching I found others with similar problems and they had to use "noapic nolapic" kernel boot options to install and boot the OS. That worked for me too and I was able to install the OS.
After I upgraded the memory and put 2 512Mb PC3200 DIMMS in the board. I tried a 64 bit install again. This time I no longer had to use the "noapic nolapic" options. With a single DIMM, BIOS (during boot) reported "single channel" memory. With 2 DIMMS, BIOS (during boot) reports "dual channel" memory. My question though is does the 64 bit kernel require "dual channel" memory or is this a BIOS problem?
Stan
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
Quoted 8 lines · On Monday 09 January 2006 08:25, Mike McCarthy, W1NR wrote:
I saw a similar issue many years ago that turned out to be a chipset bug. This was a PII system that used 16 bit wide modules. When using only one module, the chipset "fooled" the OS into thinking that it was doing 32 bit wide operations. However, it failed at full speed. Reducing the memory bus speed or installing modules in pairs "fixed" the problem. I suspect a bus or memory controller issue rather than the kernel.
Quoted 5 lines
The failure mode was exactly as you describe. It manifested itself as disk errors or DMA failures. Unfortunately the chipset vendor determined that it was a silicon bug and said that they would NOT fix it!
And that sucks the big one, Mike. Will you share that vendors name so we can bypass them in future purchase thinking?
Signature · 7 lines
Cheers, Gene People having trouble with vz bouncing email to me should add the word 'online' between the 'verizon', and the dot which bypasses vz's stupid bounce rules. I do use spamassassin too. :-) Yahoo.com and AOL/TW attorneys please note, additions to the above message by Gene Heskett are: Copyright 2005 by Maurice Eugene Heskett, all rights reserved.
Quoted 10 lines · On Mon, 2006-01-09 at 08:25 -0500, Mike McCarthy, W1NR wrote:
I saw a similar issue many years ago that turned out to be a chipset bug. This was a PII system that used 16 bit wide modules. When using only one module, the chipset "fooled" the OS into thinking that it was doing 32 bit wide operations. However, it failed at full speed. Reducing the memory bus speed or installing modules in pairs "fixed" the problem. I suspect a bus or memory controller issue rather than the kernel.
The failure mode was exactly as you describe. It manifested itself as disk errors or DMA failures. Unfortunately the chipset vendor determined that it was a silicon bug and said that they would NOT fix it!
Hi Mike,
What chipset was that?
This board has an nVidia nForce 3 chipset on it. This brings about another question. What is the consensus on using the amd74xx.c patch for the nForce 3/4 chipset that nVidia has on their website? It's supposed to improve HD performance. Any comments on including that patch in the existing kernel? How about the pros and or cons of adding that patch and rebuilding a system specific kernel?
Stan
Stan Gammons <[email protected]> writes:
First you get the price of the day for meaningless subjects. Gratulations.
Quoted 11 lines
I was wondering if anyone can tell me if the following is a 64 bit kernel problem or if it's a BIOS problem.
I have a Gigabyte K8NSC-939 with an AMD64 3200+ (Venice) CPU version F7 BIOS. When I first got this board, I put a single 512 Mb PC2700 DIMM in it from an older Celeron board I had. 32 bit Suse 10.0 and 32 bit FC4 loaded fine. When I tried the 64 bit version of either, I kept getting DMA errors on boot like the HD or controller was bad. After some searching I found others with similar problems and they had to use "noapic nolapic" kernel boot options to install and boot the OS. That worked for me too and I was able to install the OS.
That's usually an ACPI problem. Put full boot log of the failure and acpidmp output into bugzilla.kernel.org
The difference between 32bit and 64bit distro is that the later use the APIC by default so they are more sensitive to ACPI issues.
Quoted 7 lines
After I upgraded the memory and put 2 512Mb PC3200 DIMMS in the board. I tried a 64 bit install again. This time I no longer had to use the "noapic nolapic" options. With a single DIMM, BIOS (during boot) reported "single channel" memory. With 2 DIMMS, BIOS (during boot) reports "dual channel" memory. My question though is does the 64 bit kernel require "dual channel" memory or is this a BIOS problem?
That sounds weird. Most likely a BIOS problem of some sort.
Dual or single channel memory shouldn't make a difference to the kernel.
-Andi