2.6.15-rt3 + Open Posix Test Suite
It's worth noting that a few tests in the current Open Posix Test Suite
hang RT systems.
Specifically this test (hope this url comes through),
sched_setparam test 10-1.c and I think 9-1.c .
The 10-1 test spawns some children at SCHED_FIFO priority 99 , then runs the following,
void child_process(){
alarm(2);
while(1) {
(*shmptr)++;
sched_yield();
}
}I'm sure this is what's hanging the system, the yield() is one issue. Another is why the alarm() is never delivered .
Daniel
Quoted 21 lines · Daniel Walker
It's worth noting that a few tests in the current Open Posix Test Suite
hang RT systems.Specifically this test (hope this url comes through),
sched_setparamtest 10-1.c and I think 9-1.c .The 10-1 test spawns some children at
SCHED_FIFOpriority 99 , then runs the following,void child_process(){ alarm(2); while(1) { (*shmptr)++; sched_yield(); } }
Quoted 2 lines
I'm sure this is what's hanging the system, the
yield()is one issue. Another is why thealarm()is never delivered .
This runs a while loop at SCHED_FIFO prio 99? And alarm never happens. Doesn't the alarm get activated by the softirqd that is running at a lower priority? Seems that this is starving out the softirq from getting the alarm.
I believe that Thomas once had priorities attached to the timers. I'd like to see that again, and may even start adding them myself, such that when a process activates a timer, when that timer goes off, the softirq will get the priority of the timer. But this has some complications to be sorted out.
-- Steve
Quoted 5 lines · Steven Rostedt
This runs a while loop at
SCHED_FIFOprio 99? And alarm never happens. Doesn't the alarm get activated by the softirqd that is running at a lower priority? Seems that this is starving out the softirq from getting the alarm.
I thought alarm was a signal (SIGALRM) ? If it's delivered by softirqd then this makes sense. Your right , it's softirqd related.
The processes also calls yield() inside it's while loop . We have warnings about yield() and RT tasks.
Quoted 5 lines
I believe that Thomas once had priorities attached to the timers. I'd like to see that again, and may even start adding them myself, such that when a process activates a timer, when that timer goes off, the softirq will get the priority of the timer. But this has some complications to be sorted out.
Yes, I remember . Do we fix the test in this case, or the kernel ?
Daniel