Skip to contentSkip to conversation

__get_free_pages(): is the MEM really mine?

DISCUSSION Bernd Harries 1 participant 1 message Sep 27, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Ingo Molnar

well - what did you expect to happen? A freed page is going to be reused for other purposes. A big 2MB allocation can be reused in part, once memory usage grows.

With my knowledge, I expected exactly that.

Quoted 2 lines

So you should not expect the device to be able to DMA into a page that got freed, unpunished.

I am not. The DMA ioctl() finishes before the close() -> free happens after the hexdump and the DMA. The buffer is allocated in open. The fact that I get the same buffer again next time shows that the free is sucessful and effective, right?

Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel: rsc_open() minor=$1B 
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  DMA blk 0 at KV:$CE800000 BUS:$0E800000 
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  DMA blk 1 at KV:$CE600000 BUS:$0E600000

contig <

Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  Collected DMA Buffer1 at KS:$0000CE600000
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel: rsc_ioctl()
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  RSC_IOC_DMA_OUT
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel: rsc_close()
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  Free DMA blk 0 at KS:$CE800000 
Sep 27 11:43:28 pcma73 kernel:  Free DMA blk 1 at KS:$CE600000 
Quoted 1 line

Perhaps i'm misunderstanding the problem.

My problem is, I'm out of ideas. All I can think of is describe as much as possible the relevant things that I do and the things that occur. Maybe someone more experienced recognizes a principal flaw in the concept.

Quoted 6 lines

Plus, if you allocate a 2MB
physically continuous chunk then the likelyhood is high that there were fragmented pages skipped during the initial search for a 2MB block - so you still have a fair likelyhood to reallocate it after some time, if memory usage is light. But this likelyhood nears zero once RAM usage gets near 100%.

And I can rely on the fact that all the 2 MB are contig memory without holes, right? It's completely mine, isn't it?
Or is it perhaps illegal to let the mem usage pump?
Should I better allocate the mem in init_module() instead of rsc_open()? Probably page tables are more likely to get corrupted than they would be if I allocate only once. Or do I have to use a spin_lock somewhere in the nopage method?

Quoted 1 line

From my tests I'm ready the believe the 1st page really _is_ mine but now

I'm not so sure all the
(1 << 9) pages really are.

If I don't access the pages, just allocate them and free them after some time, I never saw any instabilities. But it seems that as soon as I access pages above the 1st in the buffer, something gets corrupted. So maybe today it's only legal to allocate 1 page at a time and I have to do that (1<<10) times...

Or maybe some of the VM trouble I read about recntly would also cover my problems?

Thanks,

Signature · 9 lines
Bernd Harries

[email protected]            http://bharries.freeyellow.com
[email protected]       Tel. +49 421 809 7343 priv.  | MSB First!
[email protected]       +49 421 457 3966 offi.  | Linux-m68k
[email protected]       +49 172 139 6054 handy  | Medusa T40

GMX - Die Kommunikationsplattform im Internet.
http://www.gmx.net