Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Specifying a data offset?

DISCUSSION Tregaron Bayly 2 participants 3 messages May 8, 2013 MD RAID

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

We have lots of mirrors all over our network and over time this means arrays created by different versions of mdadm. In turn this means that we have all sorts of data offsets, including a 2.3.5 mdadm version that offset the data 262,144 sectors. I can't fathom why I need my data to start 128M from the beginning of the disk, but whatever.

Inevitably an admin decided that doing a --create over the top of an existing array was a good and necessary thing and when finished we couldn't find the filesystem. Bringing it back online was simply a case of finding the correct offset, locating an mdadm version that would specify it properly and doing another create. Through the whole exercise I found myself wondering why there isn't a command line argument to specify the data offset if something other than the default is desired. I think that implementing the argument and reading the value in init_super wouldn't be terribly difficult so I must be missing an obvious reason. Can someone explain to me why this feature isn't desirable?

Thanks,

Tregaron

#1 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · Tregaron Bayly

We have lots of mirrors all over our network and over time this means arrays created by different versions of mdadm. In turn this means that we have all sorts of data offsets, including a 2.3.5 mdadm version that offset the data 262,144 sectors. I can't fathom why I need my data to start 128M from the beginning of the disk, but whatever.

Quoted 11 lines

Inevitably an admin decided that doing a --create over the top of an existing array was a good and necessary thing and when finished we couldn't find the filesystem. Bringing it back online was simply a case of finding the correct offset, locating an mdadm version that would specify it properly and doing another create. Through the whole exercise I found myself wondering why there isn't a command line argument to specify the data offset if something other than the default is desired. I think that implementing the argument and reading the value in init_super wouldn't be terribly difficult so I must be missing an obvious reason. Can someone explain to me why this feature isn't desirable?

This desirable and has been implemented. Check out the development version of mdadm and look at the "--data-offset" option.

It does not exist in a released version yet, but it has been cooking since October.

Phil

#2 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Phil Turmel

This desirable and has been implemented. Check out the development version of mdadm and look at the "--data-offset" option.

It does not exist in a released version yet, but it has been cooking since October.

Ah, very nice. Thanks!