Skip to contentSkip to conversation

jitterentropy init test failure on ARMv7 with gcc 6.2

DISCUSSION Octavian Purdila 2 participants 2 messages May 10, 2017 – May 11, 2017

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi Stephan,

Recently I started seeing the following on some of our ARMv7 boards (IMX7D):

jitterentropy: Initialization failed with host not compliant with
requirements: 2

and I traced this to the followin init test:

	lowdelta = time2 - time;
	if (!(lowdelta % 100))
		count_mod++;
	...

        /*
         * Ensure that we have variations in the time stamp below 10
 * for at least 10% of all checks -- on some platforms, the
 * counter increments in multiples of 100, but not always.
         */

	if ((TESTLOOPCOUNT/10 * 9) < count_mod)
		return JENT_ECOARSETIME;

Digging deeper, I've noticed that the delta between the timestamp is almost always constant. With the gcc 4.9 it is 102 but with gcc 6.2 it is 100 and this is the reason the above test fails.

Running a tight loop and measuring the delta in between shows that the timestamp counter increments with a fairly low value of 7 (it looks like random_get_entropy() is used and that it is defined to get_cycles()).

So the reason is not that the counter increments in multiples of 100, but that the time to run jent_fold_time() is constant during the initialization tests. Further analyzing it, it looks like jent_fold_time() is called with a constant loop count of 1 which would explain why the delta is constant.

At this point, I am not sure that the test above is correct. Am I missing something?

Thanks,
Tavi

#1 lore raw

Am Mittwoch, 10. Mai 2017, 17:40:40 CEST schrieb Octavian Purdila:

Hi Octavian,

Quoted 31 lines

Hi Stephan,

Recently I started seeing the following on some of our ARMv7 boards (IMX7D):

jitterentropy: Initialization failed with host not compliant with
requirements: 2

and I traced this to the followin init test:

	lowdelta = time2 - time;
	if (!(lowdelta % 100))
		count_mod++;
	...
        /*
         * Ensure that we have variations in the time stamp below 10
	 * for at least 10% of all checks -- on some platforms, the
	 * counter increments in multiples of 100, but not always.
         */
	if ((TESTLOOPCOUNT/10 * 9) < count_mod)
		return JENT_ECOARSETIME;

Digging deeper, I've noticed that the delta between the timestamp is almost always constant. With the gcc 4.9 it is 102 but with gcc 6.2 it is 100 and this is the reason the above test fails.

Running a tight loop and measuring the delta in between shows that the timestamp counter increments with a fairly low value of 7 (it looks like random_get_entropy() is used and that it is defined to get_cycles()).

Quoted 8 lines

So the reason is not that the counter increments in multiples of 100, but that the time to run jent_fold_time() is constant during the initialization tests. Further analyzing it, it looks like jent_fold_time() is called with a constant loop count of 1 which would explain why the delta is constant.

At this point, I am not sure that the test above is correct. Am I missing something?

Based on your description, the above test is very much correct. The inital self test code determined that the timer is too coarse to be used for the RNG. Thus, the RNG will not produce enough or any entropy on this hardware. This ultimately means that the RNG shall not be used. With the indicated error, the RNG is not allocated and thus not usable on your system.

Ciao
Stephan