Skip to contentSkip to conversation

why "PREFERRED_PROVIDER_udev" and not "PREFERRED_PROVIDER_virtual/udev"?

OE-core Robert P. J. Day 1 participant 1 message Aug 30, 2021 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore
#1 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive
Quoted 6 lines · Robert P. J. Day

i was going to extend section 3.3.17, "Using Virtual Providers",
with an intro example using "udev" until i realized that that example doesn't use the "virtual/" notation. so ... why not? is there some distinction between other components that use the "virtual/" prefix, but a reason that one does not specify:

Quoted 8 lines

PROVIDES = "virtual/udev"

rather than just:

PROVIDES = "udev"

and then use the corresponding PREFERRED_PROVIDER_virtual/udev notation?

just to make sure folks understand what i'm getting at, the section:

https://docs.yoctoproject.org/dev-manual/common-tasks.html#using-virtual-providers

opens with, "Prior to a build, if you know that several different recipes provide the same functionality, you can use a virtual provider (i.e. virtual/*) as a placeholder for the actual provider."

except there are cases where several different recipes provide the
same functionality that *don't* incorporate the "virtual/" notation, so which ones merit that and which ones don't? (i mentioned "udev" being provided by both "eudev" and "systemd", for which i wrote an utterly brilliant explanation that i now realize isn't appropriate for that section.)

in the simpler cases, you have recipes that have a new name that
can now be used in place of the old, such that "stress-ng" provides "stress", so you don't have to mess with all your old images and packagegroups. and in situations like that, the "virtual/" notation would seem out of place.

OTOH, well, virtual "kernel" and "bootloader" makes perfect sense as
they represent a more abstract idea. so ... thoughts? even though "udev" does not use the "virtual/" notation, would it still fall under the category of "virtual provider"? if not, how would one describe it?

rday