ck vs. cfs : realtime audio performance
Hello Carlo.
The ranters! comment:
I can understand your way of looking at things.
But you'd better be a bit more careful with statements like these below, if you don't really know what's going on.
Just FYI: All possible traces - Ingo asked for - are on Ingos desk!
My intention is to support you folks as good as I can to get the issues solved.
As a user, with a rather limited knowledge about ck or cfs, I am just able to judge on the results these patches are delivering.
I'll go always for the one - if I have a choice - matching my requirements!
Since there is just one patch left in the near future, at least the way it looks to me today, I am trying of course to support Ingo the best I can to identify potential issues.
Constructive critism - always welcome!
Best regards
\Klaus
Quoted 35 lines
-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: Carlo Florendo <[email protected]>
Gesendet: 02.08.07 08:27:01
An: Lenar Lõhmus <[email protected]>
CC: Klaus Schulz <[email protected]>, [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Betreff: Re: ck vs. cfs : realtime audio performanceQuoted 15 lines · Lenar Lõhmus
Quoted 6 lines · Klaus Schulz
Quoted 6 lines
I am currently testing the 2.6.22.1 cfs-rt9 vs. ck1 on my rather pure realtime high-end-audio setup. (NO X, just a terminal, streaming .wav. I am using my own written player and brutefir as the audio engine.)
Comment: This is not a standard (amarok or xmms setup), all buffers in the chain are very small. Any problem will immidetialy end up in xruns.Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines
The sounddriver, HW (pci-bus etc.) are tweaked accordingly Until now ck1 on 2.6.22 is giving me better results (less audible distortions) and runs extremely stable compared to cfs. Under ck I ran my player with schedtool -R -p 98, which was better than running it e.g. with nice -20 Both setups under cfs were giving me worse results than ck.
With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened with ck.See, this is exactly the problem of the SD ranters. A ranter posts a problem, doesn't give reproducability hints, and neither provides technical detail, not even the slightest relevant stats. And the most irritating part is that the code that the OP wrote (or at least its relevant parts) is not even available for download.
I was wondering why the OP need timers for audio playback. What type of audio? PCM, MIDI? Once does not need timers for PCM playback but for MIDI.
Quoted 38 lines
SD ranters. Pure rants.
Thank you very much.
Best Regards,
Carlo
Signature · 27 lines
Carlo Florendo Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator Astra Philippines Inc. UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman 1101 Quezon City, Philippines http://www.astra.ph -- The Astra Group of Companies 5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City Tokyo 206-0011, Japan http://www.astra.co.jp -- Carlo Florendo Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator Astra Philippines Inc. UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman 1101 Quezon City, Philippines http://www.astra.ph -- The Astra Group of Companies 5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City Tokyo 206-0011, Japan http://www.astra.co.jp
_______________________________________________________________________
Jetzt neu! Schützen Sie Ihren PC mit McAfee und WEB.DE. 3 Monate kostenlos testen. http://www.pc-sicherheit.web.de/startseite/?mc=022220
Quoted 8 lines · Klaus Schulz
Hello Carlo.
The ranters! comment:
I can understand your way of looking at things.
But you'd better be a bit more careful with statements like these below, if you don't really know what's going on.Just FYI: All possible traces - Ingo asked for - are on Ingos desk!
Then that's very good :) I was just wondering on what possibly happened to the problem since the person who forwarded your concern from the ck list to the lkml (I don't subscribe to the ck list) didn't have a follow-up after a few days.
And as far as the public list archives are concerned, there were no stats posted as Ingo had asked for. It seems though that you had done privately, then that's very good.
Since your problem had already been posted online, I thought that any person who might've had a similar problem like yours would benefit from knowing what steps got undertaken to address the problem. I particularly was interested in your problem since I myself do a lot of music in Linux. I'm very sure that if your problem got discussed on-line, many linux-user musicians/programmers would benefit from it, like myself.
Sorry if I have offended you and please accept my apologies.
Thank you very much.
Best Regards,
Carlo
Signature · 12 lines
Carlo Florendo Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator Astra Philippines Inc. UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman 1101 Quezon City, Philippines http://www.astra.ph -- The Astra Group of Companies 5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City Tokyo 206-0011, Japan http://www.astra.co.jp
Stripped CC list restored.
Am Donnerstag 02 August 2007 schrieb Will:
Quoted 39 lines
Quoted 39 lines
Quoted 39 lines
-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: Carlo Florendo <[email protected]>
Gesendet: 02.08.07 08:27:01
An: Lenar Lõhmus <[email protected]>
CC: Klaus Schulz <[email protected]>, [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Betreff: Re: ck vs. cfs : realtime audio performanceQuoted 15 lines · Lenar Lõhmus
Quoted 6 lines · Klaus Schulz
Quoted 6 lines
I am currently testing the 2.6.22.1 cfs-rt9 vs. ck1 on my rather pure realtime high-end-audio setup. (NO X, just a terminal, streaming .wav. I am using my own written player and brutefir as the audio engine.)
Comment: This is not a standard (amarok or xmms setup), all buffers in the chain are very small. Any problem willQuoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines
immidetialy end up in xruns. The sounddriver, HW (pci-bus etc.) are tweaked accordingly Until now ck1 on 2.6.22 is giving me better results (less audible distortions) and runs extremely stable compared to cfs. Under ck I ran my player with schedtool -R -p 98, which was better than running it e.g. with nice -20 Both setups under cfs were giving me worse results than ck. With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened with ck.
See, this is exactly the problem of the SD ranters. A ranter posts a problem, doesn't give reproducability hints, and neither provides technical detail, not even the slightest relevant stats. And the most irritating part is that the code that the OP wrote (or at least its relevant parts) is not even available for download.
I was wondering why the OP need timers for audio playback. What type of audio? PCM, MIDI? Once does not need timers for PCM playback but for MIDI.
SD ranters. Pure rants.
Thank you very much.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Best Regards,
Carlo
I just think it's funny that there's a group of "SD Ranters", and that they have a problem, or cause a problem, or both. And someone has been sitting around trying to figure just what the problem is with these "SD Ranters".
And I just think this is getting more and more ridiculous.
If Klaus writes he has given Ingo all debug information Ingo requested, I have no reason to believe otherwise until Ingo says he did not receive the information. And before it is clear that this information has not been given, I would not assume this. And if its not in the public post by no way this means they have not been given to the person(s) in charge to fix that potential problem.
I am really upset, cause its actually quite some of those "SD ranters" that actually helped Ingo to get CFS to match the experience that SD gave to them. And it didn't match it initially. (It now seems to do here and thats fine of course.)
Well I think I will just continue to send Ingo pointers to things that look like regression reports *privately*. Cause that avoids the "rants against anyone who looks remotely like someone who likes SD" quite effectively.
The tone I see on responses to posts that are CCed to LKML in my perception often is just completely and utterly awfully unfriendly. And often those responses actual include factual inaccuracies and preliminary assumptions as well. Is that how Linux Kernel Management Style is supposed to work? I hope not. Once in a while IMHO it makes a lot of sense to learn at least some of the basics about how communication works! Cause otherwise you get what happens here.
I do not know how Klaus feels now, but I wouldn't be surprised when he was fed up by getting this back when actually he tries to help debugging a potential problem - likely in this free and unpaid time. What would have been if Klaus did not write that he used SD? I think he would have been treated quite differently then.
So now to me it seems LKML people begin to scare away people who actually help debugging CFS just cause they like SD as well - as if scaring away Con was not enough. When I see this I more and more understand Con's decision to stay away from anything that even remotely has something to do with Linux Kernel development.
If people just started to say they are angry, cause ... instead of accusing one another that would be a good start. What Carlo has said could have been said as well like this:
"Hi Klaus!
I did not found any information on how to reproduce the problem in your post. I am quite upset about this, cause I think people who like SD often do not provide good informations on how to reproduce a problem with SD.
Could you please provide these informations?
What audio settings do you use? ...
Thanks.
Regards,
Carlos"
That in my perception would transport exactly the same facts, but it would have a completely different impact on the people involved. It would encourage involvement instead of scaring it away. It even would not be longer than the original post by Carlo.
Tthats in no way meant against you, Carlo, everyone - including myself - can learn to communicate in that way. I try to do it, but with differing success. Its not easy to stay with myself when I am upset, cause then I have to feel my emotions in me instead of venting them off at the cost of other people.
(Actually I want to stay away from this discussion at the moment, but I am really upset when I see such kind of communication in threads where people are working on *solving* potential problems.)
Regards,
Signature · 2 lines
Martin 'Helios' Steigerwald - http://www.Lichtvoll.de GPG: 03B0 0D6C 0040 0710 4AFA B82F 991B EAAC A599 84C7
Am Donnerstag 02 August 2007 schrieb Martin Steigerwald:
Quoted 5 lines
The tone I see on responses to posts that are CCed to LKML in my perception often is just completely and utterly awfully unfriendly. And often those responses actual include factual inaccuracies and preliminary assumptions as well. Is that how Linux Kernel Management Style is supposed to work? I hope not. [...]
Well, if Carlo is not a Linux Kernel manager this comment of mine is inapprobiate. Sorry for that.
Actually when I remind myself of all the responses I got from Ingo I did not see anything like that what I have complained about here. I take that as something where I can learn something: Not nearly every Linux Kernel manager is a mean and unfriendly bastard who accuses everyone who wants something merged or has a problem report. ;) (At least Ingo did not accuse me for my problem reports. If I ever happen to dig that deeply into the kernel or its documentation that I have something to merge regarding the scheduler, I can try how he reacts to that...)
Signature · 2 lines
Martin 'Helios' Steigerwald - http://www.Lichtvoll.de GPG: 03B0 0D6C 0040 0710 4AFA B82F 991B EAAC A599 84C7
Quoted 9 lines · Martin Steigerwald
Am Donnerstag 02 August 2007 schrieb Martin Steigerwald:
Quoted 5 lines
The tone I see on responses to posts that are CCed to LKML in my perception often is just completely and utterly awfully unfriendly. And often those responses actual include factual inaccuracies and preliminary assumptions as well. Is that how Linux Kernel Management Style is supposed to work? I hope not. [...]
Well, if Carlo is not a Linux Kernel manager this comment of mine is inapprobiate. Sorry for that.
I am not a kernel manager, just a simple Linux user.
I'm very very sorry if I have hurt anyone in this thread.
Thank you very much.
Best Regards.
Carlo
Signature · 12 lines
Carlo Florendo Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator Astra Philippines Inc. UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman 1101 Quezon City, Philippines http://www.astra.ph -- The Astra Group of Companies 5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City Tokyo 206-0011, Japan http://www.astra.co.jp