Skip to contentSkip to conversation

David Miller is on the list

DISCUSSION Mike McDonald 13 participants 19 messages Apr 23, 1996 – Jun 3, 1997 3 messages not in the archive MIPS

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

A dumb question, what exactly is the purpose of porting Linux to
SGI/Mips boxes? At one time, it was proposed as a way that all of the people how just got dropped from support to maintain there machine's usefull life. Now, people are talking about embedding linux in printers and Nintendo boxes! Or as an alternative to Irix on our current machines. Personally, I think the port should concentrate on R3K boxes with/without graphics. (It'd be nice if we could release the info so that X11R6 could be built on the old boxes.) The port should be a 32 bit port. (Does gcc even support 64 bit MIPS 27 ISA?) It also be nice if the R3K port would also work on the R4K machines that are fading away, ie. Indy's, Indigo2's.

Mike McDonald
[email protected]

#1 lore raw
Quoted 13 lines · Mike McDonald

A dumb question, what exactly is the purpose of porting Linux to
SGI/Mips boxes? At one time, it was proposed as a way that all of the people how just got dropped from support to maintain there machine's usefull life. Now, people are talking about embedding linux in printers and Nintendo boxes! Or as an alternative to Irix on our current machines. Personally, I think the port should concentrate on R3K boxes with/without graphics. (It'd be nice if we could release the info so that X11R6 could be built on the old boxes.) The port should be a 32 bit port. (Does gcc even support 64 bit MIPS 27 ISA?) It also be nice if the R3K port would also work on the R4K machines that are fading away, ie. Indy's, Indigo2's.

Different people have different motivations, and you have heard
some of them. My main interest is in two parts. First, on current-production low-end workstations, I would like to compare linux performance to IRIX performance. If linux is much better on most measures, in ways which matter to end users, then we would need to consider it as a choice for low-end systems. If it is better only in some dimensions, then we can use it as an existence proof that there are ways to improve IRIX in those dimensions. It is hard to compare software running on different hardware, but software running on identical hardware is directly comparable.

Second, I believe that UNIX-based systems are gratuitously incompatible,
compared to NT, and that this is an impediment to competing against NT in low-end servers and workstations. Since most efforts to standardize interfaces and administration for UNIX systems have been very slow and incomplete, due to conflicting interests of the vendors involved, I would like to try using linux as a vehicle for creating a de facto standard. Where appropriate, we should give away some enabling technology, such as Web-based administration scripts. We really compete on application performance. Trying compete in areas such as administrative commands, which are peripheral to the user's main interests, is, on balance, almost certainly counterproductive. This will be even more the case as we begin selling into larger installations (with a large number of units, not the odd one or two systems we often sell at present).

linux for older boxes is a fine thing, and not unduly difficult
to do, at least on the workstations, but there are a lot more R4000-and-better boxes out there now. As for embedded systems, there are actually pretty decent real time systems, some with POSIX compliance, which support MIPS processors. I doubt that the success of MIPS processors in embedded systems is much limited by software availability.

#2 lore raw

What target (was David ...)

In reply to Mike McDonald

Mike asked (not a dumb Q, BTW):

Quoted 4 lines

A dumb question, what exactly is the purpose of porting Linux to
SGI/Mips boxes?

Looks like there are many opinions. I don't care as long as we manage to do this port. Whatever we port it to (and the wider the port is) SGI is going to benefit tremendously. You may read my Linux pages (http://info.engr/~ariel/linux) to understand why my personal conviction (and others) is so strong.

Some of the nice things about Linux are:

1) It can work from RAM (virtual disk), So it follows that it is easily ROMable and embeddable (much more so than IRIX)

I have developed embedded apps for several years in my past and I can tell you that my life would have been infinitely easier had I been able to develop in a Linux env. Only the thought of having the same env on the host and the target is revolutionary by itself (and possible!)

2) It has a small footprint so naturally it is a good candidate for embedded market.

3) It has a common single source code for 32-bit and 64-bit machines (Alpha). So we shouldn't think of this as an "either/or" proposition.

P.S.
gcc doesn't have support for 64 bit MIPS 27 ISA, I guess, but nobody is stopping us from using our compilers (as well as gcc at our convenience).

Signature · 1 line
Peace, Ariel
#3 lore raw

Re: What target (was David ...)

Quoted 6 lines

From: ariel@yon (Ariel Faigon)
Subject: What target (was David ...)
To: linux@yon
Date: Tue, 23 Apr 1996 13:26:53 -0700 (PDT)

Quoted 6 lines

P.S.
gcc doesn't have support for 64 bit MIPS 27 ISA, I guess, but nobody is stopping us from using our compilers (as well as gcc at our convenience).

Signature · 1 line
Peace, Ariel

I strongly believe that using our compilers would be a "bad" thing
for the initial port. Requiring someone to buy IDO inorder to compile a free OS seems like the "wrong" thing to me. Now, if we (SGI) decide to ship a Linux version, then yes, using our compilers is OK. Let's just make sure that the port is dependant on our compilers in any way at this point. (I doubt that's what you were suggesting. I just want to make it clear before we get started.)

Mike McDonald
[email protected]

#4 lore raw

Re: What target (was David ...)

Quoted 8 lines

Mike dijo:

Quoted 6 lines

yo dijo:

P.S.
gcc doesn't have support for 64 bit MIPS 27 ISA, I guess, but nobody is stopping us from using our compilers (as well as gcc at our convenience).

Quoted 9 lines

I strongly believe that using our compilers would be a "bad" thing
for the initial port. Requiring someone to buy IDO inorder to compile a free OS seems like the "wrong" thing to me. Now, if we (SGI) decide to ship a Linux version, then yes, using our compilers is OK. Let's just make sure that the port is dependant on our compilers in any way at this point. (I doubt that's what you were suggesting. I just want to make it clear before we get started.)

Bob and I are working separately on making our compilers (actually only the C one, not Ada :-) be bundled with Irix (and possibly licence enabled for a nominal fee, which can be done automatically without human intervention -- surprisingly this may increase revenues because the cost of handling goes to zero and the potential upside due to lowering barriers is large). I think we have a very good chance of acheiving this as soon as our upcoming big software release.

Also, I agree, we should make sure that whatever we do is buildable by gcc. And we should also be paying Cygnus to do a real supported full port (including ld), but this is harder to achieve (need $$$ from management) at this point. However, after we have Linux and it takes off, everything related to free software would be possible :-)

Signature · 1 line
Peace, Ariel
#6 lore raw

Re: What target (was David ...)

In reply to a message not in the archive

I'm pleased that we are getting a Linux port started and that there is an incredible degree of interest and enthusiasm. This is independent of which hardware configurations will or should be supported. I see good reasons for doing all of them.

I hope that the
self-selected "steering committee" will generate some consensus tomorrow as to priorities. If there is no consensus, then Larry McVoy and I will make an "executive decision" based on available hardware resources and a shortest-path approach to getting a first port.

greg

#13 lore raw

NIS rarpd entries (fwd)

Demetrio,

Will it be possible to add an ethers entry for stacey.engr to our ypmaps ? Thanks!

If yes, David, could you send Demetrio the ethernet address ?

----- Forwarded message from David S. Miller -----

From owner-linux@cthulhu Sat Jun 29 00:07:01 1996
Date: Sat, 29 Jun 1996 00:07:52 -0700
Message-Id: <[email protected]>
From: "David S. Miller" <dm@neteng>
To: linux@neteng
Subject: NIS rarpd entries
Reply-to: [email protected]
Sender: owner-linux@cthulhu
Precedence: bulk

When I'm booting my test box I have to run a bogus hacked up copy of rarpd because the NIS maps in my domain don't have an ethers entry for stacey.engr

What is a better way of dealing with this?

Later,
David S. Miller
[email protected]

----- End of forwarded message from David S. Miller -----

Signature · 1 line
Peace, Ariel
#14 lore raw

Re: NIS rarpd entries (fwd)

From: ariel@yon (Ariel Faigon)
Date: Sat, 29 Jun 1996 18:26:23 -0700 (PDT)

Will it be possible to add an ethers entry for stacey.engr to our ypmaps ? Thanks!

If yes, David, could you send Demetrio the ethernet address ?

8:0:69:8:8a:18 stacey.engr.sgi.com

Later,
David S. Miller
[email protected]

#8 lore raw

Re: NIS rarpd entries (fwd)

In reply to a message not in the archive

Ariel,
David,

Quoted 5 lines · Ariel Faigon

Subject: NIS rarpd entries (fwd)
Demetrio,

Will it be possible to add an ethers entry for stacey.engr to our ypmaps ?

stacey is ALREADY in the YP hosts maps

	demi 39# ypmatch stacey.engr hosts
	150.166.75.5    stacey.engr.sgi.com
	demi 40#

(BTW, 150.166.75 is one of the NetWork Group nets.)

Quoted 18 lines

Thanks!

If yes, David, could you send Demetrio the ethernet address ?

----- Forwarded message from David S. Miller -----

Quoted 1 line

From owner-linux@cthulhu Sat Jun 29 00:07:01 1996

Date: Sat, 29 Jun 1996 00:07:52 -0700
Message-Id: <[email protected]>
From: "David S. Miller" <dm@neteng>
To: linux@neteng
Subject: NIS rarpd entries
Reply-to: [email protected]
Sender: owner-linux@cthulhu
Precedence: bulk

Quoted 3 lines

When I'm booting my test box I have to run a bogus hacked up copy of rarpd because the NIS maps in my domain don't have an ethers entry for stacey.engr

This is from your system

	tanya 2% ypmatch stacey hosts
	150.166.75.5    stacey.engr.sgi.com stacey
	tanya 3%

Demetrio

Quoted 12 lines

What is a better way of dealing with this?

Later,
David S. Miller
[email protected]

----- End of forwarded message from David S. Miller -----

--
Peace, Ariel
-- End of excerpt from Ariel Faigon

#16 lore raw

Re: NIS rarpd entries (fwd)

In reply to a message not in the archive

David,

Added

	cthulhu 22% grep stacey ethers
	8:0:69:8:8a:18          stacey
	cthulhu 23%

Give it about 15 vminutes to propagate.
Demetrio

PS Please disregard my previous mail. I am not complety awake.

Quoted 15 lines · David S. Miller

Subject: Re: NIS rarpd entries (fwd)
From: ariel@yon (Ariel Faigon)
Date: Sat, 29 Jun 1996 18:26:23 -0700 (PDT)

Will it be possible to add an ethers entry for stacey.engr to our ypmaps ? Thanks!

If yes, David, could you send Demetrio the ethernet address ?

8:0:69:8:8a:18 stacey.engr.sgi.com

Later,
David S. Miller
[email protected]
-- End of excerpt from David S. Miller

#17 lore raw

Name the external domain

Hi Linuxies,

Next Wednesday we are finally going to have our external linux machine online. As it turns out the networking gurus (vernon) require us to use a third level domain for very good reasons, so we cannot call the machine "linux.sgi.com".

We want a domain name that's cool, friendly to outside people, entertaining, that doesn't sound too official and that's scalable" (general enough to put more "share with the world" hostnames under it in the future.

I hate to start a long thread but this name will last for many years so I cannot have my fascist opinion rule here. Here's what people suggested so far:

	[linux.] outside.sgi.com
	[linux.] unchained.sgi.com
	[linux.] untied.sgi.com
	[linux.] at.sgi.com
	[linux.] friends.sgi.com

Lets have some more suggestions and then vote on this. We need to give Vernon a name soon.

Signature · 1 line
Peace, Ariel
#18 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

Thus spake Ariel Faigon:

Quoted 1 line
	[linux.] at.sgi.com

I don't like this one very much, if only because it's hard to explain verbally. ('at' vs. '@', etc.)

.unchained.sgi.com isn't bad, although I understand that we might be able to get some funding from Marketing if we used .cosmo.sgi.com. =)

Mike

Signature · 6 lines
#> Mike Shaver ([email protected]) Ingenia Communications Corporation 
#>                   Welcome to the technocracy.
#>                                                                     
#> "you'd be so disappointed
#>              to find out that the magic was not
#>                          really meant for you" - OLP
#21 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

In reply to Ariel Faigon

brft.sgi.com (ie. Big Red FireTruck)

---------------------------------------------////
Yow! 11.26 MB/s remote host TCP bandwidth & ////
199 usec remote TCP latency over 100Mb/s ////
ethernet. Beat that! ////
-----------------------------------------////__________ o David S. Miller, [email protected] /_____________/ / // /_/ ><

#9 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

In reply to a message not in the archive

* $ from ariel@yon at "30-May: 3:32pm" | sed "1,$s/^/* /" *
*
* Hi Linuxies,
*

I like....

* [linux.] friends.sgi.com

Or alternativley

coffeehouse.sgi.com [probably too long]
beach.sgi.com

[fill in the appropriate location where you hang out with your friends]

*
* Lets have some more suggestions and then vote on this.
* We need to give Vernon a name soon.
* --
* Peace, Ariel
*

richard.

________________________________________________________________________
Seen on uk.singles

Modula 2 is like a locked door in the middle of a field.
Charles Bryant

#10 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

Given that what Vernon is looking for is a domain for those hosts that are
outside of the firewall
(yet inside of the packet filter)
that dont provide well known service names
(www.sgi.com, ftp.sgi.com)

I was thought of the strip of land around a castle that is between the
outer wall and the moat. According to the "Castles on the web glossary"
http://fox.nstn.ca/~tmonk/castle/glossary.html this strip of land is called the berm.

/Bob... mailto:[email protected]
http://reality.sgi.com/mende/ KF6EID

#19 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

In reply to Mike Shaver
Quoted 10 lines · Mike Shaver

Thus spake Ariel Faigon:

Quoted 1 line
      [linux.] at.sgi.com

I don't like this one very much, if only because it's hard to explain verbally. ('at' vs. '@', etc.)

.unchained.sgi.com isn't bad, although I understand that we might be able to get some funding from Marketing if we used .cosmo.sgi.com. =)

Unlikely, unless you mean the compression guys :-( The Cosmo
types have already been assimilated by the dark force.

What is wrong with calling the external domain "linux.sgi.com"
and then find a cool host name (like "penguin")?

Martin

Signature · 11 lines
Check out the DevForum 97  !!!! (http://www.sgi.com/Forum97/)
  If you miss it, you'll never forgive yourself. Neither will I :-)
+---------------------------------+-----------------------------------+
|Martin Knoblauch                 | Silicon Graphics GmbH             |
|Manager Technical Marketing      | Am Hochacker 3 - Technopark       |
|Silicon Graphics Computer Systems| D-85630 Grasbrunn-Neukeferloh, FRG|
|---------------------------------| Phone: (+int) 89 46108-179 or -0  |
|http://reality.sgi.com/knobi     | Fax:   (+int) 89 46107-179        |
+---------------------------------+-----------------------------------+
|e-mail: <[email protected]>   | VM: 6-333-8197 | M/S: IDE-3150    |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------+
#12 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

In reply to a message not in the archive
Quoted 8 lines · Bob Mende Pie

Subject: Re: Name the external domain

Given that what Vernon is looking for is a domain for those hosts that are
outside of the firewall
(yet inside of the packet filter)
that dont provide well known service names
(www.sgi.com, ftp.sgi.com)

Quoted 8 lines

I was thought of the strip of land around a castle that is between the
outer wall and the moat. According to the "Castles on the web glossary"
http://fox.nstn.ca/~tmonk/castle/glossary.html this strip of land is called the berm.

/Bob... mailto:[email protected]
http://reality.sgi.com/mende/ KF6EID
-- End of excerpt from Bob Mende Pie

This is my favorite!

Signature · 11 lines
		Chris Carlson

	+------------------------------------------------------+
	| Also, [email protected]                                |
	|   Work:       (714) 756-5976     SGI vmail: 678-4530 |
	|   FAX:        (714) 833-9503                         |
	|                                                      |
	| Trivia fact: an electroencephalogram shows that a    |
	| human brain and a bowl of quivering lime Jell-O have |
	| the same waves.  [Time Magazine, Mar 17, 1997]       |
	+------------------------------------------------------+
#20 lore raw

Re: Name the external domain

In reply to Martin Knoblauch
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line

"Martin" == Martin Knoblauch <[email protected]> writes:

Martin> [snip]

Martin> What is wrong with calling the external domain Martin> "linux.sgi.com" and then find a cool host name (like Martin> "penguin")?

Even better, call the domain "penguin.sgi.com" and then have machines like "linux.penguin.sgi.com" ... Friendly enough for me :)

-- Raju
--
Raj Mathur / Web Technical Support / Silicon Graphics / New Delhi
+91-11-6216324/25, 6211354/55 / [email protected] / 7228
http://reality.sgi.com/raju / It is the Mind that Moves
PGP: F2 D4 4A 21 27 B0 63 FF | Not necessarily speaking
15 97 9D AE 9D 40 BC B8 | for Silicon Graphics