Actual status of LVM in stock kernel
Hi all,
just wanted to give you the actual status of the LVM driver on its long long way into the stock kernel.
Dirk Hohndel (THX Dirk!) supported me by talking to Linus in person about 5 weeks ago. He convinced Linus to be open to include the LVM in the stock kernel (good idea(tm)) and asked me to send a patch for 2.3.x directly to Linus.
I did but didn't get any answer from Linux within a couple of days.
So i had to ask for Dirk's help again.
He told me to resend the patch to Linus.
I did but didn't .......... 8*(((
Dirk will talk to Linus again in person next week.
Somebody out there to help me stay optimistic?
Kind regards,
Heinz
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 41
64205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 16 lines · Heinz Mauelshagen
Hi all,
just wanted to give you the actual status of the LVM driver on its long long way into the stock kernel.
Dirk Hohndel (THX Dirk!) supported me by talking to Linus in person about 5 weeks ago. He convinced Linus to be open to include the LVM in the stock kernel (good idea(tm)) and asked me to send a patch for 2.3.x directly to Linus.
I did but didn't get any answer from Linux within a couple of days.
So i had to ask for Dirk's help again.
Quoted 8 lines
He told me to resend the patch to Linus.
I did but didn't .......... 8*(((
Dirk will talk to Linus again in person next week.
Somebody out there to help me stay optimistic?
There's always the alternative way. Let's het SuSE hot for it. They do patch their (stable) kernels with all the latest stuff. It would create some (extra) momentum.
Best way is to keep developping, and keep releasing. ;)
Best regards,
Pascal
*who still thinks, LVM is the best thing happened to Linux for
the past 2 years*
Quoted 17 lines
Kind regards,
Heinz--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 4164205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 2 lines · [email protected] wrote:
There's always the alternative way. Let's het SuSE hot for it. They do patch their (stable) kernels with all the latest stuff.
What about Debian?
Someone mentioned having made a .deb outa LVM-tools... Where can I get it?
Im too new to LVM topics and have only done some little experiments with a second LVMified hd in my system but failed to get a root LVM to boot...
...so for now my knowledge is far too less to do what I suggest:
...to extend the LVM-howto. Describing benefits of LVM clearly and having distribution specific instructions how to get a (near to) perfect LVMified system running and spreading this HOWTO would be a way to push LVM...
...maybe some articles in Linux-Magazin, C'T and nongerman equivalents would be nice too...
As soon as I am fit enough in "LVM on Debian" I am standby to at least proofread and maybe extend the Debian-specific parts...
Bye!
Ulf.
Hi,
[story]
Quoted 3 lines
Somebody out there to help me stay optimistic?
Not hearing something positive does not necessarily mean something negative. Maybe Linus is a bit busy or he's trying LVM right now or ...
Give him some time, Linux is not his full-time job.
And if LVM won't make it into the stock kernel soon - well, you did what you could.
Let distributors include the patch in their distribution is not the worst thing either. BTW: SuSE 6.3 will have it, AFAIK. Correct ?
We now and honor what you did, may it be in the stock kernel or not ... :-)
Bye,
Rolf
PS: Maybe somebody can tell me how to mount a root lv ?
Signature · 2 lines
Rolf Jakob at home ([email protected]) WWW : http://www.franken.de/users/duffy1/rjakob (KDE-Utils and CCS)
Quoted 7 lines
Hi,
[story]
Quoted 3 lines
Somebody out there to help me stay optimistic?
Quoted 8 lines
Not hearing something positive does not necessarily mean something negative. Maybe Linus is a bit busy or he's trying LVM right now or ...
Give him some time, Linux is not his full-time job.
And if LVM won't make it into the stock kernel soon - well, you did what you could.
Let distributors include the patch in their distribution is not the worst thing either. BTW: SuSE 6.3 will have it, AFAIK. Correct ?
Yes, it will.
Quoted 7 lines
We now and honor what you did, may it be in the stock kernel or not ... :-)
Bye,
RolfPS: Maybe somebody can tell me how to mount a root lv ?
Create a small /boot filesystem on a partition (20 Meg is sufficient to make a bootable standalone in case something goes wrong).
Put a kernel, lilo.conf, and a selection of /sbin/*, /bin/*, /lib*.
Create a volume group with root, usr, tmp, var, opt and whatever volume you like containing filesystems and put the corresponding files into these (you need temporary space; at least some megabytes more than the amount to install a basic system)
Use lvmcreate_initrd to create a /boot/initrd.gz file containing everything to mount a LV based root and configure /boot/lilo.conf to boot with this initial ramdisk and run lilo.
Create corresponding entries in your LV base roots /etc/fstab and reboot.
Quoted 4 lines
Signature · 2 lines
Rolf Jakob at home ([email protected]) WWW : http://www.franken.de/users/duffy1/rjakob (KDE-Utils and CCS)
Regards,
Heinz
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 41
64205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 6 lines · Heinz Mauelshagen
Dirk Hohndel (THX Dirk!) supported me by talking to Linus in person about 5 weeks ago. He convinced Linus to be open to include the LVM in the stock kernel (good idea(tm)) and asked me to send a patch for 2.3.x directly to Linus.
I did but didn't get any answer from Linux within a couple of days.
Hi Heinz,
I just wanted to say that I'm still here using the LVM-2.2.11 patch on kernel 2.2.13 without problems. Occasionally I resize an lv and filesystem just for fun! Great feature! Thanks again for what has proven itself to be some pretty solid code!
Regarding getting your LVM into the stock kernel. I think we should try to keep a _little_ pressure on Linus just to let him know we are here (and waiting). I say this because I remember Linus saying that he does tend to give more attention to the folks who make the most noise (eg. the Apache folks). I am not saying we should pester him, just don't let him forget about us. I sent him a few emails back when the petition was being started and I realize that they most likely went unnoticed. I do not have any great ideas about how this should be done, other than you keep sending him patches to the latest dev kernel until he replies one way or the other.
By the way, what 2.3 kernel was the patch that you have sent him against? And are you going to make that patch available on your site?
Shane
Humble Linux and LVM user
Quoted 10 lines · Heinz Mauelshagen
Quoted 6 lines
Dirk Hohndel (THX Dirk!) supported me by talking to Linus in person about 5 weeks ago. He convinced Linus to be open to include the LVM in the stock kernel (good idea(tm)) and asked me to send a patch for 2.3.x directly to Linus.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line
I did but didn't get any answer from Linux within a couple of days.
Hi Heinz,
I just wanted to say that I'm still here using the LVM-2.2.11 patch on kernel 2.2.13 without problems. Occasionally I resize an lv and filesystem just for fun! Great feature! Thanks again for what has proven itself to be some pretty solid code!
THX 8*)
Quoted 8 lines
Regarding getting your LVM into the stock kernel. I think we should try to keep a _little_ pressure on Linus just to let him know we are here (and waiting). I say this because I remember Linus saying that he does tend to give more attention to the folks who make the most noise (eg. the Apache folks). I am not saying we should pester him, just don't let him forget about us. I sent him a few emails back when the petition was being started and I realize that they most likely went unnoticed.
Automatic delete after beeing not read for 2 days 8*(
Quoted 2 lines
I do not have any great
ideas about how this should be done,
Maybe somebody out there has a good idea.
BTW: LVM will be in SuSE 6.3 and that will hopefully help us a lot!
(THX to Volker Wiegand, Dirk Hohndel and others at SuSE)
Quoted 2 lines
other than you keep sending him
patches to the latest dev kernel until he replies one way or the other.
Sure.
Quoted 2 lines
By the way, what 2.3 kernel was the patch that you have sent him against?
2.3.21
Quoted 1 line
And are you going to make that patch available on your site?
Sorry, simply was too busy.
Will provide it soon...
Quoted 4 lines
Shane
Humble Linux and LVM user
Heinz
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 41
64205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 1 line · you
Maybe somebody out there has a good idea.
I don't know about *good*, but perhaps bringing it up in the kernel mailing lists might spurn some interest. I know that Linus & Alan both frequent it, as well as other major players. We may be able to light a spark into someone Linus talks with daily.
Quoted 2 lines
BTW: LVM will be in SuSE 6.3 and that will hopefully help us a lot!
(THX to Volker Wiegand, Dirk Hohndel and others at SuSE)
Heinz, have you heard from anyone at RedHat? With their recent push towards servers as well as their deal with Oracle, LVM seems like it would be a perfect fit, especially if you're looking at breaking into Data Centers.
-Daniel ------------------------------------------ Daniel Whicker ([email protected])
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Whicker
Heinz, have you heard from anyone at RedHat? With their recent push towards servers as well as their deal with Oracle, LVM seems like it would be a perfect fit, especially if you're looking at breaking into Data Centers.
IFAIRC [email protected] signed the (in)famous LVM petition
L.
Signature · 2 lines
Luca Berra -- [email protected] Communications Media & Services S.r.l.
Quoted 7 lines · Daniel Whicker
Quoted 3 lines
Heinz, have you heard from anyone at RedHat? With their recent push towards servers as well as their deal with Oracle, LVM seems like it would be a perfect fit, especially if you're looking at breaking into Data Centers.
IFAIRC [email protected] signed the (in)famous LVM petition
YEP.
Ted T'so, Hans Reiser, Jim Mostek and a lot of other nice guys 8*)
Heinz
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 41
64205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 9 lines · Heinz Mauelshagen
Quoted 7 lines · Daniel Whicker
Quoted 3 lines
Heinz, have you heard from anyone at RedHat? With their recent push towards servers as well as their deal with Oracle, LVM seems like it would be a perfect fit, especially if you're looking at breaking into Data Centers.
IFAIRC [email protected] signed the (in)famous LVM petition
YEP.
I would suggest posting the patch to linux-kernel, cc: it to linus, and ask whether it is too late for 2.4, or if there is something else that needs to be addressed before it is ready. I haven't seen it discussed on lkml, which may well be why linus isn't replying.
Signature · 3 lines
Ryan Murray ([email protected], [email protected]) Software Designer, Glenayre Technologies Inc. The opinions expressed here are my own.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line · you
Maybe somebody out there has a good idea.
I don't know about *good*, but perhaps bringing it up in the kernel mailing lists might spurn some interest. I know that Linus & Alan both frequent it, as well as other major players. We may be able to light a spark into someone Linus talks with daily.
He talks to Dirk Hohndel quite often and Dirk's already in 8*)
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 4 lines
BTW: LVM will be in SuSE 6.3 and that will hopefully help us a lot!
(THX to Volker Wiegand, Dirk Hohndel and others at SuSE)Heinz, have you heard from anyone at RedHat? With their recent push towards servers as well as their deal with Oracle, LVM seems like it would be a perfect fit, especially if you're looking at breaking into Data Centers.
Stephen Tweedie is interested but no other contacts to RedHat or activities from their side so far...
Heinz
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Systemmanagement CS-TS T-Nova
Entwicklungszentrum Darmstadt
Heinz Mauelshagen Otto-Roehm-Strasse 71c
Senior Systems Engineer Postfach 10 05 41
64205 Darmstadt [email protected] Germany +49 6151 886-425 FAX-386
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Hi,
Quoted 7 lines · Heinz Mauelshagen
Quoted 4 lines
I don't know about *good*, but perhaps bringing it up in the kernel mailing lists might spurn some interest. I know that Linus & Alan both frequent it, as well as other major players. We may be able to light a spark into someone Linus talks with daily.
Stephen Tweedie is interested but no other contacts to RedHat or activities from their side so far...
It's not a matter of support --- it's a matter of somebody taking up the issues with Linus until we find out what the position is. And yes, if he is preoccupied with other stuff, that can take a good deal of persistance. :)
--Stephen
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Daniel" == Daniel Whicker <[email protected]> writes:
I don't know about *good*, but perhaps bringing it up in the kernel mailing lists might spurn some interest. I know that Linus & Alan both frequent it, as well as other major players. We may be able to light a spark into someone Linus talks with daily.
I'd recommend to be very visible:
try to follow kernel releases and for each new release send a post to linux-kernel, linux-fsdevel and to linus pointing to the updated patch.
Stefan