binary modules agaaaain
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 5 lines · Guennadi Liakhovetski
Hello all
I came across an idea, how Linux could allow binary modules, still having reasonable control over them.
Quoted 8 lines
I am not advocating for binary modules, nor I am trying to make their life harder, this is just an idea how it could be done.
I'll try to make it short, details may be discussed later, if any interest arises.
A binary module is "considered good" if
I belive that you forgot to make "The Point."
And "discussion" (good vs. bad isn't discussion, but flames) went in
wrong direction.
Be constructive. For example: Let's aks h/w producers making at least
glue layer open source (bsd or something), so people eventually might help to maintain this glue layer.
How it can help? - producer with time may move bigger parts of driver
into open source domains.
How it can gets screwed? - producer might just start liking when
someone is doing his work for him. Some license a-la GPL to not let glue layer to slip into binary only domain back must be in place.
This could be a good starting point for h/w producers and linux
comunity as a whole.
Saying Good/Bad is just B.S. - helps no-one.
Building bridges between comunity and producers - might improve and
deepen relationships. And that's what I hope for.
P.S. nVidia driver might be an example: IIRC nVidia engineers were saying that they have four 2/3rd party code parts inside driver, which they are not able to open source/GPL. But open source glue layer to connect this "tainted" 4 parts with Linux kernel might help everyone: nVidia, LK and even those four companies. At least I hope for this.
Quoted 9 lines · Ihar 'Philips' Filipau
Quoted 8 lines · Guennadi Liakhovetski
Hello all
I came across an idea, how Linux could allow binary modules, still having reasonable control over them.
I am not advocating for binary modules, nor I am trying to make their life harder, this is just an idea how it could be done.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
I'll try to make it short, details may be discussed later, if any interest arises.
A binary module is "considered good" if
I belive that you forgot to make "The Point."
May be...
Quoted 2 lines
And "discussion" (good vs. bad isn't discussion, but flames) went in
wrong direction.
Very right. Let me try to explain it again. It was just an idea, that popped in my mind. I was not sure if it was good or bad, so, I decided to dump it to lkml, so, that the people here could evaluate it. And, if it can be of any use - use it. I, personally, don't care much (at least at the moment) about binary drivers. And I most of all wanted to avoid starting a new wave of flames. That's why I tried to avoid answering to other posters (sorry, if it was somewhat impolite).
Quoted 9 lines
Be constructive. For example: Let's aks h/w producers making at least
glue layer open source (bsd or something), so people eventually might help to maintain this glue layer.
How it can help? - producer with time may move bigger parts of driver
into open source domains.
How it can gets screwed? - producer might just start liking when
someone is doing his work for him. Some license a-la GPL to not let glue layer to slip into binary only domain back must be in place.
Quoted 6 lines
This could be a good starting point for h/w producers and linux
comunity as a whole.Saying Good/Bad is just
B.S. - helps no-one.
Building bridges between comunity and producers - might improve and
deepen relationships. And that's what I hope for.
Thanks! You seem to have understood the idea pretty close to what I mean, and, probably, you are better capable of explaining things, than I:-) But, I think, if it is going to be discussed further, let's move it away from LKML (you are right, Bart). It can either be discussed in private emails, or, maybe someone could create a dedicated mailing list somewhere.
Thanks
Guennadi
---
Guennadi Liakhovetski