protecting source code in 2.6
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 1 line · In article <[email protected]> Richard B. Johnson wrote:
[ rant on proprietary kernel software removed ]
Quoted 4 lines
There are very few persons who will allow you to insert secret code into their kernels where it could destroy everything of value to them.
If only this were true... but there are how many million Windows users?
Oh, and if they're too stupid to count, there are also large numbers of HP-UX, AIX, Solaris and other proprietary UNIX variants out there, not to mention IBM mainframe and AS/400 shops...
Oh, and if you only mean Linux users, we'll ignore all the ATI Radeon and Nvidea sufferers, and vmware users, and winmodem users, and every driver for a device which loads firmware, and every PC which does not release source code for the BIOS, and . . .
Arguments tend to loose a lot of their impact when based on religion rather than realism.
Signature · 6 lines
Dr. Vincent C. Jones, PE Expert advice and a helping hand Computer Network Consultant for those who want to manage and Networking Unlimited, Inc. control their networking destiny 14 Dogwood Lane, Tenafly, NJ 07670 http://www.networkingunlimited.com [email protected] +1 201 568-7810 Fax: +1 201 568-7269
Quoted 3 lines
Arguments tend to loose a lot of their impact when based on religion rather than realism.
OK, then please, provide us with a strong & valid argument justifying the interest in keeping a driver closed.
Oh, and ATI or nVidia aren't good examples, just grep for the amount of crashes caused by the later for example, look some of the backtraces and see the horror...
Ben.
Quoted 4 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
Quoted 3 lines
Arguments tend to loose a lot of their impact when based on religion rather than realism.
Quoted 8 lines
OK, then please, provide us with a strong & valid argument justifying the interest in keeping a driver closed.
Oh, and ATI or nVidia aren't good examples, just grep for the amount of crashes caused by the later for example, look some of the backtraces and see the horror...
Ben.
OK... Calm down... Take a deep breath... Take another one... Now go back and read the comment I was responding to...
I was not and am not claiming that closed source is a "good thing." Rather, I was merely pointing out that there are huge numbers of people who WILL buy/use closed source, despite its disadvantages, if they think it is the most cost effective way to solve THEIR problem. The lack of quality in nVidia drivers reinforces, rather than negates, my comment. That people will use junk if they feel they have no option (look at the number of Windows ME users out there).
Telling the original poster that he won't sell any hardware if he ships a closed driver is a blatant lie (look at wintel PCs and nVidia graphics cards) and does nothing to promote the cause. It only makes the Linux community look like a bunch of raving idiots who lack the common sense to drive a car less than 20 years old or heat their lunch in a microwave oven (a couple of very common applications which come to mind which are only available with closed software).
I don't know about you, but even when I chose a piece of software to run on my personal computer, what I really care about is whether or not it solves MY problems at a price I can afford (which includes the total cost throughout the life of the projects I base on it). Whether the code I use is open or closed is only one of a wide range of considerations in determining the cost and effectiveness.
Given the choice, I will choose open source over closed, but that was not even a consideration when I abandoned Microsoft years ago, (FWIW, moving to OS/2 for several years until Linux became a viable alternative). Nor was it a consideration when I moved from CP/M to DOS or from DOS to Windows...
But I'm not interested in a flame war or even a prolonged discussion of the merits of open vs. closed software, and would prefer to discourage either. What I would like to see is more thinking before posting to keep discussions on target (solving problems that prevent or delay the support of Linux on the platforms and with the peripherals and applications which I want). Encouraging the original poster to keep his software open is one thing, but assuming he is a blithering idiot because he does not share your ideals is another. Fortunately, there was one, lonely soul who had the common sense to give him a few hints of where to look to find the rules for doing it with minimum damage.
Vince
Signature · 6 lines
Dr. Vincent C. Jones, PE Expert advice and a helping hand Computer Network Consultant for those who want to manage and Networking Unlimited, Inc. control their networking destiny 14 Dogwood Lane, Tenafly, NJ 07670 http://www.networkingunlimited.com [email protected] +1 201 568-7810 Fax: +1 201 568-7269