Skip to contentSkip to conversation

VIA chipset problems with 2.2?

DISCUSSION Michael B. Allen 2 participants 3 messages Feb 15, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello,

What's the nature of the VIA chipset problems? I want to get a new system this weekend but I read on kernel traffic that VIA has problems? I wan't to use Hendrick's ide patches on 2.2.18. What board should I get? Help, I've searched through usenet and asked on #linux without anything conclusive.

Thanks,
Mike

Quoted 1 line

From KT:

David Riley [*] reported tremendous slowdowns in 2.4.1-pre11 and -pre12 on his Athlon 900 with a KT133 chipset. Mark Hahn [*] replied, "this is
known: Linus decreed that, since two people reported disk corruption on VIA, any machine with a VIA southbridge must boot in stupid 1992 mode (PIO). (yes, it might be possible to boot with ide=autodma or something, but who would guess?)" He added to Linus Torvalds [*], "I hope you don't consider this a releasable state! VIA now owns 40% of the chipset market..." Linus replied:

So find somebody who can figure out why the corruption happens, and I'll be really happy with a patch that fixes it. In the meantime, "releaseable" very much means that we did _everything_ possible to make sure that people don't screw their disks over.

You have to realize that stability takes precedence over EVERYTHING.

Signature · 1 line
signature pending
#1 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Michael B. Allen

Hello,

What's the nature of the VIA chipset problems? I want to get a new system this weekend but I read on kernel traffic that VIA has problems? I wan't to use Hendrick's ide patches on 2.2.18. What board should I get? Help, I've searched through usenet and asked on #linux without anything conclusive.

There are no problems with 2.2.x. What motherboard you get depends on how much you want to spend and on what type of athlon cpu you want to get. K7-2
(classic), get the KA7 by abit. Duron and T-bird should get KT7 or
something like that . I'd use alan cox's latest patch. They work great.
Awesome performance. As good as linux gets.

Quoted 25 lines

Thanks,
Mike

Quoted 1 line

From KT:

David Riley [*] reported tremendous slowdowns in 2.4.1-pre11 and -pre12 on his Athlon 900 with a KT133 chipset. Mark Hahn [*] replied, "this is
known: Linus decreed that, since two people reported disk corruption on VIA, any machine with a VIA southbridge must boot in stupid 1992 mode (PIO). (yes, it might be possible to boot with ide=autodma or something, but who would guess?)" He added to Linus Torvalds [*], "I hope you don't consider this a releasable state! VIA now owns 40% of the chipset market..." Linus replied:

So find somebody who can figure out why the corruption happens, and I'll be really happy with a patch that fixes it. In the meantime, "releaseable" very much means that we did _everything_ possible to make sure that people don't screw their disks over.

You have to realize that stability takes precedence over EVERYTHING.

--
signature pending
-

#2 lore raw
In reply to Michael B. Allen
Quoted 3 lines · safemode
Quoted 1 line

What's the nature of the VIA chipset problems? I want to get a new system

There are no problems with 2.2.x.

I'm very glad to hear that because the AMD chips are the obvious choice for a lot of people(all?).

Quoted 7 lines

(classic), get the KA7 by abit. Duron and T-bird should get KT7 or
something like that . I'd use alan cox's latest patch.

From kernelnotes? Do you have a link so I'm sure?

They work great.
Awesome performance. As good as linux gets.

That sounds favorable :~)

Thanks,
Mike

Signature · 1 line
signature pending