Skip to contentSkip to conversation

2.4.1-ac UP-APIC updates

PATCH Mikael Pettersson 1 participant 1 message Feb 21, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Ingo Molnar

my major gripe right now is that we still have bug reports that say that systems hang when using nmi_watchdog=1 and work if nmi_watchdog=0. Changing the NMI watchdog to be 1 Hz will make these bugreports "Linux hangs once a week" instead of a "Linux hangs after 1-2 hours", which is clearly hiding things and making debugging harder.

All reports I've seen have been for SMP kernels on MP machines using the IO-APIC to drive the watchdog. Are you saying there are also cases where UP boxes fail with nmi_watchdog non-zero? (My 1Hz change only affected the local APIC-driven watchdog which MP boxes normally don't use.)

Quoted 3 lines

(and driving kernel-profiling from the NMI interrupt is a short-term patch, so there is just no point in going to 1 Hz right now just to go back to 100 Hz a few days later.)

Another "constructive" use of the perfctrs. Ok, this I can see wants a higher rate.

How far in the future is this? I'm concerned that the conflicting uses of the perfctrs (watchdog, kernel profiling, my perfctr driver for user-space performance measurements) is going to require some low-level request/release API.

Quoted 2 lines

the rest of the changes are excellent - it's only the 100 Hz NMI issue i have a problem with.

Ok.

Alan beat me to it for -ac20, so I'm not including a new patch now with the 1Hz bit backed out. Ingo, I guess this means the kernel profiling patch will have to "fix" the 1Hz thing by itself.

/Mikael