Skip to contentSkip to conversation

stabs or ecoff for Linux/mips

DISCUSSION H . J . Lu 4 participants 5 messages Jun 7, 2001 MIPS

lore
Share & tools
lore

H . J . Lu

author
#0 lore raw

What is the better debug format for Linux/mips in the terms of gdb and binutils, stabs or ecoff? I know the future is dwarf2. But I need something stable now. Since Linux/x86 uses stabs, I lean toward to stabs. Any comments?

H.J.

#1 lore raw

STABS definitely.

Quoted 8 lines · H . J . Lu

What is the better debug format for Linux/mips in the terms of gdb and binutils, stabs or ecoff? I know the future is dwarf2. But I need something stable now. Since Linux/x86 uses stabs, I lean toward to stabs. Any comments?

H.J.

#2 lore raw
In reply to H . J . Lu
Quoted 5 lines · H . J . Lu

What is the better debug format for Linux/mips in the terms of gdb and binutils, stabs or ecoff? I know the future is dwarf2. But I need something stable now. Since Linux/x86 uses stabs, I lean toward to stabs. Any comments?

Go with stabs and ELF. Neither ecoff's base file format nor the debug info were particularly well-documented (I remember some of the bits in GNU being figured out by reverse engineering!), perpetuating it will just make your life more difficult in the long run. It will also be easier to move to dwarf2 when the opportunity arises.

Stan

#3 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Stan Shebs
Quoted 5 lines · H . J . Lu

What is the better debug format for Linux/mips in the terms of gdb and binutils, stabs or ecoff? I know the future is dwarf2. But I need something stable now. Since Linux/x86 uses stabs, I lean toward to stabs. Any comments?

Quoted 5 lines

Go with stabs and ELF. Neither ecoff's base file format nor the debug info were particularly well-documented (I remember some of the bits in GNU being figured out by reverse engineering!), perpetuating it will just make your life more difficult in the long run. It will also be easier to move to dwarf2 when the opportunity arises.

mdebugread is also an evil piece of code.
It duplicates almost all of buildsym. I've had to perform *major* surgery (and am still not done yet) to do the block hash table thing.

Quoted 2 lines

Stan

Signature · 8 lines
"I looked out my apartment window, and I saw a bird wearing
sneakers and a button saying, "I ain't flying no where."  I
said, "What's your problem buddy?"  He said, "I'm sick of this
stuff -- winter here, summer there, winter here, summer there.
I don't know who thought this stuff up, but it certainly wasn't
a bird."  I said, "Well, I was just making breakfast, come on
in.  Want some eggs?  Sorry."
"-Steven Wright
author
#4 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Daniel Berlin
Quoted 7 lines · Stan Shebs
Quoted 5 lines · H . J . Lu

What is the better debug format for Linux/mips in the terms of gdb and binutils, stabs or ecoff? I know the future is dwarf2. But I need something stable now. Since Linux/x86 uses stabs, I lean toward to stabs. Any comments?

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Go with stabs and ELF. Neither ecoff's base file format nor the debug info were particularly well-documented (I remember some of the bits in GNU being figured out by reverse engineering!), perpetuating it will just make your life more difficult in the long run. It will also be easier to move to dwarf2 when the opportunity arises.

mdebugread is also an evil piece of code.

That matches my own experiences. In case you haven't noticed, I have checked in patches to switch Linux/mips to stabs in ELF :-).

H.J.