Preemption Latency Measurement Tool
Quoted 3 lines · safemode
ok. The preemption patch helps realtime applications in linux be a little more close to realtime. I understand that. But your mp3 player shouldn't need root permission or renicing or realtime priority flags to play mp3s.
It doesn't, it needs them to play with a dbench 32 running in the background. This isn't nessecarily acceptable, either, but it is a difference.
Note one thing the preemption patch does is really make `realtime' apps accel. Without it, regardless of the priority of the application, the app can be starved due to something in kernel mode. Now it can't, and since said application is high priority, it will get the CPU when it wants it.
This is not to say the preemption patch is no good if you don't run stuff at realtime -- I don't (who uses nice, anyhow? :>), and I notice a difference.
Quoted 10 lines
To
test how well the latency patches are working you should be running things all at the same priority. The main issue people are having with skipping mp3s is not in the decoding of the mp3 or in the retrieving of the file, it's in the playing in the soundcard. That's being affected by dbench flooding the system with irq requests. I'm inclined to believe it's irq requests because the _only_ time i have problems with mp3s (and i dont change priority
levels) is when A. i do a cdparanoia -Z -B "1-" or dbench 32. I bet if
someone did these tests on scsi hardware with the latency patch, they'd find much better results than us users of ide devices.
The skips are really big to be irq requests, although perhaps you are right in that the handling of the irq (we disable preemption during irq_off, of course, but also during bottom half execution) is the problem.
However, I am more inclined to believe it is something else. All these long held locks can indeed be the problem.
I am on an all UW2 SCSI system, and I have no major blips playing during a `dbench 16' (never ran 32). However, many other users (Dieter, I believe) are on a SCSI system too.
Quoted 5 lines
even i dont get any skips when i run the player at nice -n -20. That
doesn't tell you much about the preemption patch though. And it doesn't tell you about performance when you dont give linux the chance to do what it does,
multitask. That's where the latency patch is directed at improving, i
think.
Agreed.
Signature · 3 lines
Robert M. Love rml at ufl.edu rml at tech9.net