Exporting GPLONLY symbols (Please CC to my email address)
Umm....I'm a new poster here to the list, but, nonetheless, I have a small complaint about the track the kernel is taking with respect to kernel modules, specifically the exporting of symbols as GPLONLY. I understand that several hackers are pushing to export many symbols as GPLONLY, which I feel is a very bad idea. The NVidia drivers will no longer work, and any other module which depends on symbols which will eventually be exported as GPLONLY will also no longer work. Do you guys really want to restrict everyone to using modules licensed under the GPL? I've read and understand the GPL all too well, and came to the conclusion that it's a horrible license to begin with, given the simple fact that Stallman's communist views are in it, forcing everything licensed under it to be under every future license....with one change to the license, he can claim all source licensed under the GPL.
I agree with Cox that something has to be done to warn the average user that inserting closed source modules might cause something bad, and you guys can't do anything about it, but FORCING all modules to become GPL is the stupidest idea yet! Linux is starting to take the road of M$, forcing a one-licensed approach. Not cool guys.
Those are my thoughts.
Justin Hibbits
Quoted 6 lines · On Mon, Dec 10, 2001 at 10:41:56PM -0500, "Justin Hibbits…
Umm....I'm a new poster here to the list, but, nonetheless, I have a small complaint about the track the kernel is taking with respect to kernel modules, specifically the exporting of symbols as GPLONLY. I understand that several hackers are pushing to export many symbols as GPLONLY, which I feel is a very bad idea. The NVidia drivers will no longer work, and any other module which depends on symbols which will
The only thing that makes NVidia's drivers troublesome is that they are stupid enough not to open-source it. It's their problem though; they have to release fixed versions ever so often to keep up with the kernel. They won't have any problems with GPLONLY symbols, however, as none of the symbols they use are exported as GPLONLY.
Quoted 1 line
eventually be exported as GPLONLY will also no longer work. Do you guys
Linus specifically stated that no old symbols were to be reexported as GPLONLY; only new symbols would be eligible for this.
Quoted 2 lines
really want to restrict everyone to using modules licensed under the GPL? I've read and understand the GPL all too well, and came to the
Obviously you haven't.
Quoted 2 lines
conclusion that it's a horrible license to begin with, given the simple fact that Stallman's communist views are in it, forcing everything
Huh? I find nothing communist about the GPL. Rather, it goes along pretty well with my liberal views.
Quoted 2 lines
licensed under it to be under every future license....with one change to the license, he can claim all source licensed under the GPL.
No, it doesn't, and he can't. The existance of newer versions of the GPL does _NOT_ override the terms in code licensed with the older ones; you simply get the _choice_ of which version to choose. In the Linux-kernel, however, the default is that the v2 of the GPL is the only version valid, unless specifically stated.
Quoted 3 lines
I agree with Cox that something has to be done to warn the average user that inserting closed source modules might cause something bad, and you guys can't do anything about it, but FORCING all modules to become GPL
It doesn't.
Quoted 2 lines
is the stupidest idea yet! Linux is starting to take the road of M$, forcing a one-licensed approach. Not cool guys.
Yeah, it's very not cool to release free software, for free use, to no expense what-so-ever by you. Bitch all you like, but don't expect anyone to take you seriously. If you're so bloody upset, fire up $EDITOR and code your own kernel of choice.
/David
_ _
// David Weinehall <[email protected]> /> Northern lights wander \\
// Maintainer of the v2.0 kernel // Dance across the winter sky // \> http://www.acc.umu.se/~tao/ </ Full colour fire </
Quoted 14 lines · David Weinehall
Quoted 6 lines · On Mon, Dec 10, 2001 at 10:41:56PM -0500, "Justin Hibbits…
Umm....I'm a new poster here to the list, but, nonetheless, I have a small complaint about the track the kernel is taking with respect to kernel modules, specifically the exporting of symbols as GPLONLY. I understand that several hackers are pushing to export many symbols as GPLONLY, which I feel is a very bad idea. The NVidia drivers will no longer work, and any other module which depends on symbols which will
The only thing that makes NVidia's drivers troublesome is that they are stupid enough not to open-source it. It's their problem though; they have to release fixed versions ever so often to keep up with the kernel. They won't have any problems with GPLONLY symbols, however, as none of the symbols they use are exported as GPLONLY.
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
eventually be exported as GPLONLY will also no longer work. Do you guys
Linus specifically stated that no old symbols were to be reexported as GPLONLY; only new symbols would be eligible for this.
This looks like it could end up being a FAQ. Hence a new entry:
http://www.tux.org/lkml/#s1-23
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
really want to restrict everyone to using modules licensed under the GPL? I've read and understand the GPL all too well, and came to the
Obviously you haven't.
Quoted 2 lines
conclusion that it's a horrible license to begin with, given the simple fact that Stallman's communist views are in it, forcing everything
Are people still searching for reds under the bed? It's getting pretty hard to find a communist these days. I'm surprised and amused when I still hear people using this old term of vilification. Get with the times, dude! You're now supposed to use the terms "child molester", "child pornographer", and, to be really hip, "terrorist". What's the fun in using a term when it doesn't have the same emotional impact?
Quoted 2 lines
Huh? I find nothing communist about the GPL. Rather, it goes along pretty well with my liberal views.
Oh, stop being rational! It's so much less fun.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
licensed under it to be under every future license....with one change to the license, he can claim all source licensed under the GPL.
No, it doesn't, and he can't. The existance of newer versions of the GPL does _NOT_ override the terms in code licensed with the older ones; you simply get the _choice_ of which version to choose. In the Linux-kernel, however, the default is that the v2 of the GPL is the only version valid, unless specifically stated.
Indeed. This has been stated on a number of occasions.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
I agree with Cox that something has to be done to warn the average user that inserting closed source modules might cause something bad, and you guys can't do anything about it, but FORCING all modules to become GPL
It doesn't.
And this too has been discussed. I wish people would read the archives (or even the FAQ) before flaming. But why let facts stand in the way of a good flame^H^H^H^H^Htroll?
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
is the stupidest idea yet! Linux is starting to take the road of M$, forcing a one-licensed approach. Not cool guys.
Not that Linux is trying to shut out proprietary drivers, but if you believe in the right of a developer to distribute code under a restrictive proprietary licence, you'd be a hypocrite to suggest that developers shouldn't distribute under a strict GPL licence. Freedom of choice means that I get to do things that *I* want but *you* don't.
Or perhaps you just want freedom to control *my* choice?
Regards, Richard.... Permanent: [email protected] Current: [email protected]
Quoted 5 lines
eventually be exported as GPLONLY will also no longer work. Do you guys really want to restrict everyone to using modules licensed under the GPL? I've read and understand the GPL all too well, and came to the conclusion that it's a horrible license to begin with, given the simple fact that Stallman's communist views are in it, forcing everything
_---________---__________
| }
/ DO NOT FEED THE TROLL \
\____ __/
-------------------`
|#:|
|#:|
|#:|
\\\|#:|/ /
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~